VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД
breakingnews
Go to main page   Art & culture   News   Court passes guilty verdict in Russian art vs. religion case  
MORE ON THE STORY
05.02.2010, 14:02 28 comments

Satanic rapists on trial

Two young people are being tried in Russia for organizing a Satan-worshiping sect. Their adepts were subjected to abuse during gatherings, while some girls, including those below the age of consent, were molested.

21.10.2010, 07:28 3 comments

Un-convent-ional treatment

Allegations of child abuse in a convent school in central Russia: pupils are said to have been suffering from harsh treatment.

The chapel built by fake priests 16.03.2010, 12:54 1 comment

Fake priest gang busted

A group of people who posed as Russian Orthodox priests and performed fake holy rituals for money has been arrested in St. Petersburg.

Grigory Grabovoy (Ria Novosti / Alexey Panov) 07.05.2010, 21:32

Charlatan healer to stay in prison

Self-proclaimed Russian healer Grigory Grabovoy, who was sentenced to 11 years in prison for fraud in 2008, has been refused early release on parole.

05.10.2010, 13:59

Jail-dodging “sex guru” arrested

The leader of a notorious quasi-religious cult, suspected of recruiting thousands of people and turning them into voluntary sex slaves, has been arrested in Russia. The man has evaded prosecution several times before.

15.01.2010, 13:17 15 comments

Terrorists trained in Georgia to attack Russia – official

Terrorist groups are being trained in Georgia to launch attacks in Russia’s North Caucasian and southern regions, Russia's Deputy Interior Minister Arkady Yedelev said.

US, New York: City Firefighters place family photos and flowers at a makeshift memorial 28 October, 2001, on the rubble of ground zero after the World Trade Center Family Memorial Service in New York. Several thousand people attended the interfaith service near ground zero of the 11 September terrorist attack. (AFP Photo / Stan Honda) 11.09.2010, 09:13 10 comments

Nine years on, 9/11 jury is still out

On the ninth anniversary of the worst terror attacks to strike the US mainland, many questions remain unanswered, not least of all concerning the true identities of the perpetrators.

23.07.2010, 16:16 5 comments

Scientologists prosecuted in Russia for hatemongering

A branch of the Church of Scientology in Russia has been accused of inciting hatred and humiliating human dignity.

02.07.2009, 18:02 6 comments

Children in Nigeria branded witches and abused

In Akwa Ibom, a Nigerian state with an alleged concentration of child witches, life’s misfortunes are often diagnosed as sorcery. As a result, children suffer abuse, abandonment or worse.

27.07.2010, 17:46 21 comments

US “sparked Russian spy sensation” in wake of WikiLeaks broadside

In an effort to distract attention from the release of thousands of secret documents on the Afghanistan War, the US rounded up 11 Russian “spies” according to internal sources.

Court passes guilty verdict in Russian art vs. religion case

Published: 12 July, 2010, 09:28
Edited: 29 July, 2010, 18:06

(8.3Mb) embed video

TAGS: Art, Crime, Religion, Scandal, Russia


On Monday a court in Moscow delivered its guilty verdict to the organizers of the Forbidden Art exhibition, who were facing charges of inciting religious hatred by putting controversial pictures on public display.

Yury Samodurov, the ex-director of the museum where the exhibition took place, and Andrey Erofeev, the former Head of the Tretyakov Gallery’s modern trends department, were fined about $6500 and $5000 respectively. The Prosecutor’s Office was seeking a three year prison sentence for both defendants for exhibiting “images which are derogatory and insulting to Christianity and religious people.”

Samodurov has been convicted of similar charges before. In March, 2005, the court ordered him to pay a fine of approximately $3500.

On Tuesday the defense appealed to a higher court to have the sentence overturned, advisor Ksenia Kostromina told the media.

The exhibition "Forbidden Art – 2006" was shown in 2007 and displayed pictures previously banned from other Moscow galleries. The works showed religious images and symbols combined with everyday, popular culture objects. Among other controversial things, the visitors could see Jesus Christ with the head of Mickey Mouse, and a Muslim Marilyn Monroe. Some exhibits contained abusive language.

The trial caused controversy in society.

The church community was not unanimous about the sentence, but did not doubt the fact that the defendants are guilty.

“It was not the Church that initiated this prosecution, but people who were offended. The investigation proved that the art pieces at this exhibit were offensive towards believers and incited religious hatred to an extent,” says Father Georgy Roshin.

 Artists and humans rights activists – as well as the directors of the Tretyakov Gallery and the State Center of Modern Art – were protesting against the trial, saying the trial is not about art, rather about politics, censorship and a curb on the freedom of expression.

“I think that neither artists, nor curators, nor art in general should be punished under criminal law. Often people see in pictures something that the artist did not have in mind at all. Time also matters, and the next generation will not understand at all what the conflict was about,” said director general of the Tretyakov Gallery Irina Lebedeva in her interview to news agency Interfax. She pointed out that she herself had professional disputes with Erofeev, but noted that a creative person cannot be strictly controlled.

“I think that this trial was premeditated. It was staged, and those believers who took part in it in fact never saw these pieces of art before,” says Aleksandr, an artist and a protestor. “Most likely it is an attempt to apply censorship to art and to once again create a tense and hostile environment in the social and cultural sphere. Art is a field where things are allowed. Experiments are going on in museums, in restricted areas. It doesn’t harm the public. If anyone disagrees, they are free not to watch, or give a verbal or any other kind of response,” he added.

On Monday the court room was not the only scene of events. According to media reports, those protesting against the trial brought a shoebox full of giant cockroaches and let them creep into the building while opponents of controversial exhibition were chanting religious songs outside the court.

However, journalist and writer Dmitry Bykov says the fine handed down to the organizers is fair.

“I’m quite sure that this decision is really modest and really honest, because it could be much worse – the orthodox fundamentalists are really very dangerous. They insisted on real punishment connected with imprisonment,” he emphasized.

Watch the full interview with Dmitry Bykov

downloadembed

+6 (6 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
11.07.2010, 16:07

Avignon Theatre Festival opens Chekhov exhibition

The Avignon Theatre Festival is paying tribute to the great Russian writer Anton Chekhov by opening a major exhibition in his honor.

RIA Novosti 15.07.2010, 21:54

Fire at Moscow art center kills two, damages artifacts

A large fire at an art restoration centre in central Moscow has killed two firefighters and damaged a large collection of paintings and icons.

Citizen 0 July 14, 2010, 18:51
0

So much for freedom of speech and freedom of expression! Usually, only countries with some kind of unstabile religious/ethnic population, or those with goverment seeking complete control over "moral values" inact laws and pass judgements that would otherwise be null and void in other countries, and Russia is no exception. a-la Homeland Security-type monitoring of all communications, laws prohibiting freedom of speech, historical revisionism, laws enforcing gag-policies even on message board and comment areas (thats why comments on RT are pre-screened)... wayt, they may have forgotten RFID`ng its population and installing at least as many cameras as they have in London, but hey - it`s a developing economy, not all can be done at once! Big players from times far in the past, now with a nice suit and a pr-managed message. Passing themselves as "civil" and "democratic"...

Rikard July 13, 2010, 15:03
0

Suppose we add some more artistic expressions, for instance red or yellow star stuffed up with swastika, and we call it art…what would the verdict be? To further simplify: the people and their expressive part society have vacancy in the sane structure of normal life. If anyone wants to move as the part of the people-and-society – he or she have enough place in the very vacancy. So they can lift their banners, believes or mark their identities. But, why to misuse this vacancy or sane permeability of any state, lifting artistic banners against those harboring identity in Christianity or any other religion? Harboring consciously, unconsciously, traditionally and emotionally. The government or judiciary system can’t comfortably identify with anyone’s art that is ridiculing him or her. It is even not satiric. It is building up the political field for further exploitation and demands intervention against blunt proselytism, being no art at all. Stalin already modernized Russia removing one traditional regulator but in spite anchored Russia as the permanent historic target for western political fluid aggressively coagulating on Russian soil. Are we now back to the re-modernization turn?

Babeouf July 13, 2010, 00:29
0

Well this story allows many in Western Europe to feel smug. While a majority of American's might go to church regularly. In England its less than ten percent of the population. And still declining. And across much of Europe religion is identified with obscurantist nonsense marketed for people who find science intellectually challenging. And here the the parables of Christianity have same force as the Greek myths. On the other hand the political repression involved allows an association to be made with the developments in other regions and religions. Islam in Pakistan and Afghanistan for instance. During the chaos of the 1990's in Russia the Russian Church may have provided some service in maintaining national integrity. But if the aim of the Russian elites is the transformation and modernization of Russia then reactionary iconography makes a bad template.