Keep up with the news by installing RT’s extension for . Never miss a story with this clean and simple app that delivers the latest headlines to you.

 

Webcam vote monitoring could crash Russian internet

Published time: December 20, 2011 17:43
Edited time: December 20, 2011 21:43
Web camera
Download video (28.19 MB)
Embed

Extra election monitoring – with the help of modern technology – could cost Russia a fortune, let alone crash Internet providers around the country, IT specialists say.

The idea to equip every polling station in Russia with constantly-streaming webcams was recently suggested by PM Vladimir Putin as a response to opposition allegations that November's parliamentary elections were rigged. The move, Putin believes, would make elections transparent for everyone.

But progressive as it may be, the initiative sparked criticism among the country’s IT specialists, who say it may eventually turn into a billion-ruble squander.

For Russia’s 94,000 polling stations, no less than 300,000 web cameras would be in place, in addition to powerful server stations and Internet links. Local manufacturers would be unable to produce such an amount of equipment – in either cameras or computers, said deputy head of the Communications Ministry, Ilya Massukh.

The project also requires Internet capacities Russia simply does not have.

“Even if we have all the polling stations equipped with Internet links, we will still need to increase speed in the whole segment,” senior vice president of communications provider Rostelecom, Baagn Martirosyan, told RIA-Novosti.

And such an increase could easily shut the Russian Internet down, Massukh believes.

“Russia’s main Internet channels, on average, are 70 Gigabytes per second, while the new project requires 100 Gigabytes per second,” he said.

Another question is how to protect the new system from hacker attack. The website webvybory2012.ru, registered for the forthcoming presidential elections, has already been shut down by an intense direct denial of service attack.

And the most curious issue is the money allocated for the project. Instead of launching a public tender, which could divide the task between several Russian companies, the government has reportedly decided to work “with a single source,” according to the director general of Intellectual Data Analysis, Ivan Begtin. It means that massive amounts of funds – to the tune of $500 million allocated for the cause – could disappear, unaccounted for.

Comments (2)

9ke9 28.12.2011 10:10

Yeah  Yeong I'm surprised at how quickly and negatively and so narrow minded these so called "IT Specialists" became.
not to criticize of course.

- Record on location to a small central server or hard disk server.

- Record only voters hands and ballots it is anon that way , yet all can see, also this keeps res down to 640x480 or 360x280.

- cut the whole day into time stamped sections - so that playback is only a few minutes long

- serve it all over the world (note the literal zero cost here) , there is nothing to hide, let people be as famous as they want to be with what they write or draw on their ballot.

- encourage people to write a message on their ballot to unique identify it.

and finally yeah elections cost money,  fair ones anyhow, the money is well spent and not at all wasted, I'm sure it cost next to nothing to just make the votes up , you know like they do in other countries.


Cheers Yeong.

0

Undo

Yeong Jeog Mugi 28.12.2011 01:49

Instead of monitoring the elections directly you could monitor them in sealed, recorded closed circuit with direct monitoring at only key places and positions.

Al l the entire process would still be monitored by this method would not crash the system.

0

Undo

Add comment

By posting your comment, you agree to abide by our Posting rules

Log in to comment in full, or comment anonymously under character-limit restriction.

100 Text

– required fields

Register or

Name

Password

Show password

Register

or Register

Request a new password

Send

or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:

or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile

Name

New password

Retype new password

Current password

Save

Cancel

Follow us