VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД FIND US ON: YouTube Twitter
breakingnews
Go to main page   Politics   Reports of civilian casualties in Gaza exaggerated, says Israel  
MORE ON THE STORY
An Iranian long-range Shahab-3 missile is fired in desert terrain at an unspecified location in Iran (AFP Photo / Shaiegan / Fars News) 18.12.2009, 15:28 20 comments

Israel can withstand Iranian missile strike - experts

A leading Israeli missile expert said this week that the damage Iranian missiles are capable of causing Israel is limited, whereas Israel is capable of setting back Iran’s nuclear program by several years.

Tzipi Livni (AFP Photo/ Jini / Pool/ Emil Salman) 25.02.2009, 19:14 8 comments

Israel threatens new operation in Gaza

Israeli Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni warned that the Jewish state may launch another military operation, unless Iran stops smuggling weapons into the Gaza Strip.

AFP Photo / Mahmud Hams 10.03.2009, 15:53 1 comment

Israeli strategists’ two-state solution suggestion doesn’t include Palestine

Amidst widespread calls for a two-state solution to the Israel-Palestinian conflict, leading Israeli strategic thinkers are suggesting that one of those two states need not be Palestine.

A palestian militant of the Islamist group Hamas (AFP Photo / Said Khatib) 11.03.2009, 15:59

United they can’t: Palestinian internal split

Moderate Arab states have begun a major effort to help the Palestinians resolve their foremost problem – not the conflict with Israel, but the internal divisions that have split the Palestinians into two hostile camps.

AFP Photo / Hasham Ahmed 28.05.2009, 22:56

Blasts kill 11 in Pakistan

At least eleven people have been killed in two blasts in the city of Peshawar, north-west Pakistan. Attackers hit a market and a police checkpoint.

US soldiers patrol in Kunar, Afghanistan (AFP Photo / Tauseef Mustafa) 16.12.2009, 03:00

“Fighting Taliban is not about half measures”

Half measures will not work in Afghanistan, managing editor of The Texas Observer Chris Tomlinson told RT.

14.10.2010, 21:39 6 comments

Ahmadinejad makes “provocative” visit to Lebanon

Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad is on his first visit to Lebanon, a trip widely viewed as provocative.

06.08.2009, 14:44 23 comments

Israeli strike on Iran just a matter of time?

Despite all diplomatic efforts the US has undertaken to dissuade Israel from striking Iranian nuclear facilities, the attack now seems virtually inevitable.

AN/TPS-59 Tactical Missile Defense Radar 17.09.2009, 19:08 15 comments

Shield repealed: US reviews anti-missile plans

American President Barack Obama has confirmed that the US intends to shelve its plans for a missile defense system in Poland and the Czech Republic.

F-15 fighter 22.10.2010, 03:16 2 comments

Saudi Arabia to do record $60 billion American arms deal

The Pentagon has announced a US $60 billion arms deal with Saudi Arabia, the largest arms sales in U.S. history if it goes ahead.

Reports of civilian casualties in Gaza exaggerated, says Israel

Published: 25 February, 2009, 15:07

Palestinians run to safety during an Israeli strike in Gaza Strip (AFP Photo / Mohammed Abed)

Palestinians run to safety during an Israeli strike in Gaza Strip (AFP Photo / Mohammed Abed)

TAGS: Conflict, Military, Middle East, Politics


Allegations that 42 Palestinian civilians near a UN school were killed by Israeli shells during last month’s fighting in the Gaza Strip have been challenged by Israeli investigators.

The investigators said that the number of fatalities in the incident totaled 12, with only three of them non-combatants.

The UN school allegations had served as the centerpiece of charges by Palestinians and international agencies that Israel used indiscriminate and excessive force against civilians during the three week operation.

In the initial version of the incident, based on Palestinian sources, the casualties were said to have been inside a UN school in the Jabalya Refugee Camp north of Gaza City. This would eventually be disproved when UN officials acknowledged that no shell had hit the school. However, Israel was still faulted for having caused the deaths of civilians.

“I know that no one was killed in the school,” a senior UN official was quoted as saying, “but 41 innocent people were killed in the street outside the school. The state of Israel has to answer for that. What did they know and what care did they take?”

An answer to that question has been furnished by Col. Moshe Levi, head of the Israel Defense Force’s Gaza Coordination and Liaison Administration (CLA), which normally deals with the transfer of aid to the Gaza Strip through Israeli crossing points. With the onset of the war, Col. Levi and his staff began compiling a list of casualties in Gaza as reported by Palestinian health officials and comparing the names with those on its own list of Gaza residents and its registry of militants.

In a 200-page report recently issued, the CLA identifies more than 1,200 Palestinian fatalities by name and gives their Palestinian identity numbers, the circumstances in which they were killed and the militant group, if any, with which they were affiliated. The report concludes that about one-third of the total fatalities were civilian, and not two-thirds as Palestinian sources claimed.

Focusing on the fatalities killed near the UN school in Jabalya, the CLA concluded that 12 persons were killed, not 42 or 43 as had been reported, when Israeli mortars fired three shells at Hamas mortarmen who had fired from near the school at Israeli forces. Israel has released the names of nine of those killed, two females and seven males. In all, nine of those killed in the incident were identified by the Israeli army as Hamas operatives and three as non-combatants.

Israel maintains that the international community was duped by Hamas claims that the bulk of the fatalities were innocent civilians.

Palestinian sources did not reply to requests for comment.

Abraham Rabinovich for RT

+1 (3 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
Nazi standards and banners thrown on the ground in Moscow`s Red Square. June, 1945 (AFP Photo Tass) 24.02.2009, 21:14 15 comments

An anti-denial law of our own

Russia needs a new law to punish anyone denying the role of the Soviet Union in the defeat of Nazi Germany, according to Emergencies Minister Sergey Shoigu.

25.02.2009, 15:53

‘Stop ruining the country, leave already!’

Ukraine’s first president has accused the current one of deliberately running the country’s economy into the ground and called him to leave.