Russian Patriarch goes green, tells America to curb its “reckless consumption”

Published time: July 31, 2009 04:00
Edited time: July 26, 2010 05:17
AFP Photo / Mustafa Ozer

Patriarch of Moscow and All Russia Kirill expressed concern about the state of the environment, as well as mankind’s collective soul, saying the economic crisis has lessons to teach us.

The latest contributor to the ongoing verbal feud between the United States and Russia came from unusual quarters as the Patriarch of the Russian Orthodox Church took a swipe at the United States for its “reckless consumption.”

“If society embarks on the road of such recklessness consumption, our earth will go under,” Kirill told an audience of students and lecturers at the Kiev Theological Academy. “It has already been proven that if the average level of consumption of the whole world matches that of the United States… the basic resources will run out in 40 to 50 years.”

“God has not given us resources to live like this,” he warned.

It seems the Russian Orthodox leader has done his homework.

Professor Jared Diamond from UCLA has demonstrated in a recent article that the Western world is using up resources 32 times faster than in the developing countries.

“The average rates at which people consume resources like oils and metals,” Diamond argues, “and produce wastes like plastics and greenhouse gases, are about 32 times higher in North America, Western Europe, Japan and Australia than they are in the developing world.”

Diamond’s conclusion may not be exactly what the economists and developers want to hear, but it correlates with what Patriarch Kirill said: “Whether we get there willingly or not, we will soon have lower consumption rates because our present rates are unsustainable.”

Patriarch Kirill’s comments show a marked tendency for religious leaders to speak out about the environmental problems now facing the planet. Earlier this month, Pope Benedict XVI warned an audience in Sydney, Australia about the evils associated with “insatiable consumption.”

“Reluctantly we come to acknowledge that there are… scars which mark the surface of our earth… in order to fuel an insatiable consumption,” Benedict warned.

No need to live in a cave

Patriarch Kirill then provided his personal insights on the present economic crisis that would never be heard in a school of economics.

“In this sense, the crisis may teach us much – restraint and rational use of our financial opportunities,” he said. “The most important thing is to learn Christian asceticism.”

But Russia’s top hierarch was quick to point out that practicing asceticism did not necessarily imply living the life of a hermit.

This does not mean “life in a cave or permanent fasting,” the Patriarch explained. “It’s the ability to regulate one’s consumption and the condition of one’s heart, and win a victory over passions and instincts. It is important that the rich and the poor alike possess these qualities.”

The Patriarch then expressed concern that members of the eastern Orthodox societies were being exposed to degenerating “western system of values.”

“The trinkets of modern life make one giddy, and inebriate the human consciousness,” Kirill said. “People believe in advertisement, fashion, stereotypes, and this virtual world as if it were reality.”

The Russian Orthodox leader also blasted same-sex marriages, a new social-political phenomenon occurring in the West that has sparked uproar of debate on both sides of the sensitive issue.

“Until recently, nobody could even have thought that same-sex marriages would receive legislative support and would be put on par with natural marriages,” he said. “In Liberalism, every person is autonomous, both from God and from other people. He creates his own system of values and this ultimately leads him to losing his inner control.”

In the United States, same-sex marriages have been legalized in 6 of the 50 states, whereas the Russian capital refuses to permit gay rights activists from organizing parades along its straight streets.

Despite the heavy criticism leveled against western lifestyles, Kirill held out hope on the possibility for an East-West dialogue, but the dialogue should not be between a “horse and rider” but rather between equal partners.

“Holy Russia is a huge civilizational project,” the Russian Orthodox leader said. “It is not meant to be guided, but it must generate ideas, and offer the choice of an outlook to which others must answer.”

Robert Bridge, RT

Comments (11)

Mykhayl 25.07.2010 23:27

Remind His Beatitude that the US is no longer his canonical territory. Or was he speaking for the KGB?

0

Undo

Sarah 23.01.2010 17:24

It won't end until there's blood. We're going to become more and more competitive with greater class divides and then eat ourselves because if one is tainted then they all are to a degree. There has to be balance within a society. There are some serious stress reactions going on our end and do to the number of explosions in Russia, I'd say the same. I go back and forth on the issue. Some days I think that it would be better if we all went back to living in huts with nice libraries but the status symbols in our society prevent this from happening because if one has something superior then they are, and they probably are but they won't always be... Then I think that the few who have temples (or whatever) will just collect the martyrs and use them for ill agendas, like in the Middle East. Every group has certain awarenesses but the giants look more perfect and are generally more stable because you get lines after a time and friend clusters but if there's too much inbalance, it's bad because humans seek to conquer. It's normal, but it doesn't have to translate into a nightmare. It's a variable in systems. Product of is? I'm angry right now because everybody is responsible for what a few do, and it'll always come back to me, so that makes me have to fight for survival, that I don't want but do by instinct, instead of work for a purpose. There are no clear lines to anything. We're told we're all equal? I don't think so. Equally human, yes, and that's probably the problem. I rely on the Patriarch to create safety switches to prevent disaster. Russia is the same, going down the same path, and it's annoying. Don't try to blame us. All humans take whatever they can, use and destroy. Look at what the oil is doing to the Native peoples. At the end of the day, there are too many people on Earth. I say everyone make it really bad so that we see the light. The enlightened among us go on a mountain side and just wait. I'm real simple, but this is never allowed.

0

Undo

George Patsourakos 04.08.2009 16:20

The Russian Patriarch is correct in telling America that it must curb its "reckless consumption." Americans tend to overbuy or buy items they do not even need. Until the current economic slump - the worst one since the Great Depression - many Americans would spend more money on their credit cards than they made each month. Hopefully, this recession will have a positive impact on our economy; namely, it will have taught Americans to be more frugal.

0

Undo

View all comments (11)
Add comment

By posting your comment, you agree to abide by our Posting rules

Log in to comment in full, or comment anonymously under character-limit restriction.

100 Text

– required fields

Register or

Name

Password

Show password

Register

or Register

Request a new password

Send

or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:

or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile

Name

New password

Retype new password

Current password

Save

Cancel

Follow us