Keep up with the news by installing RT’s extension for . Never miss a story with this clean and simple app that delivers the latest headlines to you.


'Egypt returns to pre-2011 situation'

Published time: December 26, 2013 12:28
Angry Egyptians set fire to a microbus, said to be belong to a company owned by a businessman who supports the Muslim Brotherhood, after passengers allegedly held up four fingers, the symbol known as "Rabaa", during the funeral of those killed in a car bomb attack earlier in the day, in the Egyptian city of Mansura, North of Cairo, on December 24, 2013.(AFP Photo / Mahmoud Khaled)

Egyptian people believe the labeling of the Muslim Brotherhood as terrorist, the imprisoning of protest leaders, and the crackdown on dissent, has returned the country to a police state worse than under Mubarak, journalist Shahira Amin told RT.

RT:They deny it, but do you believe the Muslim Brotherhood would carry out such terrorist attacks?

Shahira Amin: The Muslim Brotherhood have already denied any involvement in that attack, they issued a statement saying that they were not behind the attack and asking for an investigation so that the perpetrators of the crime could be brought to justice. However, the fingers have been pointed at them again despite a jihadist group Ansar-Jerusalem claiming responsibility for this suicide car bombing.

RT:What's the government trying to achieve by labeling the Muslim Brotherhood a terrorist organization?

SA: This is a new escalation in a long-running feud between the security state and the Muslim Brotherhood. What they are trying to achieve is to destroy the Islamist group all together, and not to leave any room, any space for that group to enter into political life again. Declaring the Muslim Brotherhood a terror group will mean criminalizing their activities, criminalizing their financing and also criminalizing their membership. The protests are already outlawed, so this is a new escalation, it’s another repressive measure against them, the leaders are already behind bars and thousands of their supporters languish in prisons, there have been claims that some have been tortured and not allowed visits by their families. This can lead to more violence because violence can only breed violence.

RT: Their supporters that are not in prisons, can they be called terrorists too? The Muslim Brotherhood in its day had big support, now they are told they are supporting a terrorist group.

SA: Absolutely. They are not allowed to be members anymore. If they have been given this chance to abandon the group and then be accepted into the mainstream society again, that is a proposal that the government is making. But they seem more defiant than ever, they have already called for protests this Friday saying that the coup is the real terrorism here. So I expect more violence, more bloodshed and it’s a vicious circle.

A supporter of deposed Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi (C) is seen beaten by pro-government and army supporters during clashes that erupted at Tahrir Square and around the US Embassy in Cairo, on July 22, 2013.(AFP Photo / Fayez Nureldine)

RT:Won't this development potentially radicalize the Muslim Brotherhood even further?

SA: The latest decision to declare the Muslim Brotherhood a terrorist group can only mean isolating them further. They are very much part of this society, but now this is a deeply polarized, bitterly divided country and I’m afraid that this latest decision will marginalize the group even more. They seem very defiant; they have already declared new protests this coming weekend, although they are outlawed under this new law regulating protests. It can only mean a further crackdown on the group. Although the group has been used to these repressive measures, this is even worse than it was for them under Mubarak, when they were outlawed but tolerated.

RT:Egypt was one of the first to go through the Arab Spring revolution - what is keeping the protests alive there?

SA: Initially it was pro-Morsi supporters taking to the streets, demanding the reinstatement of the Islamist president. But in recent weeks we’ve seen revolutionary activists drawn into the protests. That happened after a brutal crackdown on a protest in which young activists took part, they were protesting the new anti-protest law, which they say will limit freedom of expression and assembly. Now several symbols of the revolution have been detained and three of them have been sentenced to three years in prison.

Also there’s a crackdown on protests at the universities in which one student was killed at Cairo University two weeks ago. That has created a lot of anger. People are angry at the excessive use of force, the inability for them to express their grievances. After the revolution they had made some gains. The fact that they were able to express their demands, to take to the streets and organize protests, and now with the new law these protests have been banned. They feel that this is a return to pre-January 2011, the return of the police state, repressive measures are being taken, and all measures are taken to silence this form of dissent. And that is why many of the young revolutionaries are also joining the protests.

The statements, views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of RT.

Comments (4)


Heba Mustapha 30.12.2013 13:24

CiCi put Egypt in a civil war


Babble 27.12.2013 04:22

The military government is just stupid. While Morsi tried to unethically moved the government toward an Islamic state, the democratic process should include the brotherhood on some level. The problem is the same in many countries where the ultra conservatives are the most motivated and yet the most uneducated and easily swayed to a narrow viewpoint. I'm afraid a civil war may start in Egypt which is a terrible thing for them.


Sayed Eltantawi 26.12.2013 17:37

It is amazing how a people with great history can descend to such level of animalistic behaviors, you are killing each others instead of lending a kind hand to the millions of you who are in need. go back to Islamic teachings and help one another. sit down and talk you idiots.

View all comments (4)
Add comment

Authorization required for adding comments

Register or



Show password


or Register

Request a new password


or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:


or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile



New password

Retype new password

Current password



Follow us