VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД FIND US ON: YouTube Twitter
breakingnews
Go to main page   Politics   ROAR: “Nobody is fully satisfied with Karzai”  
MORE ON THE STORY
Vladimir Kremlev for RT 21.08.2009, 13:53 18 comments

ROAR: “The USSR had no alternative to pact with Germany in 1939”

The Non-Aggression Treaty, signed by the Soviet Union and Nazi Germany 70 years ago is still at the center of attention for politicians and historians.

18.09.2009, 21:36 4 comments

Study: War on terror weakened Obama's support

A study in the U.S. has shown Barack Obama's media image is on the decline. According to research by two American universities, the President's standing has seen a 16 percent decline.

Demonstration in Tehran (Topshots / AFP Photo / str) 24.06.2009, 05:31 24 comments

How Western media backs the “green revolution” in Iran

It was an election that was snatched from the Iranian people – or at least that's the impression being given by Western media outlets. But are they telling the full story?

13.10.2010, 18:20 1 comment

ROAR: Terror crime rates halved in two North Caucasus republics

The case of the deadly September car bomb attack in North Ossetia has been solved, Russian security officials have reported.

24.09.2010, 17:32 25 comments

Ahmadinejad’s 9/11 "conspiracy theories" prompt UN walk-out

The Iranian president pulled no punches during his speech before the 65th session of the UN General Assembly, saying the US government may have had a hand in the attacks of 9/11.

Medvedev-Obama
19.05.2010, 14:47 6 comments

ROAR: With new sanctions looming, “positive development” depends on Iran

Moscow describes the language of a new draft resolution on sanctions against Tehran as “adequate” and “acceptable,” but doubts remain about the prospects of the document.

Vladimir Kremlev for RT 16.02.2010, 14:28 5 comments

ROAR: “Moscow will defend diplomatic solution on Iran until last second”

Russia has not yet agreed to unconditionally support new sanctions against Tehran as they may backfire on Moscow, the media say.

Israeli soldiers take position during a military operation to search for militants in the northern West Bank Farah refugee camp (AFP Photo / Saif Dahlah) 14.04.2010, 11:25 5 comments

Scandal over Israeli army’s illegal operations

An Israeli court has lifted a gagging order preventing the country's media from covering the case of the journalists accused of revealing classified military information to the press.

07.09.2010, 17:09 9 comments

Please, don’t burn after reading

The top US commander in Afghanistan has warned that a church pastor’s plan to burn copies of the Koran during a 9/11 memorial service may jeopardize the lives of US soldiers serving overseas.

US soldiers in Afghanistan (AFP Photo / Liu Jin ) 23.08.2009, 12:51

“They are not fighting, but playing”

Differing interests from various political forces in Afghanistan could see war in the nation continuing indefinitely under current conditions, says RT former Afghan General Abdul Kadyr in an exclusive interview.

ROAR: “Nobody is fully satisfied with Karzai”

Published: 24 August, 2009, 13:45

Vladimir Kremlev for RT

Vladimir Kremlev for RT

TAGS: Election, Middle East, ROAR, Politics, Terrorism


The victory of the incumbent Afghan leader in the second presidential election since the Taliban regime was overthrown will not change the situation in the country, Russian analysts believe.

Meanwhile, the two main candidates for the Afghan presidency – the current head of state Hamid Karzai and his rival Abdullah Abdullah – have claimed their victory in the first round. “This means that in the near future a confrontation similar to Iran’s scenario may begin in Afghanistan, which threatens a new civil war in the country,” Kommersant daily wrote.

The preliminary results of the election will be announced by the central election commission this week, with official results expected in the beginning of September. “At the same time, it is far from certain that leaders fighting for power in Afghanistan will agree with the election’s results,” Kommersant noted. Abdullah’s followers have claimed that irregularities during the election are estimated in their thousands around the country, the daily said.

The paper added that Abdullah himself spoke about the vote rigging, “similar accusations were pronounced after the elections in Iran in June by the opposition candidate Mir Hossein Musavi.”

However, some analysts believe that the accusations in the vote rigging in Afghanistan are being used for future bargaining. “The second round of the election will be conducted only if Karzai collects less than 50% of the vote, and backstage talks fail” beelives Andrey Serenko, an analyst at the Center of Modern Afghanistan Studies.

“The western powers will not make [the second round] possible, they did not like this to happen while they had defended the country from the Taliban before the election,” Serenko told RBC daily.

Aleksey Malashenko at the Carnegie Moscow Center agrees that “Americans do not want the second round.” They also do not want Abdullah “to stage protests according to Iran’s scenario after his defeat.”

“Abdullah has practically no chance to win,” RBC daily wrote. He was nominated by United National Front of Afghanistan, which unites former commanders from the Northern Alliance. The organization does not represent “the whole specter of northern elites, the votes of Tajiks and Uzbeks," Serenko said. Moreover, Abdullah is supported only by part of the front.

The National Front unites mujahideen “who discredited themselves from 1992-1996,” Sergey Demidenko, analyst at the Institute of Strategic Studies and Analysis, told RBC daily. Those forces over four years “plunged Afghanistan into chaos, hence why the population in 1996 greeted the Talibs,” he said.

Karzai, in turn, enjoys the support of the majority of Pushtuns and a considerable part of Tajiks, Maksim Minaev, analyst at the Center for Political Conjuncture, has said. “Karzai is also backed by many field commanders and politicians, including leader of the Uzbek community Abdul Rashid Dostum, who has returned to the country from Turkey,” Minaev said. At the same time, a part of the Tajiks oppose Karzai and support former Foreign Minister Abdullah Abdullah, he added.

Evgenia Voiko, another analyst at the center, stressed that political agendas of the main candidates were similar. The differences were only in the key issues of this election – “security assurance and stabilization in Afghanistan,” she said.

Karzai helped General Dostum to return to Afghanistan and secured the votes of Dostum’s followers in the north-western provinces, Voiko said. “However, this step evoked a sharp criticism from the US,” she added. There is fear of the escalation of fighting in Tajik provinces which oppose Dostum, the analyst stressed.

“However, in reality Washington’s fears are connected with the fact that Dostum’s return may hinder the realization of its project to establish a dialogue with moderate Talibs,” Voiko said. "At the same time, the US did not refuse to support Karzai, she stressed. Washington reckons on his help in talks with Pashtuns and hopes to push Dostum aside from big politics in the future," Voiko added.

Most analysts in Russia have no doubt that Karzai will be proclaimed the president again. “He is a weak national leader, but has an exceptional talent as a political schemer,. This helps him to maneuver between different groups of influence in Afghanistan,” Demidenko said.

“Neither Afghan tribal leaders, nor the American occupation administration are fully satisfied with Karzai,” Demidenko said. “However, all political forces take him as the lesser evil and are afraid that the attempts to depose him may destroy fragile balance of powers in the country,” he added.

“Whoever wins, the situation in Afghanistan will not change dramatically,” Fedor Lukyanov, the editor-in-chief of the Russia in Global Affairs magazine, believes. “If everything goes smoothly, and I’m certain that there will be no upheavals, the Americans will try to realize a new strategy,” he told Gazeta daily.

The US wants to increase the overall security thanks to the enlargement of the American contingent and active operations, and to reach out to “moderate Talibs,” Lukyanov said. “In other words, the US will try to repeat the Iraqi scenario in Afghanistan in order to create conditions for gradual withdrawal in two years.”

However, Lukyanov doubted that this new strategy could be efficient enough. “Afghanistan differs drastically from Iraq in terms of the possibility of achieving total control,” he said. Demidenko of the Institute of Strategic Studies and Analysis also told RT that no one really knew how “the questionable Iraq scheme” would work in another country.

As for Moscow’s position, it would prefer the status quo in Afghanistan, many analysts believe. The Afghanistan election does not have a great importance for Russia, Lukyanov said. “Moscow is certainly not interested in the destabilization of the situation in Afghanistan, so if the election does not bring changes, everyone [in Russia] will be satisfied,” he added.

Analysts also comment on the role the Talibs played in the Afghanistan election. Despite the wave of violence, the Afghan authorities and forces of the international coalition “have stood the test,” Serenko said. “The Taliban has shown everything it is capable of at the moment, and it is not much,” he added.

“In the past the Talibs were able to seize and keep whole districts,” Serenko said. “One could fire on Kabul for a long time and to plant mines on roads, but this will not lead to the seizure of power,” he added.

Some other analysts believe the Taliban is still a great danger to Afghanistan and the election has not reflected that reality. Demidenko noted that “those who do not like Karzai vote against him with their feet and join Taliban units.”

Sergey Borisov, RT

0 (2 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
RUSSIAN FEDERATION, VERKHNYAYA IVOLGA : Dmitry Medvedev (C) poses for a group picture with monks at the Ivolginsky Buddhist monastery in the village of Verkhnyaya Ivolga on August 24, 2009 (AFP Photo / RIA Novosti / Kremlin Pool / Dmitry Astakhov) 24.08.2009, 11:25

Medvedev promises stable electricity prices

President Dmitry Medvedev is in the Russian republic of Buryatia to discuss social and economic development in the Siberian District.

Independence Square, Kiev 24.08.2009, 19:10 5 comments

Independence day in Ukraine sees pro-Russian rally

Ukraine is marking 18 years since it declared independence from the Soviet Union. President Yushchenko addressed his people while the Autonomous Crimea takes to streets to protest the holiday.