War made easy: Helpful, ‘simple’ color chart ‘explains’ Syria conflict
Conflict theorists and terror experts can pack up and go home: one researcher has finally devised a "simple" chart to comprehensively explain away the complexities of the Syrian War.
While the graphic created by Charles Lister - a fellow of the Middle East Institute in Washington - is described as “simple”, the zigzagging colorful lines are pretty mindboggling.
The chart is a ‘who’s who’ of forces fighting against each other in the conflict.
This *simple* chart shows all states of hostility currently being played out on #Syria’s territory#IntractableWarpic.twitter.com/1inprNB6U0
— Charles Lister (@Charles_Lister) February 13, 2016
Lister’s chart has sparked discussion online about the usefulness and over-simplification of the chart.
@Charles_Lister This chart is not just unhelpful & poorly designed, but biased in pushing an overcomplicated, nihilistic view of Syria. C-
— شَوً كَاغِيِّه، صحفي (@shawncarrie) February 14, 2016
@Charles_Lister@MidEastInsider There we have it. A peace deal is a piece of cake!
— aspals legal pages (@aspals) February 14, 2016
@Charles_Lister@skyfire747 Excellent chart. It could apply to almost any era, right back 10,000 years, in the history of the Middle East.
— John Dogherty (@fidoIV) February 14, 2016
@Charles_Lister@DinkZola So many mistakes on this chart.
— UsHadrons (@ushadrons) February 14, 2016
Questions have also been raised regarding omissions from the chart.
@Charles_Lister@iyad_elbaghdadi No one is hostile towards the Israelis? xD
— Filipe S Henriques (@FHenriques) February 13, 2016
@Charles_Lister Gee I guess Israels air force is happy
— Keir John Harry (@keirjohnharry) February 13, 2016
@Charles_Lister Will we soon be adding the Saudis to this?
— Chris Kilpack (@cakilpack) February 13, 2016
This is not the first attempt to dumb down the complexities of geopolitics in the Middle East via a handy graphic.
Karl Sharro, Middle East commentator and satirist, created a parody diagram of the region last year, which many took at face value.
Following recent event, updated diagram of geopolitical relationships in the Middle East pic.twitter.com/3QmDxZtnSn
— Karl Sharro (@KarlreMarks) March 26, 2015
“I was surprised at the number of people who made factual comments or corrections, which the diagram clearly doesn't represent accurately," Sharro told the Independent at the time.
Sharro has taken to Twitter again, in what appears to be a response to Lister’s “simple” chart:
ok here's version 2.0, you don't get that kind of service anywhere else. pic.twitter.com/eaASmwVpLj
— Karl Sharro (@KarlreMarks) February 18, 2016