VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД FIND US ON: YouTube Twitter
breakingnews
Go to main page   News   Georgians question alliance with the US  
MORE ON THE STORY
AFP Photo/ Nina Shlamova 15.08.2009, 06:23 6 comments

USA: Georgia to fight Taliban

The US is training the Georgian army to fight the Taliban in Afghanistan. The State Department says the first group of American troops will arrive in Tbilisi within several days.

11.08.2009, 13:16 12 comments

US media leaves Ossetian war anniversary untouched

On the first anniversary of the war in South Ossetia, many in the region are taking time to reflect. In the US, however, there’s almost no mention of the conflict, so heavily covered just a year ago.

10.08.2009, 20:57 3 comments

“Saakashvili will never acknowledge blame for the war”

There is still a long way to go before Georgia recognizes its responsibility for the August conflict, says Mikhail Stolyarov of the Russian State Academy of Public Service, a leading research center.

09.08.2009, 16:43 1 comment

We were Saakashvili’s next target – Abkhazia

Church services to commemorate the victims of the war in South Ossetia are held in Abkhazia. Many in the Republic think that if Georgia had achieved its plan to crush South Ossetia, they would have been the next target.

02.08.2009, 10:53 15 comments

Russia to use force if Georgian shelling continues

Russia says it is prepared to use force to protect its troops and civilians in South Ossetia if Georgia continues its military provocations, according to Russian officials.

04.08.2010, 22:41 8 comments

Moscow calls on world to stop selling weapons to Georgia – official

Moscow insists that the international community should refrain from selling weaponry to Georgia, Russia's Deputy Foreign Minister Grigory Karasin has said.

26.08.2009, 22:19 8 comments

“Saakashvili did something very stupid and very wicked in attacking Tskhinvali”

“Russia, I suppose, had to respond to that [Georgian assault], but the way it responded… was devastating to its image,” says Donald Rayfield, professor of Georgian and Russian Studies at the University of London.

29.07.2010, 17:07 19 comments

Saakashvili prepares for war with Russia

Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili has called on military top brass to build “total defense” and accused Russia of planning to “overthrow Georgian democracy.”

11.08.2010, 17:03 7 comments

Abkhazia hosts S-300 air defense unit

The Russian military has deployed an S-300 long-range air defense system on the territory of Abkhazia. Georgia sees the move as a threat to its security.

Iraq, Shaibah Base  (AFP Photo / Maurice Mcdonald / WPA Pool) 25.01.2010, 06:21 5 comments

Bring the boys back home

The United Kingdom should stop fighting distant wars and meddling in global military matters. That’s the view of Kim Howells, who until last year was the minister responsible for Afghanistan.

Georgians question alliance with the US

Published: 16 August, 2009, 09:21
Edited: 09 August, 2010, 01:29

Georgia's President Mikheil Saashvili and a U.S. military instructor

(13.9Mb) embed video

TAGS: Breakaway regions, Conflict, Military, Georgia, Ossetian War, Protest, Politics, Mass media


While the US is sending marines to Georgia to train a Georgian battalion, set to be deployed on a mission in Afghanistan next spring, ordinary people in Georgia are not so sure the country has chosen the right friend.

As Tbilisi and Washington work together, Georgia looks like a pressure cooker waiting to explode – like it did last summer when Georgian president Mikheil Saakashvili chose to attack the breakaway republic of South Ossetia.

“There are conflicts in every society, but here they are happening all the time. Because of the geopolitical location of Georgia, [the efforts of] a lot of powerful countries in the world are concentrated in this region. The possibility exists for the whole Caucasus to catch fire at any time,” says sociology and philosophy professor Shota Kvirtia, who lost his wife seventeen years ago when war engulfed the region of Abkhazia, which was fighting for its independence from Georgia.

And many in Georgia believe last year’s war in South Ossetia was just a rehearsal for what will be the real showdown.

“For almost twenty years, Americans have been in charge of everything here. The Georgian government will not even sneeze without permission from America. That's why such a serious business as conducting war could not have been done without its backing,” says Tariel Gagnidze, of the Historical Heritage Foundation, angrily. He believes the Georgian government is fabricating facts and selling lies about what’s really going on.

“Moreover, when Americans are financing the whole military infrastructure, all military budgets, all military expenses – it’s impossible to start an action without America’s involvement,” asserts Gagnidze.

That involvement is evident everywhere on the streets of Tbilisi, but it does not mean the two sides understand each other, and many Georgians think America is foe rather than friend.


Dead Georgian soldier in South Ossetia, August 2008

Irakli Todua , Editor-in-Chief of one of the few remaining independent Georgian newspapers – Georgia and the World – believes Russia had no choice but to intervene last August.

“Russia had to get involved in this conflict. If it hadn't, it would have escalated and more countries would have become involved,” says Todua.

Though his newspaper has not been closed down, its offices have been raided. Irakli says it is because he presented a view of the conflict that was markedly different from that of the government's.

In his opinion “it was a tragedy what happened between Russia and Georgia, and if there was the possibility for Russia to have avoided the conflict, I believe they would have.”

But the wounds of the war are still open, and people are confused whom to trust.

“I was in the Russian Federation and I saw it for myself that the Russians are not so angry with Georgian people. I found the opposite picture. Of course the propaganda machine works, but the people still have the mind and they still have the memory,” says Nana Japaridze, a member of the King Irakli II Historical Society, with optimism. She devotes her time to reminding Georgians about their shared heritage with their bigger neighbor.

Immediately after the war in South Ossetia, Russia was blamed for an excessive use of force against its much weaker neighbor, Georgia, and, in some instances, even for unleashing the war itself.

A year on, however, the international community has for the most part recognized that it was Georgian aggression that provoked Moscow's reaction.

Georgia's president Mikheil Saakashvili has come under fire, not just from abroad, but also at home for leading his country into a needless crisis.

downloadembed
.

“I said to him last August that he should do everything possible and even impossible to avoid any kind of military confrontation with Russia and that he should not involve the country in military actions,” said Georgian Parliamentary Speaker Nino Burdzhanadze.

She  predicted that “otherwise we will receive very serious problems and our army will be defeated by the Russian army for sure, and Russia will recognize Abkhazia and South Ossetia. That evening he told me that he understood that quite well. But unfortunately he acted in a different way.”

+29 (45 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
Freighter "Arctic Sea” 16.08.2009, 08:20 5 comments

Ransom demand received for missing Arctic Sea

Police in Finland say the owner of the missing freighter "Arctic Sea” has received a demand for a ransom, suggesting the involvement of pirates. Meanwhile, the ship's location is still unknown.

16.08.2009, 09:43

Stand up and fight!

The American-led effort to bring stability to Afghanistan may take decades - that's the verdict of some of the coalition’s top military thinkers.

Brandy July 17, 2011, 09:07
0

Whoa, thgins just got a whole lot easier.

GarryB August 08, 2010, 11:02
+2

A lot of comments involve Big Russia vs little poor defenceless Georgia. Ignorance is bliss I guess. If the 15,000 or so troops from a backwater region that were cobbled together in a hurry and equipped with stuff that was obsolete even within a military organisation that has a lot of old stuff, with last minute planning can be described as Big Russia, while Georgian forces of at least 20,000 men with large artillery forces (Artillery is ideal for dealing with lightly armed Russian paratroopers because their better training and combat counts for nothing when the artillery is 10s of kms away) with Israeli and US upgraded equipment, and of course the element of surprise by attacking during the opening ceremony of the Olympic games (Traditionally a time of ceasefires rather than invasions), it was pretty clear that it was all planned and prepared well in advance, and clearly the hope on the US and Georgian side was that it would be all over by the time the Russians could move forces into the area through the single tunnel that connects Russia to South Ossetia. There is no way the Georgians would try something like that without permission. Even Saddam wouldn't have invaded Kuwaite all those years ago without mentioning his plans to the US and getting the green light. Sadly for Saddam he got the yellow light and thought it was green from an idiot that didn't know what they were doing. In fact that same idiot screwed up in Somalia as well and the resulting problems with Adide led to more American deaths there too. Now there are Russian forces in place and they have proper equipment and they are working on their command and control structure, which was woeful during the conflict. Another conflict will be truely one sided.

Maria Kuznetsova July 30, 2010, 15:13
0

I personally think that Russia has to bin Georgia. Can Russia afford the war which would lead Russia into the draining of its resources and becoming less powerfull when facing possible furute military conflict with some more powefull countries? Georgian people did choose their president themselves -so they have to face the challenge and change situation it their country themselves too! Maria