‘How not to inspire’: Provocative ‘fat-shaming’ commercial sparks outrage (VIDEO)
A German supermarket commericial has managed to divide a nation with supporters calling it an inspiring act of marketing genius, while opponents brand it an offensive fat-shaming ploy which could spark eating disorders in children.
The story of ‘Eatkarus’ is a controversial new advertisement by the supermarket Edeka. It encourages healthy eating by retelling the tale of Icarus (the mythical Greek boy who flew too close to the sun, plummeting to his death) through the eyes of an overweight boy.
Set in a town of obese people who mindlessly stuff themselves with grey slop, Eatkarus discovers wild berries and eventually shuns his family’s overeating ways to fulfil his dream of flying.
The commericial received widespread criticism upon its release from viewers who said it simplified weight loss and attempted to promote healthy eating by ridiculing fat people.
That new Edeka ‘Eatkarus’ ad is a masterclass in how not to inspire anyone to eat more healthily, ever https://t.co/mF51UncNqgpic.twitter.com/A4nCxdPLcI
— Julia Glotz (@juliaglotz) February 22, 2017
#eatkarus#fatshaming
— woolverine (@KathiKaffee) February 15, 2017
ihr wollt andere shamen, weil sie dick sind? Weil sie euren Normen nicht entsprechen? das ist nicht okay.
"You want to shame others because they are fat? Because they do not meet your standards? This is not okay."
Dicksein ist nicht das Problem. Leute wie die Werbepersonen bei Edeka sind das Problem. #eatkarus#fatshaming
— BatPerson ^o^ (@TenzaGramorla) February 15, 2017
"Being fat is not the problem. People like the advertisers at Edeka are the problem."
Was mich an diesem beschissenen #Eatkarus-Clip am meisten fertig macht ist halt schon, dass das auf Kinder zielt. Meine Fresse.
— Kroko (@krokodilgemuese) February 15, 2017
"What makes me the most done on this shit #Eatkarus clip is just that it is aimed at children. Oh, my God."
Genau Kinder. Mit Beeren aus der Wildnis werdet ihr Dank Übelkeit&Erbrechen ruckzuck dünn! #edeka#eatkarus
— Riekje Linnewedel (@riekje_l) February 15, 2017
"Exactly children. With berries from the wilderness, you will thin in no time thanks to nausea & vomiting! #edeka #eatkarus".
READ MORE: Facebook sorry for banning plus-size photo that ‘violated health & fitness standards’
The Berlin-based Association against Weight Discrimination took to Twitter to remind people that you don’t need a tiny waist to fly and in Greek mythology Icarus ultimately crashed.
Zum Träumen braucht es keine Wespentaille - zum Fliegen übrigens auch nicht. #Eatkarus#EDEKA#ISSSO#Gewichtsdiskriminierungpic.twitter.com/QwHIG2spt8
— GgG e.V. (@GgGeV) February 17, 2017
Edeka defended the commercial in a statement by saying their intention was to simply raise awareness for healthy eating and nutrition: “With a certain exaggeration, we wanted to shake off the daily routine of fast food and the movie’s unidentified grey mash, regardless of the size of an individual.”
“We are aware that some people suffer from obesity because of illness, which cannot be solved with a simple diet change,” the statement added.
READ MORE: ‘Fat & ugly’ gym poster promotes bullying, say critics
Those in favor of the advertisement have leaped to Edeka’s defense to praise the supermarket chain for their creative storytelling and inspiring message.
#Edeka macht viel richtig. Die neue #Eatkarus Kampagne ist kreativ, polarisierend und durchdacht. #marketinghttps://t.co/IHu7VudoJo
— Marc Recker (@short_scoops) February 15, 2017
"#Edeka does a lot of right. The new #Eatkarus campaign is creative, polarizing and well thought-out. #marketing".
Fantasic #vfx#animation and brilliant #storytelling on this spot for EATKARUS EDEKA https://t.co/vY7Si3cB2dpic.twitter.com/jtf2FZa3CC
— rasinmotion (@rasinmotion) February 20, 2017
A warm video reminds me, inspires me, motivates me… You should never forget that you're here for a reason. https://t.co/CQtHSrLSdw
— tony (@tonyearlybird) February 22, 2017
Some positive inspiration. Don't be normal! Fly! #lifestylemedhttps://t.co/AIbhRMggbG
— Marc Braman (@marc_braman) February 22, 2017
Inspiring video demonstrating the benefits of a #healthydiet: https://t.co/byd1BuWMaK
— Elan (@ElanBio) February 21, 2017
This foreign ad transcends languages and borders. Stunning piece https://t.co/EPeeM2QaJ4
— Marcus Culloty (@Marcuswriterman) February 19, 2017
Someone once said "You are what you eat" Just a beautiful video about #eating and #dreaming by Edeka. Enjoy! https://t.co/ZW71UvlU0v
— Antonella Barozzi (@RABarozzi) February 19, 2017