New York prosecutors dismissed ‘most’ looting & riot cases from George Floyd protests, police data shows

Multiple prosecutors in New York state have declined to press charges against many of those arrested for looting and rioting amid last year’s George Floyd protests, dismissing hundreds of cases, according to NYPD data.

Citing police records, an investigation by a New York NBC affiliate found that a large percentage of charges filed during a wave of demonstrations last summer – many involving looting, vandalism, and even rioting – had since been dropped. 

Of the 485 cases arising from arrests in Manhattan between May and June of last year, 222 – nearly half – were dismissed by District Attorney Cy Vance. Some 128 remain open, while 73 saw convictions for minor crimes such as trespassing, which carries no jail time. 

At the time of the protests, which followed Floyd’s May 25 death at the hands of Minneapolis police, Vance openly stated that “in the interest of justice,” he would not pursue most unlawful assembly, disorderly conduct, and “other protest-related charges.” He argued that doing otherwise would undermine the “critical bonds between law enforcement and the communities we serve.”

Prosecutors in the Bronx, Brooklyn, and Queens followed Vance with similar announcements, prompting scathing criticism from law enforcement groups. 

“It is a dereliction of duty to their oath of office,” Edward Mullins, the president of the New York Police Department’s Sergeants Benevolent Association, said at the time, adding that the district attorneys were “undercutting the work of the NYPD” as well as diminishing public safety. 

In the Bronx, police data showed that an even greater proportion of looting charges had been scrapped, with 73 cases out of 118 dropped since last year. 

A source within one district attorney’s office told the NBC affiliate that, for many suspects, prosecutors simply did not have the evidence needed to pursue charges, citing the massive backlog of cases that had accumulated while some courts were closed amid the Covid-19 pandemic. 

However, former NYPD Chief of Patrol Wilbur Chapman said that, while the police had carried out thorough follow-up investigations, the district attorneys had not attempted similar due diligence – he claimed they had “allowed people who committed crimes to go scot free.”

Prosecutors in a number of other cities, such as St. Louis, Missouri and Portland, Oregon, have followed similar guidelines when deciding to charge protest-linked cases, also dropping a flurry of charges racked up during the Floyd rallies. In Portland – where unrest was particularly intense, seeing more than 100 consecutive days of clashes with police last year – the federal authorities stepped in to charge alleged rioters after county district attorney Mike Schmidt refused to pursue most of the cases. However, even those federal cases have seen a high dismissal rate, with 31 out of 90 dropped by the Department of Justice as of March.

Think your friends would be interested? Share this story!