VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД FIND US ON: YouTube Twitter
breakingnews
Go to main page   News   Estonian doctor trashes Russian patient’s passport  
MORE ON THE STORY
22.08.2009, 08:28 42 comments

Latvia equates Stalinism and Nazism

Russian and Jewish groups have hit out at a new Latvian national holiday that commemorates the victims of Stalinism and Nazism on the same day.

Image from Toivo's photostream 06.08.2009, 17:25 2 comments

Estonia re-enacts WWII anti-soviet failure

Estonia is holding its annual military exercise based on the 1941 behind-the-frontline raid of the Erna group. The group, which was Nazi-supported, fought soviet troops during WWII in Estonian territory, but was crushed.

26.05.2009, 16:04 15 comments

“Estonia has an apartheid regime”

The criminal discrimination of Russians is part of Estonia’s apartheid regime, as Johan Bäckman, a political historian and author whose book “The Bronze Soldier” has been the cause of much controversy, told RT.

image from rus.delfi.ee / Andres Putting 09.05.2009, 21:33 3 comments

Tallinn police remove replicas of Soviet memorials

Estonian police have removed a memorial plaque from the centre of the capital, Tallinn. It bore the name of Capt. Ivan Sysoyev, a Soviet officer killed in the battles for Tallinn in September 1944.

AFP Photo / Ali Al-Saadi 23.10.2010, 09:36 14 comments

Poisonous US weapons in Iraq kill thousands and mar generations

US commanders in Iraq ignored evidence of torture and the murder of civilians. These are the major findings from the leak of 400,000 secret American military files from the whistle-blowing website WikiLeaks.

Demonstrators protest outside the Swedish embassy in Tel Aviv against the Swedish government's refusal to condemn articles in the afternoon tabloid Aftonbladet claiming that Israeli soldiers had trafficked the organs of dead Palestinians (AFP Photo / Jack Guez) 22.12.2009, 10:09 10 comments

Israel admits harvesting organs of dead Palestinians

Israel has admitted to unlawfully taking organs from dead people, including Palestinians, in the 1990s without the prior permission of the families of the donors.

Irina Belenkaya (R) and Jean-Michel Andre with Eliza (AFP Photo / Attila Kisbenedek / Michel Gangne) 26.09.2009, 14:59 5 comments

Russian mother’s rights violated, French NGO claims

The French human rights organization “Stop Violence” has accused the French and Hungarian governments of violating the rights of Russian citizen Irina Belenkaya and her daughter Eliza Andre.

The defendants Roland K.(R) and Wilhelm D. (L) arrive at the district court in Traunstein near Munich on February 8, 2010 (AFP Photo DDP / Joerg Koch Germany out) 09.02.2010, 05:10

Aged men’s old-fashioned justice

A criminal trial is underway in the German city of Munich of five pensioners who found themselves in the dock after kidnapping a man who allegedly speculated with about $2.5 million of their money.

22.10.2010, 17:46 4 comments

Estonian kids post kill-a-Russian prank on Internet

A group of underage Estonians have posted a homemade video on the YouTube channel in which they “killed” a Russian of their own age. Estonian law enforcers had to intervene, getting YouTube to remove the video.

Kyrgyz special unit police officers stand by during patrol at a check point in Osh on June 17, 2010 (AFP Photo / Viktor Drachev) 18.06.2010, 20:19 6 comments

Kyrgyzstan asks Russia to send troops to defend strategic facilities

Kyrgyz authorities asked the Russian government to send forces to protect strategic targets in the conflict zone, but Moscow hasn’t responded yet, according to a source from the Russian Ministry of Defense.

Estonian doctor trashes Russian patient’s passport

Published: 03 September, 2009, 04:04
Edited: 22 October, 2010, 23:25

TAGS: Children, Conflict, Crime, Health, Scandal, Human rights, Baltic states


A doctor has been fired from an Estonian hospital for chucking the passport of a Russian patient into the dustbin because the teenager couldn’t speak Estonian.

The scandalous story, which drew heavy media attention, took place in the city of Kohtla-Järve in Ida-Viru County in northeastern Estonia, an area mainly populated by ethnic Russians.

The 14-year-old Dmitry came to see the orthopedist, Eiki Strauss over a leg injury.

According to novosti.err.ee, Dmitry’s mother Irina Gorokhova said that when her son came into the room, the doctor said “tere,” which means “hello” in Estonian. Dmitry answered “hello” in Russian. Then Strauss started to ask Dmitry questions in Estonian.

“The child was answering in Russian, telling that he bashed his leg and it was hurting badly,” Irina is quoted as saying.

When the doctor asked why Dmitry was speaking Russian, the boy said, “I can’t say the same in Estonian.”

Strauss’s reaction that followed was a bit weird, to say the least: He took the boy’s Estonian passport and tossed it in the trash, saying “you don’t need this passport since you don’t speak Estonian.”

According to Kaljo Mitt, the chief doctor at the hospital, when explaining his behavior Strauss referred to the law on the state language.

“In his comment, the doctor said he believes it’s obscene when a citizen with an Estonian passport doesn’t speak the Estonian language,” Mitt said. “He put the passport into a box under his desk.”

Strauss’s assistant then returned the document to Dmitry, who did, however, get medical help from the Russophobe doctor. But the patient’s parents, shocked by the incident, notified the police.

The following day the contract between Eiki Strauss and the hospital was terminated.

“His behavior really harmed the image of our clinic,” Mitt said. “And, I believe, affected the patient as well. Unfortunately, Ida-Viru Central Hospital can’t exclude such actions of medical personnel completely.”

The head of the hospital apologized to Dmitry and his parents, as well as to everyone else who might have been offended by Strauss’s actions.

But the story may not be over yet. According to the press service of the Estonian police department, the boy can bring his case to court and sue the orthopedist for punitive damages.

The doctor, for his part, also doesn’t seem to be ready to give up, and he may also take his case to court.

“I don’t rule out anything in this story,” he said in an interview with the Postimees newspaper. “The final decision, to go to court or not, will be made by my lawyer.”

Strauss believes the main argument he can use to support his case is the fact that, as he claims, the passport was thrown into a carton box but not into a dustbin, which would be an insult to both the citizen and the state that issued the document.

It’s not surprising the story got lots of media attention both in Estonia and Russia. The language issue has become a stumbling block in post-Soviet, and especially Baltic, states.

+14 (22 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
The "Arctic Sea" vessel 03.09.2009, 02:50 3 comments

“Arctic Sea” intercepted by Israel over missiles cargo?

The story about the hijacked Russian-crewed cargo ship grows ever more mysterious. Time magazine is alleging that the “Arctic Sea” was intercepted by Israel as it carried weapons to the Middle East.

Beloved Stalin is the People's Happiness - Soviet poster(image from www.davno.ru) 03.09.2009, 10:44 12 comments

Furore over Stalin’s return to Moscow metro

The restoration of a Moscow metro station has revived debate over how Russians view the Soviet leader Joseph Stalin. The station features an inscription from the 1950s, praising the man.

sevodnya_net October 22, 2010, 23:22
0

> "I see many on daily bases from all over the world many of which have british citizenship and yet speak little or no english." As you ought to know it is mandatory to speak English before having British citizenship. So you are either being "economical with the truth" there, or those citizenships have been come by illegally, or there were other circumstances.

The Refleks December 22, 2009, 17:21
0

I can understand where the doctor was coming from - people living permanently in Estonia should learn Estonian, just like I had to learn English when I came to Canada. However, his duty is to do no harm and it takes precedence over anything else. He should not be a doctor.

Memphissigncompany December 22, 2009, 04:17
0

Wow looks like a racist doctor to me. Even if he did not like the boy speaking in Russian, he has a duty to help him. If the boy was rude, he could have sent him to another doctor. Just be a doctor and help the human child.