Pregnant Dominican girl dies as abortion ban delays leukemia treatment

Published time: August 18, 2012 17:46
Edited time: August 18, 2012 21:46
Reuters / Edgard Garrido

The mother of a Dominican teenage girl is accusing doctors of not putting her daughter’s health first after the girl died when her body failed to respond to chemotherapy. The treatment was delayed over fears it would abort the girl’s pregnancy.

­The 16-year-old girl, whose name has not been officially disclosed, grabbed the world’s attention after doctors dragged out her leukemia treatment because of an abortion ban provided by the Dominican Republic’s Constitution.

The Constitution states “the right to life is inviolable from the moment of conception and until death,” which is interpreted quite straightforwardly in courts.

Diagnosed with acute leukemia, the girl was admitted to Semma Hospital in Santo Domingo, but had to wait some 20 days for treatment – doctors feared beginning aggressive chemotherapy as radiation could have aborted the pregnancy. Finally, they gave in Tuesday, public pressure increasing.

Friday, the girl died.

As a blood transfusion began Thursday, the teen’s body rejected it and failed to respond to the chemotherapy altogether, Dr. Antonio Cabrera, the legal representative for the hospital, told CNN.

Her condition rapidly worsening, the girl suffered a miscarriage Friday morning. Cardiac arrest followed. Attempts to revive the girl having failed, the official reason for her death was recorded as complications from her disease.

"They have killed me, I'm dead, dead. I'm nothing," says Rosa Hernandez, the girl’s mother. "She was the reason for my existence. I no longer live."

The incident stirred controversy and heated discussion with the Catholic Church and the Dominican public. Given the strict abortion rules, Hernandez had to apply both to the doctors and the government for an exception to be made for her daughter.

"My daughter's life is first. I know that [abortion] is a sin and that it goes against the law … but my daughter's health is first," Hernandez said.

At the moment of her the death, the fetus was 10-13 weeks old, according to various media.

Comments (7)

Huh? German Housewife (unregistered) 23.08.2012 05:58

German housewife (unregistered) wrote in #5 As i understand the story, the treatment was delayed but as the mother insisted on it, carried out anyway, and the treatment (not the illness itself) lead to the death of child and mother. I disagree strongly to rename sideeffects of treatments as "complications" of an illness, if the illness itself without treatment would not develope such complications. Furt hermore, chemotherapy is controversal, as it is (recently) proven to trigger cancer growth.  There are also controversial views on leukemia. In most cases, the people lack confidence and this is processed on an organic level somewhere in the bones, they will degrade until its recognizable as anemia. Once the people find confidence the bones recover and this is what you call leukemia. It surely is painful, because of the internal pressure on the nerves in the bone-skin, but if left untreated it is almost never deadly, it is one of those things you just need to ride out. Some years ago it was seldom treated at all, because it was viewed as harmless. It's crazy how people are brainwashed into killing themselves with such treatments while blaming the illness, just by sarcastic interpretation. If the treatment lead to her death once aplied, than an earlier treatment would only have resulted in an ealier death, and although i wouldn't go as far as to say that its all the mothers own fault to have guided her daughter along this destructive path, i'd surely say she should face the fact, that she shares responsibility, and has to accept the consequences of what she (and her daughter) choosed to believe in.  this comment makes absolutely no sense.  Do you have children?

0

Undo

A. Nonymous (unregistered) 19.08.2012 12:12


Earth to "German Mother" poster... Anemia and Lukemia are not related. Yes, the are both blood disorders, but that is where similarities end. Also, how could you possibly think that both diseases are related to someone's level of confidence. That just doesn't make any sense.  Anemia is when  ody doesn't produce enough red blood cells, and lukemia is when white blood cells are damaged a the DNA level.

+2

Undo

German housewife (unregistered) 19.08.2012 11:38

As i understand the story, 
the treatment was delayed but as the mother insisted on it, carried out anyway, 
and the treatment (not the illness itself) lead to the death of child and mother. 

I disagree strongly to rename sideeffects of treatments as "complications" of an illness, if the illness itself without treatment would not develope such complications. 
Furthermore, chemotherapy is controversal, as it is (recently) proven to trigger cancer growth.  

T here are also controversial views on leukemia. In most cases, the people lack confidence and this is processed on an organic level somewhere in the bones, they will degrade until its recognizable as anemia.
Once the people find confidence the bones recover and this is what you call leukemia. It surely is painful, because of the internal pressure on the nerves in the bone-skin, but if left untreated it is almost never deadly, it is one of those things you just need to ride out. Some years ago it was seldom treated at all, because it was viewed as harmless. 

I t's crazy how people are brainwashed into killing themselves with such treatments while blaming the illness, just by sarcastic interpretation.

If the treatment lead to her death once aplied, than an earlier treatment would only have resulted in an ealier death,
and although i wouldn't go as far as to say that its all the mothers own fault to have guided her daughter along this destructive path, i'd surely say she should face the fact, that she shares responsibility, and has to accept the consequences of what she (and her daughter) choosed to believe in.  



0

Undo

View all comments (7)
Add comment

By posting your comment, you agree to abide by our Posting rules

Log in to comment in full, or comment anonymously under character-limit restriction.

100 Text

– required fields

Register or

Name

Password

Show password

Register

or Register

Request a new password

Send

or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:

or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile

Name

New password

Retype new password

Current password

Save

Cancel

Follow us