Keep up with the news by installing RT’s extension for . Never miss a story with this clean and simple app that delivers the latest headlines to you.


​‘Burden on Australia’: Immigrant family fights deportation over son’s autism

Published time: December 14, 2013 14:39
Dr Siuly Kabir (R) and Dr Enamul Kabir (L) with son Srijon (C) (Image from @siuly.kabir)

Dr Siuly Kabir (R) and Dr Enamul Kabir (L) with son Srijon (C) (Image from @siuly.kabir)

A professional immigrant family in Australia faces deportation because their son has been diagnosed with autism, even though the parents are prepared to pay the extra cost for the child's special schooling.

The Kabir’s pursuit of a better life in Australia from their native Bangladesh appears to be an immigration success story: Enamul Kabir is a doctor of mathematics and his wife, Siuly, is a doctor of biomedical engineering. Residents of Brisbane, they have lived in Australia for five years and never fail to pay their taxes, they say.

However, their eight-year-old son, Srijon, has been diagnosed with autism and for that reason the Kabirs may be sent packing back to Bangladesh.

Enamul and Siuly Kabir had their application for permanent residency turned down because their son Srijon's condition could "likely result in a significant cost to the Australian community in the areas of health care and community services," The Australian newspaper reported.

Enamul Kabir insists his son Srijon will not be a burden on Australia.

“The last report from the doctor mentioned he has moderate autism and is improving and also mentioned now he is getting support but in future may not need any support,” Enamul Kabir told World News Australia (WNA).

“First of all he doesn’t require any medication and therapy, [the] only support he requires is special schooling, and we are very happy to pay his special school fees if we get permanent residency,” he said.

The Kabir’s fear what will happen to Srijon if they are deported back to Bangladesh, where there is no special schooling or support for children with autism.

The possibility that Srijon – and other immigrant children like him - may require expensive, long-term medical care, paid for by taxpayer money, is exactly what Australian officials are seeking to avoid.

“Before somebody wants to migrate to Australia they have to prove they’re not going to be a drain on our health system and a medical officer basically calculates how much this is going to cost our health system,” said Dr Susan Harris-Rimmer of the Asia Pacific College of Diplomacy at the Australian National University.

“So the reason a lot of kids get caught is because they calculate it over their lifetime, and they don’t take into account whether you’re going to use the services or not.”

Once the medical care exceeds the 200 thousand dollar [Australian dollars = approximately 180,000 US dollars] threshold the amount of care is deemed “a burden” on Australia and the individual’s application to stay in the country is rejected.

Australian Immigration Minister Scott Morrison (AFP Photo / William West)

However, many people say the office of Immigration Minister Scott Morrison should exercise extreme discretion in this case, considering that the Kabirs are contributing something positive to Australian society, as well as the economy.
The Kabirs are now awaiting a decision from Mr. Morrison, who can personally intervene on behalf of the family.

"There is discretion on the part of the minister that on the grounds of compassionate circumstances he can reverse the decision of the tribunal," Andrew Rouyanian, the lawyer representing the Kabirs, told The Australian. "Srijon has been here for five or so years. He's had the benefit of a special school and his doctors say his condition is improving. One doctor the family saw said if they were thrown out and sent back to Bangladesh, then he'll be lost for life."

A spokesperson for Morrison said the minister was "waiting for a submission to be prepared for his consideration" by the Immigration Department.

A 2010 parliamentary investigation into immigration recommended a “net benefit” test be used in cases like the Kabirs, including what skills the migrants can offer.

Immigration policy has become a hot topic in Australia, which has become a popular destination for asylum seekers. In fact, the problem is so bad that Australia last month gave Sri Lanka a gift of two patrol boats to aid its efforts in stopping refugees heading to Australia.

‘Not a burden to society’

Enamul Kabir, who is employed at the University of Queensland, says he has contributed a fair share to Australia during his time in the country.

“When I came here as a student I was working as an associate lecturer at the University of Southern Queensland, and for more than the last two years I’m working full-time [sic], I’m paying tax to the government,” he said.

Srijon Kabir (Image from @siuly.kabir)

“For example in the last financial year I paid $18,000 in tax, so yes I’m contributing to the economy of this country and as well I’m helping researchers, students and academics who need help with statistics, so I’m contributing in that way as well.”

The Kabirs hope their professional skills, which are in short supply at present in Australia, will be an incentive to the government to allow them to remain in the country.

“At the moment there is a really big reliance of foreign workers, we really need to build up the skills in Australia, and meet that with domestic supply, but at the moment we need the supply internationally,” Professor Kerrie Mengersen, the former president of the Statistical Society of Australia, told WNA.

“So there’s a huge demand in Australia because there’s [sic] industries and businesses that realize they need data analysis, modeling, prediction, the advent of big data, different kinds of data, and there’s not enough people coming through from universities and schools doing good maths and stats,” the professor added.

The Kabir family's plight made headlines when a former colleague of Enamul Kabir, Christine McDonald, created a petition on the website In four weeks it has attracted 24,000 signatures. At the time of writing (Saturday December 14), it was just 100 signatures shy of the 25,000 needed to qualify as a petition to the government.

Comments (35)


Ben Dalby 13.03.2014 10:54

australia has enough immigrants as it is we really don't need anymore. they barely even make a contribution anyway, just complain about our culture while feeding off our medicare. the muslims are the worst, trying to turn cities into muslim only areas. aus is the perfect example of the failure that is multiculturalism.


Amit Kalia 07.01.2014 09:00

This shows status of Mind . I'll never advise any 1 to australia as a immigrant. Totally selfish country with emotion less administration. Couple with doctorate degrees tried spend peaceful life with dignity and social contribution. But government is calculative. Aus. will pay in future for such a disgusting acts, in terms of skill outsourcing. I have dropped my plan to go Australia as i don't know when i become burden on aus. & they simply say bye bye to me due to my issues or my family issues. Families build community & then nation. Australia is disturbing roots of humanity... Thank GOD my INDIA is great....


Samundra Baral Magar 18.12.2013 16:31

children with autism can be proved to have beautiful future if they are loved and go for special schooling. even,what we say normal child,could be burden if he or she do not get good schooling. come on! do not overlook humanity. broaden our mind and respect medical science and this world.

View all comments (35)
Add comment

Authorization required for adding comments

Register or



Show password


or Register

Request a new password


or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:


or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile



New password

Retype new password

Current password



Follow us