Female genital mutilation – tradition or torture?
Published: 26 June, 2009, 20:45
Edited: 24 August, 2010, 17:06
TAGS: Children, Health, Africa, Asia, Middle East, Human rights, Law
Female genital mutilation, usually associated with Africa, the Middle East and South-East Asia, is a growing problem in Europe. Despite criticism, the barbaric practice is thriving with more immigrants coming to Europe.
The operation, in which parts of a girl’s clitoris and labia are cut off, causes urine retention, infertility and death, and those lucky enough to survive such a process will never enjoy sexual relations. UNICEF says over 130 million women and girls are suffering from the aftermath of this procedure worldwide.
“The blood pumped out in waves. Words can't describe the pain. The bleeding was so bad I was rushed to hospital. That is why I am celibate to this day,” remembers Christine Beynis, one of the victims, living in Paris.
The annual circumcision event begins and ends with prayer services. (Stephanie Sinclair) |
“It’s my tradition, my grandmother and ancestors are all excisors. No one’s ever died after my operations,” she said.
Critics insist the practice is barbaric and must be stopped regardless of cultural traditions. Lawyer Linda Weil-Curiel, who put Greou behind bars, has to fight white male colleagues, who say banning foreign tradition is neocolonialism, and dub the method “female circumcision”.
“They would use the word circumcision, which I will not hear of. Because if you did to a young man what
is done to a young woman, he wouldn't say I have been circumcised, he would say I have been mutilated, and right he would be, because it’s equivalent to chopping off the penis for the boy, so for the girl it’s the clitoris and the labia,” the lawyer said.

The girl who was being soothed in the second photograph, after her circumcision. (Stephanie Sinclair)
Hawa Greou now says mutilation is wrong, but in many communities girls will continue to be cut, and men order the crime to be committed. Officials say France alone has more than 50,000 victims.
Linda Weil-Curiel's success in court made the state go after the practitioners, but has just pushed the problem elsewhere. Even though the practitioner case has led to France convicting mothers who mutilate their daughters, many instead take their children on special “holidays” abroad.
Ines Laufer, founder of the Hamburg-based Task Force for Effective Prevention of Female Genital Mutilation, says there is a solution.
“I think in Germany authorities have gone in the right direction,” Mrs. Laufer told RT.
“We already have several court decisions that stop girls from being taken to the country where they are at risk of being submitted to genital mutilation. In Germany 14 girls are being protected already – their parents have not been allowed to take them to the countries.”
Genital mutilation, she says, simply cannot be justified.
“All the girls, all the children who live here [in Europe] and abroad have a fundamental right to an intact body, to physical and mental health,” Mrs. Laufer said. “And banning genital mutilation is nothing more than guaranteeing this fundamental human right to the children.”
“The best way of addressing this problem is through education,” said Dr. Abdelhadi Eltahir, a senior adviser to the Washington-based Maternal and Newborn Health at Pathfinder International. “They have to realize that this practice is harmful.”
This practice can be stopped, says victim Khady Koita. 20 years after her own daughter was mutilated, Khady has written a book about it and is fighting the practice. It has nothing to do with religion, but is rather a tradition, says Khady. And can be stopped through dialogue, she says.
26.06.2009, 20:25
3 comments
“I’ve seen Kim Jong Il and he’s OK”Kim Jong Il is feeling well and has no problems with his memory, says the director of Russia’s Moiseyev Ballet, who just returned from tour in North Korea. |
26.06.2009, 21:12
3 comments
Medvedev looking for diamonds in the rough in AngolaDiamonds, oil and gas were the key topics discussed by Russia and Angola during President Dmitry Medvedev's visit to the country. |
Some people need to be circumcised, cough, even though Jesus didn't like it, lamenting that it was a "New Creation not Circumcision." galatians 6:15 I'm surprised that they don't use that verse more.
I'm confused about whatever you're going on about, MinaJuJu, because I don't see anybody outright calling anyone inferior (I'm not disagreeing with you, I just don't understand where that came from because I take a while to catch on; sorry buddy.) And hey, Thousand, I understand it's not an entirely Islamic practice. I don't know as much about different cultures as I'd like, but, just saying. At least one other person commenting understands this *flail* Anyway, about the practice itself, I just don't support this kind of torture on anyone for any reason :( These children should be protected. Ignoring that the reasons themselves seem sexist and ludicrous in the first place, nothing but physical and emotional trauma can come out of it. Nobody should be forced to go through something like that *shudder* It really is mutilation. That's not the same thing as circumcision. I've read/heard about it before. Granted, I'm not expert, nor do I claim to be one. Only giving an opinion. I'm all for cultural differences, traditions, being proud of your heritage and all that, but this doesn't have anything to do with being proud of who you are or celebrating your heritage. It's like reducing women to animals and saying they don't even have the right to say what happens to their own bodies.













"When in Rome, do as the Romans do." If these barbarians wish to mutilate their women, then them do it back in their own countries and answer to God for it. Why should we in the West be forced to accomodate something which is fundamentally anathema for us? They don't even allow Westerners to drink alcohol in their Muslim homelands and enforce it strictly without criticism from us, but we must allow them their practices in our countries? No, it is wrong and one-eyed! Let them make up their minds where they wish to live and by whose rules they wish to live.