VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД
breakingnews
Go to main page   USA   News   Freedom of religion only for some?  
MORE ON THE STORY
25.10.2010, 16:31 14 comments

Vatican rejects “chosen people” claim, calls on Israel to end “occupation”

A high-ranking Israeli official on Sunday slammed a statement from Catholic bishops, who called for international organizations to lead the cause of Palestinian statehood.

10.06.2010, 23:50 40 comments

The silencing of Helen Thomas and the First Amendment

From the time of Eisenhower to Barack Obama, Helen Thomas enjoyed a 57-year stint working as a Washington correspondent, until an ill-advised comment on Israel sent her into early retirement.

Khaled Mashaal 05.02.2010, 17:24 7 comments

Hamas leader to visit Moscow

The leader of the radical Palestinian party Hamas, Khaled Mashal, will visit Moscow next week to discuss ways of ending the Palestinian split and how to resume the Palestinian-Israeli negotiations.

28.05.2010, 15:33 7 comments

As Obama moves against homegrown terrorists, it’s time to read the fine print

The president's national security strategy focuses the big security guns on homegrown terrorism, but some observers fear the new program will ride roughshod over democratic terrain.

US, Washington: President Barack Obama (R) talks with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel (C) and President Mahmoud Abbas of the Palestinian Authority (L) during an event in the East Room to make statements on the peace process on September 1, 2010 at the White House in Washington, DC. (AFP Photo / Tim Sloan) 02.09.2010, 11:41 1 comment

“It’s blabber, but without it the situation is getting worse” – Russian analyst

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas are expected to sit down together on Thursday for the first round of peace talks in nearly two years.

 Photos by John Perkins 17.12.2009, 16:10

Between landmines and apples

New satellite research indicates that for the past million years, the politically disputed Golan has been moving closer to Israel – bringing thousands of Druze closer to the country they do not wish to be a part of.

UN Photo / Mark Garten 24.03.2009, 08:02 2 comments

Kosovo the focus of the UN Security Council

At Monday's UN Security Council Session Kosovo accused Belgrade of of stirring up trouble in its Northern areas, while Serbia countered that an Albanian ethnic mafia was trafficking drugs, people, and guns from Kosovo.

Rally in memory of the victims of terrorist metro bombings in Moscow on March 31, 2010 (AFP Photo / Oxana Onipko) 02.04.2010, 18:37 2 comments

Medvedev calls for crackdown on terrorists’ accomplices

Dmitry Medvedev called for a crackdown on people who provide any assistance to terrorists. The comments come just 4 days after the bombings in Moscow and Dagestan killed at least 50 people and left over 120 injured.

07.07.2010, 06:58

UK national security is failing to combat domestic terrorism

Five years after the July 7 terror attacks in London, which claimed 56 people, critics of the British government say national security policy has failed to guarantee the public's safety.

11.06.2009, 14:06 24 comments

Child saved from Jehovah’s Witness parents

Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili has demanded that a four-year-old-girl be saved from almost certain death. The girl’s parents, who are Jehovah's Witnesses, were preventing hospital doctors from treating her.

Freedom of religion only for some?

Published: 02 September, 2010, 00:15
Edited: 09 September, 2010, 22:37

Supporters of a Islamic cultural center and mosque planned to be built near Ground Zero (AFP Photo / Don Emmert)

(17.0Mb) embed video

TAGS: Religion, Politics, Human rights, USA


The Ground Zero mosque is slated to be built on what is considered by many as sacred ground, just as Glenn Beck’s ‘Restoring Honor’ rally was held on ground sacred to others.

All summer long, a debate had raged about the appropriateness of building a mosque near the 9/11 site. The question from opponents of the mosque being: how can Muslims desecrate the memory of those heinous attacks by building a mosque on the site where terrorists attacked in the name of Islam?

Glenn Beck’s “Restoring Honor” rally was – among many purposes – about honoring America’s servicemen and women, firefighters, police officers and raising scholarship money for the children of servicemen and women killed in combat. It was not supposed to be about politics at all. But in true Glenn Beck style, it was. It was held at the Lincoln Memorial on August 28th, which happens to be the same date and location of Dr. Martin Luther King’s “I Have a Dream Speech”. Being an extremely divisive figure, Glenn Beck was railed against for holding his event at that particular date and location. It was essentially sacred ground for Beck’s critics.

To be specific, the proposed mosque does not sit exactly on hallowed ground unlike the rally which essentially did.

If Tea Partiers want the Cordoba House moved because of its proximity to sacred ground and because it could potentially violate the sanctity of a defining moment of American history, couldn’t one argue the same thing for the “Restoring Honor” rally? If Tea Partiers wonder why the mosque just can’t be moved, then why couldn’t Glenn Beck have moved his rally?

Some in the Tea Party have argued there is no way to compare the two situations, because the rally is a one-day event whereas the mosque would be sitting by Ground Zero in perpetuity. But, what if Glenn Beck decides to host his rally on that same site on the same date for the rest of his life?

The mosque is actually designed to be a community center with a mosque in a single room located within the center. Currently, there is a mosque within the Pentagon which was attacked on 9/11 as well. However, there have not been calls for the Pentagon or that mosque to be removed.

The majority of Tea Partiers believe America is a “Christian” nation. The group claims to honor and uphold the US Constitution as the bedrock of their beliefs. However, the US Constitution guarantees freedom of religion and freedom of assembly. One cannot invoke the Constitutional rights of freedom of religion and assembly for one system of beliefs and not extend the same to someone of another belief. You can’t have it both ways.

RT’s Cedric Moon asked one Tea Partier; "Is the only difference between this event being held here on this day and what's happening at Ground Zero is the fact this is a Christian nation and this is a Christian event? Is that the difference? Is that what you're telling us at this point?"

"You know what? You know what? I am going to stand on that and I'm going to say 'yes'. But not only am I going to say 'yes' but that the difference is Glenn Beck is an honorable person," he replied.

Watch the full interview with Thom Hartmann


Radio host Thom Hartmann said that both the 9/11 site and Lincoln Memorial are iconic. Yet the bizarre comparison is more what Beck stands for as opposed to what Martin Luther King, JR stood for. King stood for rising up the poor, unionizing workers, and simply helping others.

Glenn Beck’s message is the exact opposite of that,” said Hartmann.

He argued it was a desecration for sorts to co-op the day and place for his rally. He explained that Tea Partiers see the rally/King’s speech issue complexly separately from the ground zero mosque debate.

What this really highlights is the hypocrisy of the language of separation of church and state because, the whole Glenn Beck thing is lets religious and bring religion into the state, but it damn well better be Christian religion,” said Hartmann.

He argued that the Tea Party is ok with church and state mixing, so long as it is their religion, the Christian Religion.

“It goes beyond double standard, it goes to screaming hypocrisy and frankly I think a large chunk of racism,” said Hartman.

Beck claimed at his rally that he wanted to restore the values of America; Hartmann said Beck is complexly incoherent.

If he wants go back to the value system that was extant at that time; the age of consent was seven, child prostitution was legal and common, pretty much everybody, well not everybody, but a lot of people were using cocaine and legally, public drunkenness was widespread, there were no unions, I mean do we really want to go back to that? If he is talking about lets go back to that. Or, does he want to just go back to the 50s when black people couldn’t go in certain restaurants and when segregation was legal? Frankly I think the America he is nostalgic for is the segregated America,” said Hartmann.

+5 (9 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
Barack Obama shakes hands with Iraq war veterans on August 31, 2010 at Fort Bliss, Texas (AFP Photo / Tim Sloan) 01.09.2010, 17:59 4 comments

Obama’s cruel summer ends on (slightly) upbeat note

President Barack Obama is hoping that his decision to end military operations in Iraq will silence his many critics, but with midterm elections fast approaching, this is mission impossible.

Image from kitatkonenutnewyork.org 02.09.2010, 10:30

Israeli army veterans in US train up for self-defense

While politicians are working on peace in the Middle East, a Jewish group in the US is preparing itself for the worst. Thinking they may be attacked, they train intensively in military skills and survival methods.

Slick April 24, 2012, 10:55
0

This country only tolerates White Anglo-Christians. 

Adam September 09, 2010, 21:50
0

Argument could be made against, people who attended Glen becks event, most them are the same people who opposed the civil right movement .

Wilson Boozer September 04, 2010, 00:57
+1

Why on earth would anyone expect tolerance from a nation founded by slaveholders that for over two hundred years has been braying "freedom" to the rest of the world?