Israel denies visa for HRW researcher, citing ‘Palestinian propaganda’
Israel has denied a work permit for a Human Rights Watch researcher, saying that the group is engaged in the “service of Palestinian propaganda,” HRW said, adding that Tel Aviv is not distinguishing between “justified criticism” and “hostile propaganda.”
“Israeli authorities denied Human Rights Watch’s application for a work permit for its Israel and Palestine director on the grounds that it is not a real human rights group,” the organization said in a statement.
HRW said that they received a letter from Israel, denying a work permit for researcher Omar Shakir, an American citizen who was to be based permanently in the area, on February 20. Shakir investigates “human rights abuses in Israel, the West Bank, and Gaza,” according to information on the HRW website.
Israel: Human Rights Watch Denied Work Permit https://t.co/hwsN0n8nr9
— Human Rights Watch (@hrw) February 24, 2017
“The opinion received from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs noted that, for some time now, this organization’s public activities and reports have engaged in politics in the service of Palestinian propaganda, while falsely raising the banner of “human rights”, and therefore recommended denying the application,” HRW's translation of the letter from Israeli authorities said.
Shakir, who was recently assigned to the position of the Israel and Palestine Country Director within the HRW, told RT that the group “found the decision shocking.”
“We really do not understand where it is coming from. We understand that the Israeli authorities may disagree with some of our findings on particular issues it sees as contentious. But we have long written reports like this and they are no different from what they have been before, so we really do not understand this decision and we really hope that the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs … will reverse its decision,” he said.
He went on to say that “Israel is not the first state that disagrees with our research findings but stifling the messenger is not the way to go, especially for a country that commits itself to being a democratic one and to respecting the rule of law and international human rights.”
He also stressed that such actions put Israel “in the [same] group with countries like Cuba, North Korea and Sudan [who] have denied us access.”
Israeli gov not only one to disagree with @hrw findings but dismissing them as propaganda puts it in group w most repressive states we cover pic.twitter.com/fBh3nyu2cI
— Omar Shakir (@OmarSShakir) February 24, 2017
Shakir also emphasized that Israel’s decision “was particularly surprising” as the HRW “had regular access to Israel and the West Bank for nearly three decades” and its members “regularly engage and correspond with the Israeli authorities.”
“Just last year, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs requested our intervention in a matter involving the human rights of Israeli civilians,” he said.
In the meantime, the HRW assumed that this decision could be politically motivated.
“This decision and the spurious rationale should worry anyone concerned about Israel’s commitment to basic democratic values,” said Iain Levine, deputy executive director of programs at Human Rights Watch. “It is disappointing that the Israeli government seems unable or unwilling to distinguish between justified criticisms of its actions and hostile political propaganda.”
Nobel Peace Prize & reporting on 90+ countries apparently not enough-Israel accuses @hrw of not being a legitimate human rights organization pic.twitter.com/I7B6ewo7HA
— Perrine Vaillant (@perrinev) February 24, 2017
‘Part of a larger pattern’
Shakir also drew attention to the fact that the decision is “a part of a larger pattern that is happening in Israel and across the world.”
“We have seen the space for human rights defenders in Israel and in the occupied Palestinian territories shrinking. We even saw some Palestinian groups facing criminal charges as a result of their human rights advocacy,” he told RT, adding that “it is coming at a time when there is a more permissive environment in the international community to the rights violators in the name of security and stability.”
Shakir also expressed his hope that the international community would use its influence to make Israel reverse its decision.
“We are encouraged to see strong statements from the US Department of State, we hope that other states in Europe and Russia will similarly use its leverage to encourage the Israeli authorities to allow us and other human rights groups to operate because it is a key way to ensure the respect the international law and the human rights,” he told RT.
However, the group also reiterated that Israel has refused access for the group’s personnel to Gaza since 2010, except for one visit in 2016.
According to the group, “the characterization of Human Rights Watch promoting Palestinian propaganda does not square with the research and advocacy that the organization conducts to challenge violations of human rights and international humanitarian law by all actors in the region.”
It also referred to its previous reports on violations by Israeli government, including its critics of Israel’s new law regulating human rights groups in 2016.
However, HRW said it had also released reports denouncing the Palestinian administration. One of them criticized the Palestian authorities' crackdown on journalists in 2016.
By denying visa to an HRW employee, Israel has joined a few countries who have blocked the group’s staff members, including Cuba, North Korea, Sudan, Uzbekistan, and Venezuela.
