Breaking news

UK govt confirms Woolwich murder victim member of the armed forces - media

ACTA in UK: 10 years in jail for 'illegal downloads'

March 03, 2012 10:24

UK web surfers have caught a grim glimpse of the future with Internet users being threatened with 10 years in jail for “illegal downloading” after a prominent music file-sharing site was shut down shortly after Britain signed the notorious ACTA bill.

View full story

Comments (31) Sort by: highest rating oldest first newest first

Marconi 08.03.2012 00:28

Talking of copyright, Imagine what progress we would not have had in the world if such common everyday items as the housebrick, shoes and the wheel had been copyrighted. I bet TPTB would love to have had a revenue stream coming in from all those things...

+9

Undo

toini 05.03.2012 11:03

sharing files to millions of people by uploading to the internet against the wishes of the creators of their art is illegal ... they create and they need to get paid like anyone else.  

0

Undo

carla (unregistered) 04.03.2012 20:26

We need to fight back in the way the internet can fight back in these cases.

Every U.K. politician needs to have their home addresses and personal information revealed with all their family's information.  A downloader sentenced to 10 years in jail will certainly have his children's lives profoundly disrupted.  Why shouldn't the politicians who enslaved their fellow citizens receive double this same treatment?

Oh by the way, undobtedly their was some payoff or inducement for politicans to sell out their fellow countrymen to these tyrannical corporations.  Let's get busy identifying and disrupting everly single one of these politicians - in 3 times the way they intended to imprison us.

Their horrible attacks on us WILL CONTINUE, until they are afraid to bully us again.

+42

Undo

Mr. Hand 04.03.2012 14:43

People who go into the field of art to fund their lifestyle generally do not do it for the money.  There is some intrinsic value in the art itself.  & nbsp; If I buy art from a street vendor, I pay the artists directly for the work.   The artist is free to charge what they want and I am free to buy it or move on.  But with music, there is an entire industry of extremely high paid managers, presidents and vice presidents, mostly all non-value adding entities (to the music anyway).    To buy musical art under today's structure I am forced to fund a whole side industry of hangers on that do little or nothing to further the music.   I cannot choose to reimburse the artist for their music, I must fund the industry first.  Copyright laws are there to protect the artist, as they should be.  But to demand that I fund the industry of hangers on that spring up around and feed off the artist is somewhat irritable.  The facts are many people cannot afford to fund the lifestyles of so many ultra rich people at the price of .99 a song or more so they download the music and don't pay for it.     This law protects mostly the industry, not the artist.  & nbsp;So remember before you buy, is it worth funding a side industry willing to throw someone in prision for 10 years for downloading one song?  Are these the kind of people you want to freely give your money to?  10 years of prision at 50K pounds per year is a half million pound cost of incarceration.    For one song?   Wow, it better be a really good song.

+52

Undo

John Alexander 04.03.2012 14:42

The only people that are in any way having their interests protected by this act are those who exploit the creative people that produce the music or art, namely the corporations and their "banksters." I work in engineering design and my small company does a lot of RD work we had a large corporation ask to use one of our developments and when we asked them to contribute to the cost we were politely told to f@%k off as they already owned the patent. Thats how it goes!

+13

Undo

LOL 04.03.2012 14:04

Ok, lets do like this. You lower the house pricing by half, and pay my wage to a private company in my name so that I only pay 20% tax in the UK. Then,maybe I will afford to buy original stuff.

+9

Undo

CON 04.03.2012 09:45

This site is cool but wrote in #5
what I wonder is how long Hong Kong is going to let Press TV in their country pushing the Islamic agenda?  Now you have protesters in China.  Press TV quit letting you have Freedom of speach. RE ABOVE: Presstv, the 'voice of the voiceless'. One of the few stations with an alternative view. That's why it's deemed too dangerous in the UK., people might start hearing an alternative message than that spewed out by the corporate media. A move that almost certainly guaranteed increased viewing figures through other means. It's got nothing to do with an 'Islamist agenda', as you put it, it's all about getting away from mainstream garbage.

+5

Undo

This site is cool but 04.03.2012 07:16

what I wonder is how long Hong Kong is going to let Press TV in their country pushing the Islamic agenda?  Now you have protesters in China.  Press TV quit letting you have Freedom of speach.

0

Undo

bluetoo 04.03.2012 06:42

Funny how they can call sharing stealing. Copyright can't be claimed if copies are being shared noncommerically. But the masters of the universe want to own everything, even dna.

Invading people's countries and taking their resources, is that sharing in their upside down world?

+14

Undo

tides 04.03.2012 03:21

It's funny to hear people justifying stealing. lol Oh, but it's not stealing, it is helping the artist become popular. lmao

But 10 years is ridiculous and the UK and US governments are hardly in a position to be preaching morality to anyone.

+1

Undo

Vellach Samie 04.03.2012 01:59

if copyright is given only to the artist, i can fully support it. but such "information" is now used by a group of useless people calling themselves music company. they are same as pimps selling other peoples' talents. i cannot understand their "rights". someo ne downloading something from web is same as someone looking at other man's wife. can you regulate that? 

+7

Undo

Add comment

By posting your comment, you agree to abide by our Posting rules

Log in to comment in full, or comment anonymously under character-limit restriction.

100 Text

– required fields

Register or

Name

Password

Show password

Register

or Register

Request a new password

Send

or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:

or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile

Name

New password

Retype new password

Current password

Save

Cancel

Follow us