VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД
breakingnews
Go to main page   USA   News   Holbrooke testifies on Afghanistan before Congress  
MORE ON THE STORY
KANDAHAR PROVINCE - JUNE 15: A soldier in the 1-71 Cavalry of the 10th Mountain Division walks down the hood of an M-ATV vehicle, the heavily-armored successor to the Humvee 17.06.2010, 03:07 3 comments

Is the war in Afghanistan a lost cause?

The US-led war in Afghanistan continues to struggle and US President Barack Obama has decided to postpone the Kandahar offensive.

Afghanistan, Kabul : Afghanistan-based Polish soldiers at Kabul International Airport on April 11, 2010. (AFP Photo / Shah Marai) 02.09.2010, 22:00 4 comments

Poland wants to start pulling troops out of Afghanistan

Polish President Bronislaw Komorowski has complained that the mission in Afghanistan costs Poland $1 billion annually, and asked NATO to define plans to start withdrawing soldiers from Afghanistan as soon as possible.

29.09.2010, 02:58 7 comments

Pentagon destroys war memoir, releases censored version

The Pentagon burned 9,500 copies of a book it deemed a threat to national security. The US government paid the publisher nearly $50,000 dollars in printing costs, had the books pulled and destroyed.

Afghans hold a banner which reads" We want to form our Islamic government to stop the wilful operations of the foreign forces in Afghanistan" during a demonstration in Mazar-i- Sharif, Balkh province, north of Kabul, Afghanistan on Saturday, July 10, 2010 10.07.2010, 21:17

Afghan protests against NATO raid in full swing

In northern Afghanistan, over 1,000 people have joined a protest to demand foreign troops get out of the country.

08.07.2010, 04:08

“Restrepo” – a look into the lives of Americans fighting in the Korengal Valley

The Korengal Valley is one of the most remote and dangerous places in Afghanistan. It is also home to a 15-man outpost called Restrepo.

Peace Activists close NATO Headquarters 24.10.2010, 03:25 12 comments

NATO is a past matter – Russian scholar

NATO has no future and today we have to re-think European security anew to switch to other forms of interaction between Russia and the EU, insists Viktor Kremyenuk, Deputy Director of the U.S. and Canada Institute.

A Marine from 3rd Battalion, 3rd Marine Regiment, ground guides a vehicle into position near a temporary observation post in Southern Shorshork, Helmand province, Afghanistan, during the first day of Operation Cobra, June 16. (1st Marine Division Public Affairs / Photo by Sgt. Mark Fayloga) 26.06.2010, 02:54 3 comments

What’s next for the US war in Afghanistan?

Many are wondering how the switch from Gen. McChrystal to Gen. Petraeus will affect the policy and strategy in Afghanistan.

US Gen. David Petraeus appears before the Senate Armed Services Committee for a confirmation hearing to become the head of US and NATO forces in Afghanistan on Capitol Hill in Washington, DC on June 29, 2010 (AFP Photo / Nicholas Kamm) 29.06.2010, 20:16 1 comment

Gen. Petraeus faces Senate hearings prior to confirmation

The US Senate is holding hearings that are expected to confirm the appointment of General David Petraeus as the new commander of the war in Afghanistan.

06.07.2010, 11:26 48 comments

“US is building secret bases in Afghanistan for war against Russia” – journalist

Investigative journalist Daniel Estulin, who has made it his mission to uncover the secrets of the Bilderberg Group, has shared some of his revelations with RT.

A CH-53 helicopter releases flares after being shot at from the ground while flying over Helmand Province, southern Afghanistan 16.08.2010, 21:35 7 comments

“Afghan occupation has little to do with Afghanistan per se” – writer

American public support for the war in Afghanistan is at an all-time low, with July being the deadliest month for US and NATO troops since 2001.

Holbrooke testifies on Afghanistan before Congress

Published: 15 July, 2010, 03:53
Edited: 15 July, 2010, 18:34

Afghanista, Kandahar (AFP Photo / Shah Marai)

(23.0Mb) embed video

TAGS: Conflict, NATO, Politics, Afghanistan, USA


Last month, Afghanistan surpassed Vietnam as the longest military campaign in US history, said US Senator John Kerry. It’s the comparison that cannot be avoided, by press, pundits, and now, politicians.

Senator Kerry brought up the failed U.S. war of decades ago at a crucial time in America’s current one.

This is a difficult moment in the Afghan conflict,” according to the Senator.

It’s a moment when questions about strategy and progress abound, evident at a hearing on governance and the US civilian strategy in the region. The man in charge of those efforts for the Obama Administration, a Vietnam veteran himself, tries to make a lesson of that history.

I want to underscore the fundamental difference between those two wars, in [Afghanistan] national security is at stake,” said US Ambassador Richard Holbrooke, special envoy to Afghanistan and Pakistan.

With the safety of the US at stake as Richard Holbrooke claims, you might think congress would have crossed their T’s and dotted their I’s by now, in fighting their longest battle, as they’re supposed to.

The United States Constitution requires that before the U.S. goes to war there is an act of Congress,” said US Congressman Denis Kucinich (D-OH) in an interview with RT.

But just as in the Vietnam War, Congress “never filed that procedure with respect to a war in Afghanistan,” according to Kucinich. “We’ve simply drifted into a war and a long term commitment.

It’s a long term commitment that appears to be wearing on lawmakers who want to know this:

Wouldn’t it be helpful for the president to at least lay out a flexible timetable,” asked US Senator Russ Feingold (D-WI).

He is referring of course to a timetable for when the US is getting out of Afghanistan. That is beyond the July 2011 date to start the withdrawal US President Barack Obama previously set.

It is given no assurance “that this should not be an open ended occupation,” said Senator Feingold.

Holbrooke emphasized the US’s committed to no calendar.

I am very leary of giving an absolute date of troop withdrawal from the region,” he told congress.

But still, the end game is unclear.

The military and civilian mission is proceeding in Afghanistan without a clear definition of success,” said Senator Richard Lugar (R-IN).

The ambassador is banking on the success of reintegrating the Taliban, starting next week. But little about Afghanistan appears to be in US favor.

It’s not where you chose to defend the American homeland,” Holbrooke said of Afghanistan. “It’s the most logistically difficult place the US has ever fought in its history.”

But just who can put an end to this fight, in the absence of withdrawal dates, and if military and political missions fail?

The congress has the ability to stop the war by not funding it,” Kucinich pointed out.

As US lawmakers and officials talk strategy and tout successes in Afghanistan, this comes amidst escalating violence in the region. June was the bloodiest month since the conflict started. One hundred international troops were killed. So far in July 45 have been killed, 33 of those were Americans. And in the last 24 hours alone, 12 have been killed.


The overall strategy in Afghanistan is to pass on the leadership role from the US and coalition forces to the Afghan military. Jake Diliberto of Rethink Afghanistan said however that the Afghans are in no way prepared to take on the leadership role.

The Afghan army is ineffective in every possible way, so the Taliban are going to gain momentum and unfortunately unless there is peace talks and peace negotiation the situation will always be a quagmire,” said Diliberto.

Diliberto argued that the Taliban is a generational mindset that is deeply embedded into the culture. It is an ideology that cannot simply be defeated with force and no amount of money will make the Taliban stop fighting.

The main reason for the rise of the Taliban is because we are in their villages and valleys. We shouldn’t be there,” said Diliberto.

He added that utilizing a proposal US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton supports that would use funds to buy-off Taliban members won’t work.

It would be kind of similar to bribing gang members to rat out other gang members” he said. "The concept is absolutely ludicrous.

+3 (3 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
AFP Photo / Robyn Beck 15.07.2010, 03:29 4 comments

US immigration debate heats up in Utah

An anti-immigration group calling themselves the Concerned Citizens for the United States has collected a list of 1,300 alleged illegal immigrants in Utah and are planning to send the list to government agencies.

The Soyuz-Apollo Soviet-U.S. space crew after docking, July 1975. Cosmonaut Alexei Leonov, center, and astronauts Thomas Stafford and Donald (Deke) Slayton (RIA Novosti) 15.07.2010, 09:09 1 comment

US and Russia mark anniversary of first joint space flight

Thirty-five years ago Russia and the US took a giant leap for mankind with the launch of their first joint space mission, Apollo-Soyuz, which marked the beginning of an era of space cooperation between the two countries.

Srbin July 15, 2010, 14:56
0

May they remain there for a long time to come. It is one of the ways to fight unemployment at homeland.