Keep up with the news by installing RT’s extension for . Never miss a story with this clean and simple app that delivers the latest headlines to you.


Chelsea Manning: US secrecy breeds unilateralism that defies constitution

Published time: February 21, 2014 14:31
Chelsea Manning, formerly known as Bradley (Reuters/Gary Cameron)

Chelsea Manning, formerly known as Bradley (Reuters/Gary Cameron)

The US government’s pursuit of secrecy and power lends itself to unilateralism which the Founding Fathers feared, Chelsea Manning has said. The whistleblower spoke out after being awarded the Sam Adams prize for Integrity in Intelligence.

In a written statement posted on the Pvt. Manning Support Network, Chelsea Manning said the US is moving towards what the American constitution was written to prevent. Following the attacks on the Pentagon and the World Trade Center, “the American government has been pursuing an unprecedented amount of secrecy and power consolidation in the Executive branch, under the President and the Cabinet,” Manning wrote.

Referencing a recent Freedom of Information case, when the US government declined to release documents on targeted killings that it deemed harmful to national security, Manning called the White House’s approach “seemingly Orwellian.”

In the case, the New York Times and the American Civil Liberties Union argued that the practice of targeted killing of US citizens was a matter of public interest, and information pertaining to it should be available.

However, the court concluded the American government had “not violated the FOIA (Freedom of Information Act) by refusing to turn over the documents sought in the FOIA requests, and [could not] be compelled . . . to explain in detail the reasons why [the Government's] actions do not violate the Constitution and laws of the United States.”

According to Manning, such cases represent a critical problem in US society and raise the issue of the “level of secrecy, obfuscation, and classification or protective marking.” He argues that although the American government claims it is trying to protect the citizens of their nation, it is breeding “a unilateralism that the founders feared, and deliberately tried to prevent when drafting the American Constitution.”

“When the public lacks the ability to access what its government is doing, it ceases to be involved in the governing process,” said Manning, highlighting there is a line to be drawn between tyranny and freedom.

Chelsea Manning (formerly Bradley Manning) was sentenced in August 2013 to 35 years in prison for 20 charges including espionage, theft and violating computer regulations. The charges relate to the 700,000-odd Iraq and Afghanistan battle reports he released to whistleblowing website, WikiLeaks, in 2010 while he was working as an intelligence analyst in Iraq.

The Sam Adams Prize was awarded to Manning “for casting much-needed daylight on the true toll and cause of civilian casualties in Iraq; human rights abuses by US and ‘coalition’ forces, mercenaries, and contractors; and the roles that spying and bribery play in international diplomacy.”

The award ceremony was held last month and Manning was awarded the prize in absentia, as he is currently incarcerated at Leavenworth Prison.

Comments (24)


Donna Marie 23.02.2014 08:32

There have been so many that were prosecuted for wrong doing while serving in Iraq . If they committed war crimes they were and still being tried and punished . Some how people are getting the impression that crimes are going unpunished . Sorry we in the US are not living in prison .We have the freedom you will never know about . Funny part is the people that are commenting from Russia . Manning would be in prison just for what he is . He would be dead if he had leaked something about Russia ,so would Snowden. The propaganda is getting to a comical point on RT . How long did the something Riots spend in prison ?


Ana 22.02.2014 18:29

Tessa 21.02.2014 23:49

...The world is erupting in protest against tyranny, but here in the US it is expected and accepted..


You were on the right path to the truth all way long to the pre-end of your comment. Than you s.crew it up, sorry. The world is not erupting in protest against tyranny. There's no such pro.found tyranny in the world as US is. People went to erupting protests by being exposed to the same methods of conditioning their minds (as american people are) to give up their existing freedoms to EUUS-elite promising to 'protect them and take care about them'.


Ana 22.02.2014 18:03

Mark Hall 22.02.2014 02:00

Perhaps Manning should remember his oath to protect America.May God bless America.


Perhaps your should call the governmet to remeber the oath to serve american people and their rights to freedom. May God bless American people, sure, but I am afraid it will not happen as long as most of them are accepting evil government's order, in selfish (and stupid) hope to grab a promised 'piece of heavens' for themselves. Hats down to Manning and Snowden, but they are left alone. Where is the rest of americans? I'm not sure Manning would prefer US prison over death.

View all comments (24)
Add comment

Authorization required for adding comments

Register or



Show password


or Register

Request a new password


or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:


or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile



New password

Retype new password

Current password



Follow us