Name_Not_Found

NameNotFound

back to bloglist

NameNotFound's column

Entries
27 October, 2009, 11:39
Hamid Karzai and the end of the love affair

Spring of love in late autumn

It was love at first sight: intense and passionate.

The strapping silver-haired man wearing exotic clothes, speaking halting English, won hearts, minds - and the purses of many a man and woman in the West.

Coming from nowhere (more precisely from the Popalzai clan of Afghan Pushtuns - but few of his most ardent foreign supporters had ever heard of Pushtuns, never mind Popalzai) the man became a fixture of international conferences, dialogs and colloquiums, as well as a darling of television news bosses.

Read more

Meet Hamid Karzai, leader of Afghanistan for the last 8 years.

His meteoric rise to stardom is next to none. Until November 2001, even journalists who covered the Afghan wars did not really know or consider him important.

When GWB decided that he would hurt the Taliban badly and swiftly, the CIA quickly went through their files of former anti-Soviet mujahedins who were on their payroll during the 80's.

The man named Hamid Karzai seemed a perfect match - an ethnic Pushtun from a powerful family with a few scores to settle with the Taliban.

Within days, Hamid was back inside his home country in the company of the US SF, or Special Forces soldiers, a tough and extremely capable lot.

The war was swift - the reeling mullahs decided not to push their luck against B-52s and B-1Bs, each of which cost more than the entire Taliban war chest.

The new rulers rolled into Kabul - amongst them a still relatively-unknown, but already ascending, Hamid Karzai.

His natural photogenic charms, coupled with the relentless pushing of the neocon White House did the trick - at the post-war Bonn Conference in December 2001, the man was presented as the "leader of the new Afghanistan"

The West was going ecstatic looking and listening to this man in traditional chapan and karakul hat.

"The IRC (International Rescue Committee) has bestowed its prestigious Freedom Award on President Hamid Karzai in recognition of his leadership and courage in helping Afghanistan and its people move toward peace and freedom..."

"....the Liberty Medal has always been awarded to world leaders of great courage, vision and faith in the future…President Karzai is working tirelessly and skillfully to unify his country’s diverse factions, strengthen its economy and move towards democratic values and practices."

"...Afghan President Hamid Karzai has been awarded an honorary knighthood by the Queen. The honor had been recommended by Prime Minister Tony Blair. The ceremony in the Oak Room, the Queen's private sitting room at Windsor Castle, was a mark of the esteem in which Mr Karzai is held by the British Government..."

The lone voice of animal rights campaigners complaining about Karzai's famous hat being made from aborted lamb fetuses was not heard.

"The process of producing karakul may seem brutal to outsiders, but it is part of Afghanistan's culture," a Karzai loyalist said in defense of his boss.

They should have listened already then to that bit about "Afghanistan culture", but those newly in love are deaf, are they not?

Why are things so bad?

During the next almost 8 years a very odd thing was happening.

Both Western leaders and the mainstream media refused to register or acknowledge the blatantly obvious...

...that Karzai's authority has never extended beyond a handful of Central Kabul blocks from where "suspicious" citizens were expunged. (His nickname from the start? "The president of Kabul")

...that the deeply religious and patriarchal population refuses to accept even the basic tenets of Western liberalism

...that, put simply, nothing large-scale is being built or developed except for a couple of fancy hotels in Kabul (attacked by Taliban) and the new road to Kandahar (several stretches of which are now controlled by the Taliban)

Yes, girls have returned to the university in Mazar-i-Sharif. Yes, the strategic cement factory in Pol-i-Khumri is churning out all important building materials. And yes, the world's highest long-tunnel at the Salang Pass has reopened. But what does all that have to do with Karzai or his Western backers, exactly?

The Salang, the lifeline of Afghanistan, that connects the Northern and Southern parts of the country, was built by the Soviets in the 1960's, blown up by the Northern Alliance being pursued by advancing Taliban back in 1996, and re-built jointly by the British HALO Trust and the Russian Emercom rescuers in December 2001, when the Taliban retreated.

Restored and handed over to the Afghans without much pomp, the tunnel works and makes the country remain one, rather than splitting into Pushtunistan down south and Uzbeko-Tajikistan up north (with a Hazarajat in between).

The Afghans never forget anything. They did not forget the Soviet bombs and the BMP fighting vehicles destroying their mud-brick houses.

But they also remember well who built the Salang Tunnel, who explored and developed the Sheberghan oil and gas fields, and who built the Mikrorayon district of Kabul that is the only semblance of modern housing project Kabul has - even up to this day.

Compare the Soviet bombers with F16s, A10s and B1Bs that rain the new generation of deadly metal from the skies.

Compare BMPs to US Army Strykers in the amount of damage done to those still mud brick houses.

But you won't find anything resembling the Salang Tunnel under construction. What you will find instead is hundreds of foreign advisers, project coordinators and trainers cramming the more upscale (read - with occasional electricity) quarters of Kabul. Most of them are well-meaning and enthusiastic people.

But their individual monthly compensation package is roughly equal to the yearly income of a whole Afghan mountain village.

Viscious cycle

So, you are a well meaning, modern man or woman from a "developed world".

You wish all those local people well.

You know that girls should not be married at the age of 14,

…and that paying money to a local official or doctor is called bribe and not a "gift".

You are convinced that keeping foreign humanitarian aid to distribute later to select friends and clansmen is totally wrong.

Now try and do something about it when, for the people around you, those are the generational rules of life, not crimes.

Sooner or later, you get upset.

Then you get very upset.

Finally, you get so upset that you call for close air support and some unknown to you Capt. Jackson, USAF, arrives to administer a deadly portion of retribution and punishment to all those terribly medieval thieving criminals and child molesters, shooting blazing arrows from the skies, invisible and unassailable

...killing a 14 year old "wife" and her newborn child in the process.

And in one stroke creating a hundred men with only one thing on their mind - revenge

Karzai, who knows his people well through the virtue of being one of them, tells the West to stop.

It won't listen. It seriously believes that those "even smarter" weapons will know how to distinguish between the innocent girls and their nasty old husbands.

Divorce

So, after billions of reconstruction money has been spent in Afghanistan, after more billions were spent on fighting elusive enemy, after hundreds of Western soldiers are dead or maimed, things are markedly worse in Afghanistan from the Western point of view.
The ranks of the Taliban are swelling, the population is hostile to foreigners, there is no sign of benevolent Western influence, unless you discount bootleg copies of Hollywood movies for sale on every corner of the bazaar.

There must be somebody to blame, right?

And the former darling Karzai becomes Mr. "corrupt government" Karzai.

Let's re-rack a few years, shall we?

When a disgruntled Afghan soldier raised his gun at Karzai in September 2002, the world breathed a collective sigh of relief upon learning that the great man survived.

A few veteran journalists in Kabul tried to question how a soldier firing a volley from his AK-47 from a distance of 10 feet (3 meters) could miss a static target, but the editors back in New York and London quickly quashed the untimely thoughts.

Similarly pooh-poohed was any questioning as to why American bodyguards killed the would-be murderer who had already been wrestled to the ground by an ordinary Afghan well-wisher who happened to be standing nearby. The heroic well-wisher died too. Obviously, the DynCorp guards want to see their enemies dead very-very quickly. Why? At the time, nobody wanted to dig into that story either.

There was no bigger news in the world that day and the next: Karzai Survives Assassination Attempt.

What would the world do without the charismatic, charming Afghan leader?

Seven years later, beleaguered and angry, the Afghan president is facing overwhelming pressure to admit that the elections were rigged, that he is to blame for all the failures, and that "change is needed".

Today, not-quite-Sir (he cannot use the title as he is a foreign national) President Hamid Karzai is in the midst of a most bitter divorce.

Divorce from his former admirers - and donors.

The worst part? The sides can't quite decide how they can live apart and who is to blame.

Both sides were full of illusions. The process of divorce is hurting.

It seems to be hurting the Afghan people the worst.

Show comments (1)
Bianca

28 October, 2009, 03:24

The best Afghanistan story yet! And the lessons? Soviets should have never built the tunnel separating Pashtunistan from the North. US should leave Karazi alone, and the "corruption" is just the way of doing business in Afghanistan. Everybody is practicing it, not just Karazi government. Once upon a time, working for UN in Yemen, I was one of those "shocked" at the notion that USAID merchandise was sold openly on the shelves of all stores. Boldly, accross little metal oil containers, is a red-white-and-blue flag, with the words printed over it: "Not to be sold or exchanged". In other words, the oil, sugar, flour and other staples were to be distributed to people. But they were instead given as a bribe, to be sold to merchants that then retailed them everywhere.

Every day, in shops, I would meet staff from USAID, UN Agencies and others. We would buy the same clearly imprinted containers and bags. Is it any different today? For starters, USAID knew exactly who received the goods, and knew exactly what will happen with them. And never complained about the neat little money making schema. It is because, whoever took over the goods from USAID took it under understanding that US interests were to be observed in return. It is simple, very simple.

The armies of coordinators, project managers and other "enthusiasts" actually know what is up, and only idiots waste their time on "corruption". Of course, until the "memo" is received to complain about corruption. The entire relationship of foreign presence --- on all levels --- is corrupt through and through.

Keep all that money here in US. No more "help", no more project managers and coordinators. No more paying for their rents, cars, gas, computers and daily expenses. While we are at it, withdraw all the armies of "do gooders" that infest all countries of this planet. Bring them all back to their cozy Western homes. US could save hundreds of billions by eliminating just these non military expenses. As there are over 800 bases worldwide, even a modest civilian expenditure in the country will add up to over 100 billion. And add to this the more intensive civilian infrastructure and the expenses for "aid" and the armies of NGO's, one can easily add another 500 billion. These are the moneys that those countries will not miss. This will reduce the corruption, as there will be no funds to grease the wheels of corruption. And we can return that money back to the US middle class, the only victim of this "recession". It is not a recession for Wall Street, and the sacred trust funds for the weathly have been saved. Now, their offspring will not have to worry about working for living --- they can count on getting income from their trusts, the day they are born. We the taxpayers have saved them from loosing the money they so greedily put in those fabulous financial instruments. We have paid up to keep those instruments, the "toxic assets" frozen and "valuable", with out future income. Our savings have gone down the drain. Our 401K will not help anyone to retire.

So, let us save the world from corruption. Let us bring our money, the root of all the corruption, back home. Along with the hundreds of thousands of "coordinators", "project managers" and other distributors of corrupt goods and cash. And the armies of human rights activists, teachers and journalists. And anyone who is there on taxpayers expense.

Then decide what to do with the armed forces. Before we give a dime about it, let us have everything else back, please!


post comment
14 October, 2009, 09:32
Alexander Vershbow, ridiculous cop
03 October, 2009, 18:03
Paul Joyal, hallucinating – mainstream media, helping
About author

He's called NameNotFound for a reason.

It's because he does not have a name.

Come to think of it, he does not have a physical body…

...therefore becoming non-eligible for gender denomination.

Oh, cut the c*@#!!!

NameNotFound is a collective op-ed page run by several veteran news reporters who, between themselves, have covered pretty much every big news story there’s been in the last twenty-something years - from the fall of the Berlin Wall to the Obama election.

It's edgy and a bit condescending, just like you would expect from news veterans.

But unlike many couch-potato theoreticians, NameNotFound have seen the world change with their own eyes - and are not shy about share their musings with you…