Oops: PBS gets around rainy Fourth with fake fireworks footage
Wet and foggy weather dampened America’s traditional Independence Day fireworks in Washington, DC, on Monday, but millions watching the public television broadcast might have thought everything was fine after old footage was shown instead.
‘A Capitol Fourth’ is a DC tradition going back 36 years. Every Fourth of July, the Public Broadcasting System shows the fireworks display in the nation’s capital from the West Lawn of the US Capitol building. This year, PBS producers apparently decided the mercurial Washington weather wouldn’t be allowed to rain on their parade. After all, who would know?
#Blessed to see the fireworks from my apt window & watch #July4thPBS. Tho, the fireworks out my window don't look like @pbs. #fake? 🤔🇺🇸
— Tina (@tinpant) July 5, 2016
Not cool @pbs.... Fake footage of fireworks on the Fourth???? It's cloudy and rainy in DC. Those shots are clearly not from tonight.
— Chris Wallgren (@seawall77) July 5, 2016
LOOK: PBS fakes the #capitolfourth fireworks. This proves it. Capitol has scaffolding on it, PBS show had none. pic.twitter.com/gtCluBDkya
— Marcus Harun (@marcusharun) July 5, 2016
As PBS tweeted about how amazing the show was, the real fireworks lit up social media, with outraged viewers protesting the misleading broadcast.
— A Capitol Fourth (@July4thPBS) July 5, 2016
The backlash eventually drew an apology from the public broadcaster, which claimed that the show was a composite of this year’s show with previous years.
“It was the patriotic thing to do,” PBS said.
@July4thPBS The stock footage fireworks are amazing! The live version, not so much. #capitolfourth
— Victoria Collins (@VCollins82) July 5, 2016
Many were still not amused, slamming the station for attempting to pass stock footage as the real thing. In the words of one columnist, it was “such a DC thing to do.”
It's just a shame you didn't tell us up front you were going to pull this switch. Not very professional. #pbs#July4thPBS
— Joe Cap (@JoeCap393) July 5, 2016
@July4thPBS How is using stock video patriotic? If I wanted that, I'd watch YouTube. #fake#July4thPBS
— Thomas Rainer (@ThomasRainerDC) July 5, 2016
More than four hours after the show, at almost 2am local time on Tuesday, PBS finally tweeted an apology… of sorts. While apologizing for “any confusion” caused by the switch, the station defended its decision to intercut footage from previous concerts “for the best possible television viewing experience.”
I knew public broadcasting was powerful. Until tonight l I didn't know it could clear cloudy skies & scaffolding. #capitolfourth
— Jennifer A. Dlouhy (@jendlouhyhc) July 5, 2016