VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД FIND US ON: YouTube Twitter
breakingnews
Go to main page   Politics   Will UN action on Gaza “war crimes” derail peace process?  
MORE ON THE STORY
Israel, Hadarim Prison : Israeli police vans carrying 19 Palestinian women leave the Hadarim prison near the coastal city of Netanya on October 2, 2009 (AFP Photo / Yehuda Raizner) 02.10.2009, 14:14

Israel releases Palestinian prisoners for hostage video

Israel has freed 19 Palestinian women from their prisons in exchange for a video proving that captured Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit is alive. The one minute recording of Gilad was reportedly filmed recently.

Israeli forces monitor the border with the Gaza Strip on February 1, 2010 (AFP Photo / David Buimovitch) 03.02.2010, 12:07 15 comments

Israelis want another war

A recent poll has revealed more than half of Israelis approve of another attack on Gaza – despite widespread international condemnation of last year's offensive which killed more than 1,300 Palestinians.

Palestinian woman holds the picture of a relative held in Israel during a protest in east Jerusalem on April 15, 2010 (AFP Photo / Menahem Kahana) 17.04.2010, 08:40 1 comment

Israel under pressure over 1,000 to 1 prisoner exchange with Palestine

Since Hamas captured Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit back in 2006, his plight has been etched into the nation's conscience. Israelis have pressured the government to offer thousands of Palestinians in exchange for Shalit.

04.02.2009, 12:56 1 comment

Hidden war: Israelis eat away at Palestinians’ lands

While the world’s attention is focused on the fragile peace in Gaza and the food crisis it is facing after Israel’s military offensive, Palestinians in the West Bank see their land confiscated, polluted and walled off.

26.02.2009, 09:05 1 comment

Israeli police dog attacks centenarian

A 99-year-old Palestinian man is recovering in hospital after being attacked by Israeli army dogs. The pensioner's ear and shoulder were bitten as he lay in bed when soldiers conducted a house search.

Iranian Shiite Muslim worshippers (AFP Photo / Atta Kenare) 30.07.2009, 09:16 1 comment

Shi’ism comes from Iran to Sunni Gaza

Palestinian divisions in Gaza are offering a way in for Iran, which is bringing fears in the region over the motives of the dominant Shia power, in an area which is traditionally Sunni Muslim.

Israelis hold banners showing captured Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit (AFP Photo / Gali Tibbon) 27.11.2009, 10:56

Israelis divided over 1000:1 prisoner exchange

An Israeli soldier kidnapped by Palestinian militants three years ago might be home soon. Israel is negotiating a deal which could see 1000 Palestinian prisoners released, but for some it is too high a price to pay.

A Palestinian enters a tunnel in the southern Gaza Strip that runs under the Egyptian border (AFP Photo / Patrick Baz) 27.01.2009, 09:44

Gaza tunnel network back to life

In southern Gaza merchants are busy rebuilding a complex network of underground tunnels used to bring in goods from neighbouring Egypt. Many of the passages were destroyed or badly damaged during the Israeli offensive.

28.01.2009, 09:49

Israeli mother: ‘I want my Palestinian kids back!’

The recent fighting in Gaza tore many families apart, but for one mother it offered the hope of being reunited with her three children who were left behind in the war-torn Gaza Strip.

AFP Photo / Olivier Laban-Mattei 28.01.2009, 13:17

Other nations join in siege of Gaza

Hamas’ efforts to break the Israeli siege of the Gaza Strip by firing rockets into Israel not only triggered this month’s Israeli air and ground attack, but has also led to an even tighter siege.

Will UN action on Gaza “war crimes” derail peace process?

Published: 16 October, 2009, 19:28
Edited: 18 October, 2009, 11:35

Jabalia : Palestinians live in the ruins of the home they lost during the 22-day Israeli offensive "Operation Cast Lead", in Jabalia, in the northern Gaza Strip on February 4, 2009 (AFP Photo / Mahmud Hams)

Jabalia : Palestinians live in the ruins of the home they lost during the 22-day Israeli offensive "Operation Cast Lead", in Jabalia, in the northern Gaza Strip on February 4, 2009 (AFP Photo / Mahmud Hams)

TAGS: Middle East, Gaza Stories, Robert Bridge


Despite a diplomatic blitz by Israel to block passage of the Goldstone report, which accuses Israel and Palestinians of war crimes in the Gaza War, the UN on Friday voted to back the recommendations.

The UN Human Rights Council (UNHRC) passed the resolution 25-6, as the United States and five European countries voted against.

The report demands reliable inquiries by Israel and Hamas into charges of war crimes and possible against humanity during Operation Cast Lead, the 22-day conflict that ended in a ceasefire in January yet continues to arouse passionate global scrutiny.

The report now moves to the UN General Assembly and the Security Council where the Israelis and Palestinians will be given six months to investigate the war crime charges. In the event of non-compliance, both sides risk an international war-crimes tribunal by the International Criminal Court in the Hague to prosecute militants.

Human rights groups say that more than 1,400 Gazans were killed in the conflict, but Israel officials put the number at 1,166. Thirteen Israelis were killed in the conflict, which Israel said was an act of self defense against rocket launches from Gaza into Israeli territory.

What next for the peace process?

At the beginning of the month, Israeli President Benjamin Netanyahu warned the UN that endorsement of the Goldstone report would “strike a fatal blow to the peace process… because Israel will no longer be able to take additional steps and take risks for peace if its right to self-defense is denied.”

Israel also accuses the Palestinians of employing “civilian shields” to cover their attacks, which works to propagate “anti-Israel propaganda sentiment” in the media.

Netanyahu said accepting the report would “strike a severe blow to the war against terrorism since it will afford total legitimization to terrorists who fire upon civilians and who hide behind civilians.”

(Incidentally, the Israeli president’s stern words may have been responsible for PA President Mahmoud Abbas voting for a UN deferral on the issue. But news of the retreat did not go down well on the Palestinian street, which erupted in protests and demands for Abbas's resignation. The public outcry forced the Palestinian government to throw their “full support” behind the discussions).

Others, however, argue that the Israeli military used “disproportionate force” during the conflict.

Former U.S. President Jimmy Carter, who paid a visit to Gaza in June, told reporters he had to “hold back tears” while viewing the destruction.

Visiting the American School in Gaza, severely damaged during Israel’s military offensive, Carter said “it’s very distressing to me,” explaining that the facility had been “deliberately destroyed by bombs from F-16s made in my country and delivered to the Israelis.”

What next for U.S.-Israeli relations?

Although Israel and Washington remain strong allies, the relationship has noticeably chilled since the arrival of Barack Obama.

In May, Netanyahu paid a visit to the White House where he and Obama attempted to close the circle on the Middle East tangle.

The U.S. President, echoing past administrations, stressed the need for a “two-state solution” to the Palestinian crisis, as well as a halt to settlement construction in the West Bank.

The government of Benjamin Netanyahu has all but excluded the possibility of an autonomous Palestinian state. While the hawkish Israeli President yielded to American pressure to support the creation of a Palestinian state, his conditions – that it must be demilitarized and recognize Israel as a Jewish state – may be asking for too much.

Now, with international pressure in the form of a possible war crimes tribunal looming for both Israel and Palestine, it will be interesting to see what course the road map for peace takes.

Beyond the pale of war

One reason for Israel's opposition to the Goldstone report is that it touches upon subjects not directly related to the Gaza conflict.

It "strongly condemns" actions taken by Israel that place limitations on Palestinians' access to their property and religious sites "on the basis of national origin, religion, sex, age or any other discriminatory ground."

It further condemns "Israeli violations of human rights in Occupied East Jerusalem, particularly the confiscation of lands and properties, the demolishing of houses and private properties, the construction and expansion of settlements, the continuous construction of the separation wall, changing the demographic and geographic character of East Jerusalem, the restrictions on the freedom of movement of the Palestinian citizens of East Jerusalem, as well as the continuous digging and excavation works in and around Al-Aqsa mosque and its vicinity."

Although this shopping list of grievances are not immediately connected to the question of war crimes in the Gaza conflict, they are a source of extreme antagonism between the two sides that demand attention.

Now it seems the UN wants to see serious action taken on these hot-button issues so that a desperately needed solution to the Middle East crisis can finally become a reality.

Robert Bridge, RT

+16 (16 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
16.10.2009, 17:13 1 comment

Russian parliamentary protest lingers into second week

The Wednesday walkout of three Russian parliamentary factions waned seriously by the end of the week, with two of three parties deciding to return to their seats on Friday.

16.10.2009, 20:17

"A milestone in the comprehensive strategic dialogue"

One of the major results of Hillary Clinton’s visit is the approval of the Russian-American Presidential Commission, said Russian Foreign Ministry spokesman Andrey Nesterenko.

armen08 October 18, 2009, 02:29
0

@Roberto: Israel has lost all claim to have been a victim of genocide. No matter how loud you yell, no matter how often Israeli criminals blame the Palestinians for the ongoing genocide in Palestine, history and facts cannot be changed. Go on, keep repeating Israeli lying points at infinitum. You will fool nobody. But you have no other choice. You have lost your freedom of thought, just as Israel has lost its moral integrity. No lies will help you, or Israel, to escape from this trap.

Roberto October 17, 2009, 07:44
0

@armen08: What kind of genocide and self-inflicted holocaust are you talking about? The current Israeli policies have nothing to do with the expansionist ones of the early '80s, and genocide has never been an Israeli policy--the Jews have already drunk enough of that cup to never want to touch it again. The current Israeli government is in favor of a two-state solution, and is willing to make extensive concessions. Right now the Palestinian side is the one holding out and hardening demands. The only ones we should denounce wholeheartedly are the terrorists, who make the process of building a secure peace settlement harder for everyone with their attacks on innocent civilians.

Roberto October 17, 2009, 07:11
0

This reminds me of the international reaction to the Russian intervention in South Ossetia. Both Gaza and the 2008 South Ossetia war were defensive actions whose facts and origins were almost immediately lost among international media, to be replaced by stories of false atrocities and disproportionate force. I don't see why Russia doesn't support Israel in this. Israel's current government isn't only into counterterrorism, it also wants to build a situation in which everyone's security is more certain and where there are no reasons for further terrorism to occur--the exact same goals as Russia! Both countries have relatively progressive foreign policies, it would be easy for them to shed their history of troubled relations between 1967 and 1991 and start cooperating in the area of security. Even if we're talking in terms of bloc politics, it would make sense for Russia to become more friendly with Israel because their relations with the United States are cooled down significantly thanks to Obama.