Keep up with the news by installing RT’s extension for . Never miss a story with this clean and simple app that delivers the latest headlines to you.

 

3,000 euro Google search: French blogger gets fined for re-posting indexed govt files

Published time: February 10, 2014 17:45
Olivier Laurelli (Photo by Flickr user 4M Tunis)

Olivier Laurelli (Photo by Flickr user 4M Tunis)

A French appeals court has fined an activist 3,000 euros for publishing documents accessed via an open hyperlink in a Google search. The “hacker” was prosecuted despite the fact that the government agency owning the files didn’t pursue a case against him.

For the French blogger, Olivier Laurelli, nicknamed “Bluetouff,” it all started with a simple Google search. While browsing the web for what he claims was an irrelevant subject, the co-founder of the tech-savvy activist news site Reflets.info came across a link to an online documents archive of the French National Agency for Food Safety, Environment, and Labor (ANSES).

The link led to a trove of 7.7 Gigabytes of files on public health, and Laurelli decided they might be worth looking through. For what he later said was for more convenient reading, the activist downloaded the entire online directory with a common Linux tool, and then transferred them to his desktop.

At the time, the blogger judged that the freely available documents of a public establishment “ought to be” legally available for the public to see, quotes the Ars Technica blog.

But soon after posting some scientific slides from the archives on his website, Laurelli realized that he was wrong.
ANSES discovered their archive was accessed only after the slides on “nano-substances” went public on Reflets.info, French media said. Citing possible “intrusion into a computer system and data theft from a computer,” the agency filed a report with the police, also prompting the French Central Directorate of Interior Intelligence (DCRI) to launch a case.

According to the activist himself, the investigators’ decision to pursue a criminal case against him was fueled by the fact he used a Virtual Private Network (VPN) service that masked his IP address as a Panamanian one. The VPN was actually provided by a security company he owned called Toonux.

Laurelli was then indicted with fraudulently accessing and keeping data, which, according to the French Criminal Code carries up to 2 years in prison and a maximum fine of 30,000 euro (about $41,000).

While testifying, Laurelli admitted he did spot a requirement for login and password at an upper level directory when he tried browsing the ANSES resource further, but there was no explicit indication that the directly accessible files he stumbled on required authorization and were illegal to obtain.

A screenshot from an archived version of anses.fr

To its own embarrassment, ANSES then discovered the suspected “hacker” did not need to do any hacking as such, because “it was sufficient to have the full URL to access the resource on the extranet in order to bypass the authentication rules on this server.”

The criminal court eventually ruled that Laurelli could not be penalized for accessing data that was not secure. ANSES decided not to pursue any further civil action.

However, the case did not end there as the DCRI decided to appeal the decision and punish the “hacktivist.”

A French court of appeals last week stated that Laurelli was “conscious of his irregular retention of automated data processing,” and still “disseminated” the data to others, and made copies of it “without the knowledge and against the will of its owner.” For this, the court decided to fine the blogger 3,000 euros ($4,100).

The precedent, branded one of the most expensive Google searches in history, caused outrage and concern not only inside France’s tech community, but also among some of the media outlets.

“You can be called a hacker if you search something in Google and accidentally stumble upon documents that shouldn’t have been there in the first place,” Laurelli’s lawyer, Maitre Iteanu, was quoted as saying, calling the accusations “deplorable.”

Le Point has warned that any French citizen can now find oneself in Laurelli’s shoes: “This decision should unsettle all citizens, in particular journalists, who could themselves to be convicted much more heavily when they publish documents with the same motive: that of informing.”

Details of the hearing, which have recently emerged in local media, also offered internet users some food for ridicule, but also highlighted a “hugely troubling” situation in French courts.

French media outlets widely quoted the presiding judge as pronouncing Google as “gogleu” and not being able to comprehend what login is, which the judge allegedly referred to as “lojin.” Even more ridiculous appeared to be the statement attributed to the prosecutor, who is said to have uttered: “half the words I heard today, I did not even understand.”

Laurelli himself addressed the issue with humor, tweeting that he is now “officially a cybercriminal.” A sarcastic page on a “public extranet” was also created on Reflets.info, redirecting those who “have the courage” to click a hyperlink to a hidden directory to a site which reads in French:

“Lost on the Internet?
Do not worry, we’ll help you
* <----- You are here”

Comments (8)

 

Gary David 11.02.2014 16:20

The world Corporations who joined together are the ones responsible for the takeover of many Governments. This is what the worlds people need to do to defeat them. Alas they instigate the hatred we have for each other to keep economic war from stopping. Their enemy is peace and their arms are very long indeed. All truthtellers are their enemy including this unfortunate man who obviously did nothing wrong at all.

 

itsme1248 11.02.2014 04:28

Johnfelix12345 67 11.02.2014 00:25

(Thanks to Russia Today for relative free speech on their website.)

  


Surely, you jest.

 

Johnfelix1234567 11.02.2014 00:25

(Thanks to Russia Today for relative free speech on their website.)

View all comments (8)
Add comment

Authorization required for adding comments

Register or

Name

Password

Show password

Register

or Register

Request a new password

Send

or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:

OK

or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile

X

Name

New password

Retype new password

Current password

Save

Cancel

Follow us

Follow us