Will Obama and Clinton testify for Manning?
Published: 09 December, 2011, 20:38
Bradley Manning
TAGS: Crime, Military, Scandal, Law, Internet, Information Technology, USA, WikiLeaks
As the defense attorneys for alleged WikiLeaks aide PFC Bradley Manning prepare for a pre-trial hearing, the US government is trying to shut down all of the nearly 50 witnesses they’ve asked to testify, including Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton.
Manning has been under strict and severe military custody for nearly two years for his suspected involvement in WikiLeaks, Julian Assange’s whistleblower site that the government says is detrimental to the security of the nation. Attorneys for Manning, however, believe that they have a strong case to support their client, though are now encountering a new road block with the government giving them the run around.
David E Coombs, attorney for Manning, has asked for both President Obama and Secretary of State Hillary Clinton to testify during the Article 32 hearing scheduled to begin next week. Slated to start December 16, the hearing will serve as precursor to further judicial action and will determine if Manning’s case will be fit for a full-scale court martial hearing. Coombs hopes that by grilling the president over remarks he made earlier this year, he will be able to show that the commander-in-chief was out of place by what he says was an expression of “unlawful command influence.”
Back in April, Obama remarked on Manning publically, saying that the soldier had “broke the law.” Such a statement, says Coombs, can cause the case to collapse, noting in a recent court filing that a “superior officer in the chain of command is prohibited from saying or doing anything that could influence any decision by a subordinate in how to handle a military justice matter.”
Additionally, the defense had hoped to question Secretary Clinton on whether the documents Manning had allegedly leaked actually posed any threat to America’s security. Administration officials had earlier expressed that the papers Manning supposedly sent to WikiLeaks were of “rather benign nature” and of no real damage to national security.
The court has called Obama and Clinton “too important” to stand trial, says Coombs, to which the attorney writes is a blow to not just his case but to the judicial system as well.
“The government seems to argue that in matters of justice, if you have too important of a position, you should not be bothered,” Coombs writes. “Military justice should not be controlled by the importance of your duty position.”
Coombs has asked for 50 defense witnesses to take the stand during the Article 32 hearing, but the government seeks to reject all of them sans those that they are also calling as witnesses. If the 48 witnesses the defense has asked for, they will thus be left with only ten.
Specifically, says Coombs in an official filing released to the media, the government has opposed testimonies from witnesses that the defense believes will show a deterioration in Manning’s mental health, which could have led to a lessening of any punishment brought before the private. The government insists that reading written statements will suffice for the sake of the trial, but Coombs responds, “Simply reading the sworn statements of some of these witnesses and hearing from a few others will not allow either party or the Investigating Officer to explore the relevant information.”
“The listed witnesses need to be questioned personally and individually about what they saw, heard, and experienced if there is to be a thorough and impartial investigation,” adds the attorney.
09.12.2011, 02:42
4 comments
Homeless Occupy the woods – RT revisits Tent CityWhile Occupy Wall Street tents have been popping up all across the US, homeless people have been forced to Occupy a camp in the woods over the last five years. Occupy Wall Street |
09.12.2011, 21:32
44 comments
Ron Paul says Bush was thrilled with 9/11Ron Paul stopped in Ames, Iowa on the campaign trail on Thursday, and used some harsh words to explain President George W Bush’s reaction to the September 11 terrorist attacks. US Election 2012 9/11 tragedy |
@Maya
I thought about this all day.
I wish they would have warned me about a few things but it's impossible to get everyone; they never seem to understand, history says. The morals that make up society are such that we have these rights to exist. Freedom of speech is really freedom of confession so that the spies know and they create our ignorance. Things like that.
There has to be a way to warn the weary thinking ones though. I hate what happened. I wish I could say "53" and show the @ then be left alone, something like that.
no the nazi terrorist voted dec 3 2011 that anybody who dose not think their way can be detained tortured for life and murdered without trial or warrant worst is the gov said if u are missing fingers on your hand you are a domestic terrorist that's a real kick in the face to the returning soldiers that had limbs blown off







This feels like a Nazi trial, were everyone is expected to climb on to their oats and up in the knees of those corrupt politicians that has done nothing but soiled the American Uniform these past 20 years. The military court that is to judge this person, got a possibility to clear this man, or get a peoples trial themselves like the Nazis did during the Nuremberg trials. The power of these corrupt politicians is only that strong, as more people wake up, the power of the people will end this tyranny much sooner then later, and many of those smelling corruption will face a peoples judge and get a swift trial themselves for conspiring, treason, and miscarriage of justice. If history has taught me anything it is that tyrants does not last forever. The military is expected to preform their duty? They only preform their duty to their slavemasters the corrupt politicians running the US today. The Nazis that went to the gallows during the Nuremberg trials did the exact same thing for Hitler. "They only followed orders". The military of the United States has no honour left if they judge this boy for telling the truth about the corrupt people running this world today. This is my two cents, as there has not been one death caused by the release of these documents. The only thing that has happened is that a few tyrants has gotten their dirty laundry exposed to the rest of the world and the US military is expected to lick it up and sentencing a truth teller. If media did what they should be doing, this would not have happened in the first place.