‘Greta shaming’ trend in Israel discourages plastic utensils with ‘dystopian’ cut-outs of teen climate activist
Photos of Swedish climate activist Greta Thunberg are popping up in cafeterias across Israel in a “green” trend designed to shame diners out of using plastic cutlery. Many online saw shades of Orwell in the new fad.
Dubbed “Greta shaming,” the trend has swept workplace lunchrooms in Tel Aviv, with eco-minded workers placing photos of a disapproving Thunberg alongside disposable forks and plates, casting judgement on anyone who dares to ignore their environmental footprint.
A trend in Tel Aviv workplace cafeterias - photos of a judgemental Greta Thunberg next to disposable utensils. Here is #1: pic.twitter.com/8Zk93RfZ5s
— Allison K. Sommer (@AllisonKSommer) November 5, 2019
The teenage activist has trotted the globe doling out doses of climate shame and “How dare you”-s to world leaders over their alleged inaction on the environment, but it appears her message is catching on in Israel, where the city of Tel Aviv recently passed a ban on single-use plastics in some childcare facilities.
And in the AP office in Jerusalem, via @PattyNiebergpic.twitter.com/7igt2u8M6I
— Allison K. Sommer (@AllisonKSommer) November 6, 2019
Here's another one - at Wix headquarters in Tel Aviv, via @YatirKaarenpic.twitter.com/9c4Gr21O4f
— Allison K. Sommer (@AllisonKSommer) November 6, 2019
While several netizens praised the trend’s message in earnest, even while enjoying the humor, many found the scowling photos off-putting, conjuring dystopian images of a green analogue to Orwell’s all-seeing “Big Brother.”
“Basically the same idea as of Orwell's 1984?” one user asked, while another warned“Little Sister is Watching.”
Have you seen THX 1138? In a dystonia future, state run confession booths have no priests but have an image of Hans Memling's Christ Giving His Blessing (1478)Maybe our future has... pic.twitter.com/h7IxXLTCGb
— Apostic (@AposticMark) November 7, 2019
— Sysop of Dune (@MysterMyke) November 6, 2019
Some supporters of the young activist took the fad as pure ridicule, however, and were accordingly offended, with one stating“How juvenile and ignorant can you get? I am surprised at Tel Aviv and disappointed.”
— David Best (@davidbest95) November 6, 2019
Other environmentally-minded commenters approved of the idea, but observed that plastic contributes little to climate change – accounting for only a “drop in the bucket” – largely robbing the trend of any practical effect.
Not using #plastic doesn't help very much when it comes to the #climatecrisis - not eating #meat (living #vegetarian/#vegan) and not #flying by airplane (#flyless) helps much more. pic.twitter.com/PmKpQtRvm3
— There is no plan(et) B - EU (@NoPlanetB_EU) November 7, 2019
I would agree. I'm sure I sound pedantic but the amount of CO2 released into the atmosphere as a result of plastic flatware manufacturing is a drop in the bucket.
— Mike Marshall (@mndevguy) November 6, 2019
“Instead of shame, they could just empower people with more conscientious alternatives,” another tweeter suggested.
I love that people are wasting trees printing unnecessary pictures to shame others about paper/plastic usage.
— Peninah Lamm (@PeninahLamm) November 6, 2019
Thunberg rose to fame after staging a school walkout over the climate issue in Sweden in 2018, and has since toured the world lecturing on the follies of fossil fuel-addicted “grown-ups” and calling for urgent action to address the environment.
Like this story? Share it with a friend!