Chinese architects accused of plagiarizing Zaha Hadid's Soho project in Beijing

Published time: January 05, 2013 10:32
Edited time: January 05, 2013 14:33
This combo shows pictures a model of the Wangjing SOHO (left) building in Beijing, designed by architect Zaha Hadid, and a model of the Meiquan 22nd Century building (right) in China's southwest Chongqing on January 3, 2012. (AFP Photo)

Beijing architects have been accused of plagiarizing the creations of renowned British-Iraqi architect Zaha Hadid, who designed the Guangzhou Opera House in Guangdong Province two years ago, becoming a household name in China.

­Hadid's latest project currently under construction in Beijing, known as 'Wangjing Soho,' has already become so eye-catching that pirate architects on the Island of Chongqing are allegedly busy copying it, Der Spiegel reported. The apparently plagiarized project may even be completed before Hadid's original.

According to Hadid's website, Wangjing Soho is an office and retail complex that is a "welcome and farewell to Beijing." It consists of three asymmetrical towers conceived to establish a "vibrant, dynamic presence on the Beijing skyline."

Image from http://www.zaha-hadid.com
Image from http://www.zaha-hadid.com

­Hadid's project is set for completion in 2014. However, she may now have to race against time to complete Wangjing Soho before her imitators.

While Hadid's design features three towers, the copycat version reportedly has two, also constructed in an asymmetrical and futuristic style.

The developer of the Chongqing project, Meiquan 22nd Century, has denied accusations of plagiarism.

This picture shows the Meiquan 22nd Century building in China′s southwest Chongqing on January 3, 2012. (AFP Photo)
This picture shows the Meiquan 22nd Century building in China's southwest Chongqing on January 3, 2012. (AFP Photo)

­The project director for the Beijing complex, Satoshi Ohashi of Zaha Hadid Architects, told Der Speigel Online that "it is possible that the Chongqing pirates got hold of some digital files or renderings of the project."

Comments (13)

Concepts belong to mankind. Engineering belongs to whoever did it. (unregistered) 10.01.2013 06:02

The ancient Romans copied the ancient Greeks. The Renaissance It alians copied the ancient Romans. The British & French copied and re-interpreted the Italians. Renaissan ce Italian architect Palladio was one of the most copied architects in Great Britain. Thomas Jefferson's famous home 'Monticello' was directly copied from a Palladian design.

Ameri can mid-century modernist architects were heavily influenced by German architects. German modernism (Bauhaus)was directly copied from the Soviet Russian Constructivist  architectural movement. 

I deas circulate and are re-interpreted throughout history. 

Fr ank Lloyd Wright re-interpreted (copied) the  minimalism and clean horizontal lines of Japanese architecture that fit into the landscape totally unlike the obnoxious Victorian mansions of his day.The BIG difference between Frank Lloyd Wright & Zaha Hadid is that F.L.W. engineered all his buildings and designed every last structural detail. Zaha Hadid is purely conceptual & does none of her own engineering. 

Many Western architects simply provide concepts to the Chinese and allow the Chinese to totally engineer the projects. As a result, the Chinese are in possession of all the working drawings required to construct these buildings. To me this is unclear whose intellectual property this is although one could make a case that the Chinese do all the work necessary to make these buildings viable..

0

Undo

Gregg Lynn (unregistered) 08.01.2013 05:09

And just to emphasize my point. While two square buildings are not necessaily the same, in this case the Chinese have clearly copied Zaha Hadid. Just like they did with the Apple store.

0

Undo

Greg Lynn (unregistered) 06.01.2013 18:29

Zaha Hadid Ripped Off the same design from londons gerkin building (unregistered) wrote in #10
like most corrupt people she accuses others of her own guilt. She only became famous after a massive bbc publicity campaign. She has very little experience in architecture before she was hyped by marketing experts. -------- -------------------- -------------------- -------------------
The gherkin is composed of a triangulated structure and curtain wall skin. It's proportions are situated vertically. In case you don't know how to count, also, the gherkin is one skyscraper. 
Zah a's buildings are oriented horizontally and vertically both in proportion and circulation. The structural system is primarily concrete. The complex of buildings also connect via skywalks and utilize parametrics to smooth surfaces and connections. She was the first to attempt such things computationally (Saarinen did it by hand). You might also be familiar with Jean Nouvel's tower in Spain, which really is more similar to the Gherkin.  You might also know that Zaha's work is very different from and edgier than Foster, just look at the Phaeno, vitra, et al. If two buildings are square they are not necessarily the same thing.
BTW Ottoman, the chinese did not invent pizza, they made green onion pancakes which were like sandwiches. Marco Polo could have thought of pizza without the chinese. The pizza he invented was very different from what the chinese made.

+1

Undo

View all comments (13)
Add comment

By posting your comment, you agree to abide by our Posting rules

Log in to comment in full, or comment anonymously under character-limit restriction.

100 Text

– required fields

Register or

Name

Password

Show password

Register

or Register

Request a new password

Send

or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:

or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile

Name

New password

Retype new password

Current password

Save

Cancel

Follow us