''Children cannot get heart transplants in Russia''
Published: 13 May, 2009, 09:39
Russian law says that a person can become a donor only if their brain death is ascertained according to accepted medical criteria, but it also says those criteria cannot be applied to minors.










It is a tragedy, to see a child in suffering, or at worst passing away, when techniques exist to save them. We would all love, for them to get better. However, we need be careful here. In the west, there has been a rush to extract organs, either for profit, or as a result of playing God, in deciding that the recipients life is of more worth than the donor. We don't want to go down this path in Russia. In terms of profit, we all know, we have a huge issue with corruption. Without stern controls, this would turn us into body snatchers. We therefore need absolute, strongly policed protocols, driving all that can be done, to save the potential donors life, without any regard to a recipents condition. The standard needs to be absolute, with strong criminal sanction, for breach. Only when the donor child dies naturally, should the recipient, based on parental consent be allowed to receive the donors organ. This does have an affect on the availability of organs, there is no doubt about it, however, we need be absolute here. Being absolute, will nulify any notion of becoming God and also stamp on corruptive forces. It will leave a problem, but this problem should be seen as a force, driving innovation to create transplant alternatives. This is an opportunity for Russia. Just going down the slippery slope to playing God is not the answer, for any dying child, We are not God, so leave it at that. But we are people, who can overcome problems in the correct way, without always taking the easy way out through liberal relativism.