Poland accuses Russian TV channel of rewriting history
Published: 26 June, 2009, 13:40
Edited: 13 August, 2010, 03:48
Signing of the Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact, August 23, 1939
TAGS: Conflict, Politics, Europe
Poland’s Foreign Ministry has issued an official protest to their Russian counterparts over a history documentary, part of which was aired last Sunday. They say the film puts part of the blame for World War II on Warsaw.
The film produced and shown by the national Channel Rossiya tells the story of the treaty between Nazi Germany and Soviet Union signed in 1939, the Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact. The non-aggression agreement had a secret protocol dividing Eastern Europe between German and Soviet spheres of influence. This later led to Germany and the Soviet Union annexing the corresponding territories.
The documentary claims that Warsaw was trying to sink down Germany’s plans to secure Moscow’s neutrality and invade Poland by convincing Japan to attack Soviet Union in the Far East.
“Poland has reasons to see Hitler as an ally, namely the 1934 treaty. In its secret part Berlin and Warsaw promised each other military help,” says in the film its author, journalist Ilya Kanavin.
Warsaw believes this documentary puts part of the blame for the beginning of World War II on Poland, reports on Friday Kommersant daily. A note of protest published by the Polish embassy in Moscow brands the documentary as “a vivid attempt to falsify history” and “a clumsy attempt to review the work of both Polish and Russian historians.” It also lashes at the authors for failing to mention that the Soviet Union violated a non-aggression agreement with Poland when it invaded the country in 1939.
The embassy suggests that the film should be considered by the presidential commission formed recently to fight against revisionism.
Channel officials so far have not commented the accusations, while the foreign ministry said it was confused about why this issue was addressed to it.
“Opinions voiced by TV channels should not be subject of consideration of official agencies. What times exactly is it suggested that we return to? There’s freedom of speech,” the response of the European department of the ministry says.
Speaking unofficially, a source in the ministry said Poland was using double standards.
“If we drew attention to everything said on Polish national channels about Russia and Soviet history, it would have been another case,” the diplomat told the newspaper.
Poland and Russia have quite a number of past and present grudges, which the countries find difficult to overcome. On Wednesday, Nezavisimaya Gazeta newspaper reported that at least one of them – the dispute over the Katyn massacre – may soon be closed. The mass killing of Polish prisoner soldiers and officers by Soviet secret police has been marring bilateral relations between Moscow and Warsaw for years, but thanks to the work of a commission for settlement of the issue it may be taken away from the political agenda soon.
The settlement, which entails Russia giving Poland access to classified material on the case in exchange for shelving it, is expected before September this year, when Prime Minister Putin is to visit Poland to take part in commemorations dedicated to the beginning of World War II, the newspaper says.
26.06.2009, 11:45
Changing tactics in Afghanistan an easy task?As international forces continue their operation in Afghanistan, the situation is still tense. In a nation at war, how can NATO troops bring peace? RT military analyst Eugene Khrushchev says that it is not an easy task. |
26.06.2009, 15:14
2 comments
Berezovsky sentenced to 13 yearsSelf-exiled tycoon Boris Berezovsky has been found guilty in absentia of the embezzlement of assets belonging to Russia’s biggest carmaker AvtoVAZ and sentenced to 13 years in prison, Interfax news agency reports. |
Historical facts are – historical. However, let’s take the present generations who – on either way – inherited the previous ones and reflect their predecessors (consciously and unconsciously). Who is pressing Eastern Europe today, West or East neighbors? East Europe is not willing to admit that it has over-paid for the moderate extent of pressure from the West packed in NATO cellophane. So what is the difference – from East Europe point of view – between the two vectors coming from West and East? Their resultant there is zero. But – what makes them zeroed exactly in East Europe? Why they don’t zero in Germany? The answer is – our non-sovereignty. And whatever the excuses about our “mediating” cause of being the victims “in-between” – we stay only as the negative constant among two or more sovereignties. Yugoslavia has been the most expressive damage using this morally speculative trash. The extent of damage is in the character Tito left in the present people totally unable to perceive sovereignty as a challenge beyond the price. Only Serbs still feel it in the stomach as the not-vomited substance. Easter Europe is the graveyard of our destiny sunk in self-zeroing. Neither West, nor Russia belongs to this misery! We in East Europe remained – consumable part of past and future “historical facts”. Our misery is the ultimate expression of the whole region being left without reality or – being full of churches including those destroyed – without religion. How come – the communism in Russia did never loose reality or religion, what is the same thing? Because, Russian responsibility has been expressed in fighting to maintain the sovereignty. How many industrial directors in USSR ended loosing the heads? It is quite a list. But find one on the Tito’s list; he was using only the irresponsible selective code, pretending today to the precious left-legacy!?
Now there's a novel twist! Moscow, along with Hitler, attack, partition and occupy Poland, commit horrific atrocities against its people and maintain their stranglehold over the country until their own states collapse from underneath them -- and it is all Poland's fault! Absolutely brilliant -- why didn't I think of that?
this site's coverage is totally russian-biased. is there really still a "debate" over what happened in Poland during WWII? I'm not surprised, the Russians themselves are in the dark ages when it comes to history. What an insult, as though the Poles were somehow partly to blame for what happened to them... Russia partly won the war, so inherited Polish land, controlled the Polish people. Simple.