'Barbaric' Magnitsky bill will harm the whole world – Russia

Published time: June 28, 2012 09:18
Edited time: October 23, 2012 23:43
Speaker of the Russian Federation Council Valentina Matvienko (RIA Novosti/Valeriy Melnikov)

The head of Russia’s Federation Council has said that the so called Magnitsky Bill would cause a rift in the Russia-US relations that could damage the whole world.

Valentina Matviyenko blasted the Magnitsky Bill as a “barbaric” move and an open interference with another nation’s affairs and warned of retaliation from Russia. “No state that has self respect can swallow such an unfriendly gesture. The Foreign Ministry has a large arsenal of ideas and options that can answer such a step,” the top parliamentarian told the RIA Novosti news agency. She also said that “Russia is not going to turn the other cheek” after such a step.

She added that the bill had no real foundation, but a hidden interest of certain forces. “It is obvious that the forces that are interested in adopting the bill are the forces that oppose the arrangement of constructive cooperation between Russia and the USA, and there are such forces in the USA,” the politician said, adding that the USA were interested in positive cooperation not less with Russia.

“Russia and the US are serious players on the international politics and economics and the situation in the world as a whole depends on our normal relations,” Matviyenko told the agency.

The Magnitsky Bill, was approved by the Foreign Relations Committee earlier this week, would impose visa bans and asset freezes on Russians the US accuses of human rights violations. Specifically it targets those linked to the death of the Hermitage Capital lawyer Sergey Magnitsky, who died following mistreatment in custody in 2009. The act has yet to be voted on in the full House and signed by President Barack Obama.

The Russian Foreign Ministry has blasted the move as an attempt to pressure justice and interference in another state’s internal affairs. The ministry also warned of dire consequences if the bill comes into force. "They have an opportunity to weigh the consequences, so we urge our U.S. partners and U.S. lawmakers to do just that," Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said. The official added it was "too early" to describe what action Russia will take in response.

Russia has already introduced its own entry ban on a group of US officials suspected of human rights violations as response to the first adoption of the Magnitsky Bill in 2011.

Comments (44)

Fred (unregistered) 01.07.2012 04:26

As an informed American , I can say this much, any American representing our government should be banned from carrying a passport undewr this act  because we are the greatest human rights violators in the world,,we are a criminal state and really have no right to judge any country until we clean up our own act

+7

Undo

Count Cash 29.06.2012 18:11

That Hermitage committed the fraud is glaringly obvious, what the responsibilities are for officers in the company, given that state of affairs is also glaringly obvious. Indeed the burden of proof shifts to them, to show otherwise, that they were not in control. Indeed the suspicion in any jurisdiction would fall immediately on them, and there would be raids, investigations, seizures, arrests given that state of affairs anywhere in the world. That burden to discharge is an onerous one indeed, to prevent the ‘it wasn’t me’ argument that was so frivolously used and abused in this case. The deliberate con by Hermitage here is to try to hold a trial by media, or worse to try to fabricate a video trial, with outcome favourable to them, piecing as much, out of context, untested, unverified and circumstantially leading evidence as possible, to paint the picture they want. Given their approach, if Hermitage directors could be shown to have sizeable assets, it would be direct proof that they carried out the fraud. That is the way the legal spin goes in the west, Hollywood style! As they say Excerpts are for experts to exploit, and Hermitage do it in style, but you would expect that on a big budget, oh doesn’t that prove they must have done the fraud then, because they have property, assets…. What a laugh! As the Russian government has said many times, bring the documents to us, make the case, the failure to do this is the greatest persuasive argument of all, that there is nothing that would stand up to the rigour of examination in court, so maybe it needs staying in film for a gullible audience!

0

Undo

Truth Hurts (unregistered) 29.06.2012 17:38

Cout Cash, your response is predictable and unpersuasive.  First, you focus on one fact  - a fraud was committed in the name of an entity, Hermitage - and ignore the others that show WHO carried out the fraud.   Second, you allege that the numerous facts against the ral criminals are fabricated, without proof or specifics of your allegations.  Third, you point to a general scapegoat,  i.e., "western bankers," who, because they are evil (you seem to suggest), make up lies.   You add some "of courses" to create the assumption that "everyone knows your points are true." Well, your points are not true.   The facts show otherwise. The Russian Untouchable videos name specific names, facts, dates, real property addresses, dollar amounts, etc.  They take uncontested excerpts from court documents, bank records, public land records, publicly available flight manifests. The videos are not shy.  They don't leave anything to the imagination, as you try to do. The videos set forth the specific facts and invite anyone - you included - to argue that they're wrong.  In response, you want to waive your hand and say "don't even look at them.  They are not credible."  Why isn't a land record credible?  Why isn't a flight manifest credible? Meanwhile, the Russian Government, which should be angry as hell that $230,000 was stolen, refuses to even look at the evidence.  Instead, it puffs its chest and says "you won't accept our criminals, then we'll get back at you somehow."   

+1

Undo

View all comments (44)
Add comment

By posting your comment, you agree to abide by our Posting rules

Log in to comment in full, or comment anonymously under character-limit restriction.

100 Text

– required fields

Register or

Name

Password

Show password

Register

or Register

Request a new password

Send

or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:

or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile

Name

New password

Retype new password

Current password

Save

Cancel

Follow us