Top Ukrainian academic claims British publisher censoring truth
A leading academic on Ukraine has accused prominent British publisher Routledge of attempting to censor his new book, claiming the company demands he include “alternative” perspectives in his analysis of the Russia-Ukraine conflict.
Ivan Katchanovski, a University of Ottawa professor originally from Western Ukraine, is known for his forensic debunking of popular myths around the so-called Maidan coup in Kiev, and a critical stance towards Kiev’s pro-Western, post-Maidan government.
In a series of X posts on Thursday, Katchanovski claimed that Routledge, under contract to publish his book “From the Maidan to the Russia-Ukraine War,” is refusing to release it unless he revises the manuscript to include Western-backed conspiracy theories.
He specifically mentioned the publisher’s request to reflect “alternative sources” on contentious issues such as the Nord Stream bombing and the blocking of peace talks in 2022, which Katchanovski says were hindered by the US and the UK.
Katchanovski wrote: “Routledge states that my book cannot be published unless I would revise the entire manuscript… and would use other perspectives and alternative sources concerning the Russia-Ukraine war, the peace deal, the Nord Stream bombing, and all other issues I examine, including the Maidan massacre.” He argues that the demands are politically motivated and prevent him from presenting his findings based on the facts.
Thread https://t.co/KZmt9e0PuR
— Ivan Katchanovski (@I_Katchanovski) November 15, 2024
According to the academic, his book has garnered support from several experts. One unnamed peer reviewer described it as “an important contribution” to the study of the Russia-Ukraine conflict, noting its “unsurpassed broad empirical base.” Another reviewer stated that Katchanovski’s work has “withstood criticism” and is highly respected within the academic community.
The professor built his reputation on his evidence-based research, including an analysis of the 2014 Maidan sniper incident, which he claims, using forensic video analysis, was a false flag operation used to justify the ousting of Ukraine’s then president, Victor Yanukovich. This theory, which contradicts the official Western narrative, was met with criticism from pro-Maidan voices when first proposed, but Katchanovski continues to be cited by scholars and analysts.
Katchanovski says he faces the choice of either revising his manuscript to fit Routledge’s requirements or canceling the contract altogether. He refuses to commit “academic fraud,” stating, “I cannot base my book on politically convenient narratives and sources propagated by any government and media.”
Routledge, a major academic publishing house, has yet to comment on Katchanovski’s allegations. The publisher is known for its books in the humanities and social sciences, but has been accused of yielding to political pressure in recent years.
Katchanovski has suggested that he may seek alternative publishers if Routledge continues to block the release, though this could delay publication of his work by up to a year.
