DNA confirms Tsar’s family remains
Published: 17 July, 2008, 00:55
DNA results have confirmed that remains found near Ekaterinburg a year ago belong to Prince Aleksey and Grand Duchess Maria Nikolayevna of the Romanov family. The announcement comes on the 90th anniversary of the execution of Tsar Nicholas II and his fami
On Wednesday, church services are being held across Russia to remember the tragic event.
The last Tsar of Russia and his family were shot in the early hours of July 17 1918, less than two years after the abdication of Nicholas II, in the Urals city of Ekaterinburg.
Prince Aleksey
The bodies of the Royal Family were stripped and burned. After a failed attempt to conceal them in a mineshaft, they were taken to a nearby field, drenched in acid and buried.
“This was one of the greatest crimes in the history of humanity. This was not just an attempt to kill a family, but destroy Russia itself, and Russia paid the price with its subsequent history, because the Bolsheviks had acted without legitimacy,” said historian Pyotr Multatuli.
This is the most common account of the death of Nicholas II and his wife and five children. But many facts in this story are contested.
The death of the Royal Family was the start of a 90-year mystery that has spawned hundreds of alleged survivors – only in Europe 147 people claimed to be survived ‘children’ of Nicholas II. There were dozens of archaeological digs and many theories, some well researched, others wildly speculative.
Within a year after the death, those claiming to be the slain Tsar's children cropped up. The most famous is Anna Anderson, who spent her life in a legal battle to prove she was in fact Princess Anastasia.
The Soviet authorities covered up the executioners accounts. The house where the family was killed was pulled down.
Grand Duchess Maria
Amateur archaeologist and historian Aleksandr Avdonin, who’s been piecing together information with his team, claims they recovered the bodies of Nicholas II and others in 1979. But they would be arrested if anyone found out, and they then reburied them.
When the USSR collapsed in 1991, the team returned to the site, and this time the remains were submitted for DNA testing. While most experts said the bones belong to the royals, the Russian Orthodox Church and many historians remained unconvinced.
A year ago further remains supposedly belonging to Crown Prince Aleksey and his sister were recovered just yards from the first site. But the now solved mystery of their authenticity is not the most important thing.
“We must recognise and accept what happened here. And the Russian authorities must make every effort to condemn this slaughter, if it sees itself not just as the heir to the USSR, but to the regimes before it,” believes Petr Multatuli.
17.07.2008, 00:34
Obama commits to eliminating nuclear weaponsDemocratic presidential candidate Barack Obama has said that eliminating nuclear weapons is central to his vision of U.S. nuclear policy. |
17.07.2008, 01:38
Ukraine bans Russian TV over NATO coverageUkraine has reportedly banned broadcasting by Russian and pro-Russian TV channels in the port cities of Odessa and Yuzhny on the Black Sea coast. |
1. If missing bodies have been found, what of reports that the russians were searching for a missing princess prior to the killings at Ipatiev House. 2. The Russian authorities have had plenty of time to re-arrange the bones and contaminate with DNA prior to the recent mtDNA analyses. 3. The 'crime-scene' was not secured, can the scientists confirm that the bone fragments were recovered as claimed
Why hasn't Queen Elizabeth and Prince Phillip made any comment about the tragedy that befell their extended family? Is it because they are afraid their reign might go the same route and be destroyed? Is that why their relatives disinvited Tsar Nicolas and his family when they tried to flee after he abdicated? Recently, The Sovereign wore a tiara from the Russian family. Very interesting.
The Bolsheviks disseminated false information that they were searching for escaped members of the Tsar's family (AFTER the murder of the Imperial Family at the Ipatiev House in Ekaterinburg) so as to confuse investigators from the White Russian Army who were (after the town fell to their forces) trying to find out exactly what had happened to the Tsar and his family. Equally, the information referred to by Rax may in fact relate to the murder of other members of the Imperial Family at Alaepavesk. The British Royal Family has always been extremely sensitive about the fate of their Russian relatives because it was the Tsar's cousin King George V who persuaded his government to withdraw its offer of political asylum for the Tsar and his family. This was in 1917 and the king feared that his own position would be compromised if the Tsar and his family came to England. However, following the murders at Alaepavesk and Ekaterinburg, George V was subsequently instrumental in arranging the successful evacuation by the Royal Navy of numerous members of the Russian Imperial Family from their Crimean estates in 1919 as the White Armies withdrew southwards. There are numerous books about the Russian Imperial Family - I have about thirty. The easiest to follow is still Robert K. Massie's "Nicholas and Alexandra. Jonathan