VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД
breakingnews
Go to main page   Politics   Bill Clinton: “Russian Israelis” key obstacle to peace  
MORE ON THE STORY
US, Washington: President Barack Obama (C) walks with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel (L) and President Mahmoud Abbas of the Palestinian Authority. (AFP Photo / Tim Sloan) 03.09.2010, 17:06 5 comments

Peace brokers pray for miracle in the Holy Land

Following a two-year collapse in direct talks, the leaders of Israel and Palestine met in Washington on Thursday where they began the formidable task of brokering a two-state solution.

US President Barack Obama shakes hands with Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu during meetings in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington on July 6, 2010 (AFP Photo / Saul Loeb) 09.07.2010, 20:03 5 comments

Obama and Netanyahu upbeat (again) on Middle East peace

The Israeli and American leaders have told separate meetings that peace in the Middle East may be possible “soon,” but Barack Obama admitted the process would be “wrenching.”

Jerusalem: A Palestinian woman passes right-wing Israelis demonstrating against fellow leftwing peace activists who joined a Palestinian protest against the eviction of Palestinians from their homes in annexed Arab east Jerusalem, in the Sheikh Jarrah neighborhood on January 1, 2010.(AFP Photo / Ahmad Gharabli) 24.08.2010, 18:09 1 comment

Israeli-Palestinian peace will take more than hope

When Israeli and Palestinian negotiators sit down in Washington next week for a new round of peace negotiations, they will be confronted with a huge plate of challenges.

RIA Novosti / Mikhail Fomichev 05.08.2010, 13:24 16 comments

“Belarus has not sold S-300 air defense systems to Iran”

Minsk has denied an Iranian new agency’s report on selling S-300 surface-to-air missiles to Tehran. Fars agency earlier said that Iran had obtained four such missiles.

14.10.2010, 18:43 6 comments

ROAR: “Britain does not mix economy and politics”

After William Hague’s visit to Moscow, many analysts still doubt that “a quick new start” in relations with Russia is among London’s priorities.

Barack Obama and Mahmoud Ahmadinejad 11.03.2009, 14:33

Did Obama send a personal message to Ahmadinejad?

Media worldwide is speculating whether Turkey’s President Abdullah Gül did indeed pass on a personal verbal message to Iran’s President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad from US President Barack Obama regarding US-Iran relations.

U.S. President Barack Obama (C) watches as Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu (L) and Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas shake hands (AFP Photo / Getty Images) 22.09.2009, 22:33

Low expectations proven true at Obama-Netanyahu-Abbas summit

U.S. President Barack Obama met with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas on Tuesday in an effort to revive stalled peace talks between Israel and the Palestinians.

L to R: Hillary Clinton, Sergey Lavrov, Ban Ki-moon and Catherine Ashton (AFP Photo / Yuri Kadobnov) 19.03.2010, 16:10 10 comments

Quartet strikes a chord, calls for Palestinian state in 24 months

Representatives of the Quartet on the Middle East are in Moscow where they have called for a halt to “unilateral” actions on the part of Israel and the Palestinians in order to jump-start peace talks.

A contractor speaks to an employee as they look at the plan of a new theater in the West Bank Israeli settlement of Ariel, on August 30, 2010 (AFP Photo / Jack Guez) 01.09.2010, 18:44 3 comments

Israel pledges to resume construction in West Bank

Israeli settlers have stated that they will resume construction works in the Palestinian Autonomy. This comes after four Israelis were killed when gunmen attacked a car near the city of Hebron.

21.03.2010, 22:17 7 comments

Middle East Quartet urges talks, calls on Israel to freeze settlement activity

The Middle East Quartet mediators have called on Israel to freeze settlement activity in East Jerusalem. They have also urged the sides to return to the negotiation table.

Bill Clinton: “Russian Israelis” key obstacle to peace

Published: 23 September, 2010, 13:29
Edited: 26 September, 2010, 23:10

Former U.S. President Bill Clinton speaks with television reporter Maria Bartiromo of CNBC (not pictured) during the taping of a program titled "Meeting of the Minds," at the Clinton Global Initiative in New York September 22, 2010

Former U.S. President Bill Clinton speaks with television reporter Maria Bartiromo of CNBC (not pictured) during the taping of a program titled "Meeting of the Minds," at the Clinton Global Initiative in New York September 22, 2010

TAGS: Conflict, Meeting, Russia, Hillary Clinton, Middle East, Politics, Immigration, Netanyahu


Russian-speaking Israelis have reacted angrily to the former US president’s statement that they are “an obstacle to peace with Palestinians.”

Speaking at a round table meeting during the annual Clinton Global Initiative conference on Tuesday, the former US President reportedly said that Israel is "different" now due to high influx of new Russian-Jewish immigrants and settlers who will not want to surrender their homes in the event that a peace deal with the Palestinians is reached.

Foreign Policy magazine quoted Clinton as saying that such a change in Israel's demographics may make it more difficult for the goverment of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to remove Jewish settlements in the occupied territories.

"An increasing number of the young people in the IDF [Israel Defense Forces] are the children of Russians and settlers, the hardest-core people against a division of the land. This presents a staggering problem," Clinton said. "It's a different Israel. Sixteen percent of Israelis speak Russian."

Clinton reportedly told reporters that Russian immigrants are the group least interested in a peace deal with Palestinians.

"They've just got there, it's their country, they've made a commitment to the future there," Clinton said. "They can't imagine any historical or other claims that would justify dividing it."

In the opinion of the former president, whose wife Hillary Rodham Clinton, the US Secretary of State, is currently mediating Israeli-Palestinian peace talks, the most pro-peace Israeli citizens are the native-born individuals who can trace their family roots back for centuries.

The magazine reported that Clinton also provided an account of a conversation he had with former Soviet dissident turned Knesset member Natan Sharansky, who, according to former US president, was the only Israeli minister to reject the peace agreement that then-president Bill Clinton proposed at the Camp David Summit in 2000.

"I said, ‘Natan, what is the deal [about not supporting the peace deal],'" Clinton was quoted as saying. "He said, ‘I can't vote for this, I'm Russian… I come from one of the biggest countries in the world to one of the smallest. You want me to cut it in half. No, thank you.'"

Clinton reportedly replied, "Don't give me this you came here from a jail cell. It's a lot bigger than your jail cell."

Sharansky, however, denied Wednesday that such a conversation with Clinton ever took place.

“A report of President Clinton's comments has been brought to my attention which I hope is inaccurate," he said, as quoted by Haaretz, the Israeli daily.

"I appreciate President Clinton's commitment to peace and talent for political analysis, however…I was never at Camp David and never had the opportunity to discuss the negotiations there with President Clinton. It may be that he had in mind our conversations at Wye Plantation years before, where I expressed my serious doubts, given the dictatorial nature of the PA regime, whether Mr. Arafat would be willing to bring freedom to his people, an essential element of a sustainable peace," said Sharansky.

Israel's reaction

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Wednesday described the remarks attributed to Bill Clinton as “distressing."

"As a friend of Israel, Clinton certainly knows that the immigrants from the former Soviet Union have contributed and are making a great contribution to the strengthening and development of the IDF and the state of Israel,” the Israeli leader said. “Only a strong Israel can establish solid and safe peace.”

Many other Israeli politicians have also expressed their indignation with the former US leader.

“If Bill Clinton found time to further study the issue, he would have realized how much Russian-speaking immigrants have brought to the region,” said Yohanan Plesner, a Knesset member. He believes their political convictions are based “on real situation rather than illusions,” Vremya Novostey daily quoted Plesner as saying.

“Such the incorrect statement of the former president came as a great surprise,” Olga Sivan, an immigrant from St. Petersburg, told the paper.

However, there may be some truth in Clinton’s words, the daily noted.

“Many Russian-speaking Israelis actually hold extreme far-right opinions and support settlement movement on the territory of the Palestinian Autonomy,” it said. “According to statistics, two thirds of them constantly vote for right-wing or ultra-right parties.”

However, Plesner stressed that in political issues the pragmatic approach of Russian-speaking immigrants “is not an obstacle but a stimulus for progress” in reaching agreements with Palestinians.

Sergey Borisov, RT

+33 (35 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
23.09.2010, 12:56

Poland receives new documents on Katyn massacre

Russia’s General Prosecutor’s Office has handed over to Poland 20 volumes of the materials on the Katyn Massacre, the mass killings of Polish prisoners in Soviet Union in 1940.

23.09.2010, 14:33 8 comments

No strife for the Arctic – Putin

Russia’s Prime Minister Vladimir Putin named comfort of living, attraction of investment and nature preservation as the basics of his Arctic program, speaking at the Arctic: Territory of Dialogue international forum.

ken November 04, 2010, 12:54
0

@johnx " Palestinian groups like HAMAS have been involved in jihadist or Islamic movements since the 1950's in Central Asia" . so was irgun they did many bombings and king david ones is one of their famous one it was declared a terrorist group and later irgun members became pm and presidnet of israel it means they are terrorists.ethnic cleansing in bosnia you must be kidding non muslims serbs did that and in kosovo both of the communities were trying to do that..please to show two sides of the topic not inly one because you very much sound like an anti muslim.thank you

sam September 26, 2010, 22:35
-1

I wonder, does Mr Liberman of Israel , as we know is Russian immigrant , does he have a criminal record when he in the Russia , when he talks it doesn't sound a normal person , does it?, then Mr Clinton may be correct in his diagnosis ?.

joseph walker September 25, 2010, 18:22
0

Time Clinton took his medication,if not under medication,seek medical advice ,it seems american politicans meander between reality ,and ignorance.Or so deluded ,with themselves ,imagine millions are interested in what they say.