Hundreds gathered in Israel on Saturday to rally against the government’s plans to resettle some 40,000 Bedouins. The proposal has triggered accusations of “discrimination” and “ethnic cleansing” from activist groups, also sparking a protest in the UK.
The demonstrations were organized as part of an international “Day of Rage” against the proposed law which would arrange for Bedouin settlements to be created in southern Israel’s Negev Desert, also known as the Prawer-Begin plan.
The Prawer Plan would see up to 40,000 (according to local media) and up to 70,000 (according to the Guardian) Bedouin removed from their homes in Negev, southern Israel. The plan also provided for the demolition of about 40 villages and confiscation of 70,000 hectares of land.
The Israeli government has said the Bedouins will be re-homed and granted compensation for the move. However, the UK-based charity, Palestine Solidarity Campaign, said that the plan heralds “the forced displacement of Palestinians from their homes and land, and systematic discrimination and separation.”
On Saturday, the international “Day of Rage” which was proclaimed by rights groups prompted protests across Israel, in both Gaza City and in East Jerusalem, in addition to the UK.
In the Negev village of Houra, clashes broke out at the main demonstration where about 1,200 protesters had gathered. The action started out peacefully with people chanting against “fascism”, Haaretz reports. But eventually some protesters started throwing stones at police.
The Israeli police responded with tear gas, stun grenades and water cannon. Eleven protesters got detained, with ten police injured and a number of police vehicles damaged by stones.
The draft legislation was adopted by the country’s parliament,
the Knesset, at its first reading in June, but still has two more
readings in the Knesset before it becomes law.
On Sunday morning , Haaretz revealed that the World Zionist Organization’s Settlement Division has also been devising a plan to settle more Jews in Galilee in order to establish a balance with the Arab population. The Settlement Division has been contacting a number of planning firms, according to letters seen by the paper, suggesting that they bid on a tender to produce a development policy document which will map the absorption of 100,000 new residents in central Galilee, with the intention of “giving expression to Israeli sovereignty through settlement activity” and “enhance the demographic balance.”
There were also protests across the UK as Britons took to the streets to voice their anger at Israeli plans, while 50 high-profile British artists, writers, and musicians added their signatures to an open letter to the Israeli government denouncing the proposal.
The group published a letter in the Guardian on November 29
condemning the plan and urging the UK government to act. The
letter contains the signatures of 50 public figures supporting
The document calls for immediate action from the British
government, urging harsh measures rather than the usual
“There can be no ‘business as usual’ with a state which is
preparing to ethnically cleanse 70,000 people. It’s time to start
challenging Israel’s racism and apartheid policies,” the
activist group wrote in the letter.
In support of the letter mass protests have been planned across the United Kingdom on Saturday. The “Day of Rage” demonstrations will be held in Brighton, Bristol, Cardiff, Lambeth, as well as a number of locations in central London. In addition, Palestinians in Israel are staging mass demonstrations against the Prawer Plan to draw international attention.
Despite opposition to the plan, the Israeli government is pushing
ahead and is expected to vote on the initiative before the end of
Some Israeli media has also condemned the plan on the basis that
the Bedouins are Israel citizens who were granted citizenship in
“These are Israeli citizens – citizens in a ‘democratic’
state, some of whom have even served the country militarily – who
are now having their homes destroyed,” David Harris-Gershon
wrote in his blog for the Tikkun Daily.
“The plan [is] to regularize Bedouin settlement in the Negev’,
but it does nothing to solve problems and regularize our
settlements – it stipulates only destruction,” said Fadi
El-Obra, a 29-year-old from Rahat, speaking against the Prawer
Plan to the International Solidarity Movement.
The UN Secretary Ban Ki-moon issued a statement on the
International Day of Solidarity with the Palestinian People
calling for Israel to call off plans to expand building in the
settlements. Israel and the Palestinian Authority agreed to
restart peace talks this summer after a three-year diplomatic
stalemate. In spite of the revival of negotiations, very little
headway has been made on some of the most pressing issues
obstructing a peace agreement.
The Palestinian Authority has slammed Israel’s plans to continue
expanding settlements, while Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin
Netanyahu has accused the Palestinian side of purposely
“inciting artificial crises.”
Israel “will not be subjected to any restrictions concerning
settlement,” Netanyahu recently vowed at a meeting with the
Israeli right-wing Likud bloc, stressing that the Palestinians
are well aware of that.