Religious education debate far from over
Published: 21 July, 2009, 09:35
TAGS: Children, Religion, Russia
With schools preparing for the new academic year, the debate continues over whether religious education in Russia should be taught more widely – and whether it should become a school subject.
Unlike in many European countries, high school teaching of religion is not available in most Russian schools.
Russia’s President Dmitry Medvedev has suggested setting up an experiment in selected regions by including the basics of religious culture, religious history and basics of secular ethics into the school programs.
“I find it possible setting such an experiment. So far 18 regions are on mind, but the number can be discussed,” said Dmitry Medvedev.
On Tuesday, the President underlined, that “students and their parents must choose the subject by themselves.”
“This means it can be the basics of Orthodox culture or the basics of Muslim, Judaist or Buddhist culture,” explained Medvedev.
Another variant is also possible, he said.
“Most certainly many would like to study the variety of Russian religious life. For such students the general course of history of major traditional confessions of our country can be developed,” said the President.
For those who don’t have specific religious beliefs, can choose the third variant – studying secular ethics, Medvedev said.
If experiment proves to be a success, starting from 2012 religious education could be added to the school programme.
Two sides of a coin
There are four official religions in Russia – the dominant one being Orthodox Christianity, along with Islam, Buddhism and Judaism.
All kinds of religious faiths were repressed during the 70 years of Soviet rule, but since the fall of communism there has been a growing call for them to be taught.
“The foundation of each life is our understanding of good and evil. This is a key element of religion. In this modern age, people can easily find out that most arguments, most wars and conflicts, are the result of misunderstanding. If people have common sense, they can always discuss their problems and live in peace,” says Father Sergey Ribico, an Orthodox priest.
Veronika Agafonova, a mother of three, sends her children to one of Moscow’s private Orthodox Christian schools.
A devout believer herself, she feels the principles of religion will help restore cultural values and offer a higher level of education.
![]() Sunday sÑÂÂhool |
“Pupils pray before meals, before the beginning of the classes. Of course, if the family does not practice things like that at home, their child can find our school strange, but when children get information, they get a right to choose – it means that they are free,” Veronika says.
Others feel religious knowledge shouldn’t be something enforced, especially on children.
“A man should study the history of world religions, but the question is – at what age? Private schools can have religious classes because it was the parent’s decision to send their children there. But we can’t have theological education in public schools because we live in a secular state,” says Professor Yury Nisnevich from the People’s Friendship University of Russia.
Age might be one factor up for debate – but there is also the thornier issue of which religion will be discussed in schools.
Some members of Russian society are concerned that Orthodox Christianity might dominate and further increase the church’s influence in the country’s culture. Instead, unity between all faiths needs to be the key.
“People need to feel that the state cares about them and their children. This turns people into patriots. If we fail to do that, this will be a huge drawback for everyone,” says Imam Anavar-Khasrat Salaev, head of the Muslim community in Moscow.
“Law against animal cruelty not working in Ukraine”The incident with vet students who dissected a dead dog, and posted pictures on the web, again shows that the law against animal cruelty is not working in Ukraine, says Anna Karpova from the Alliance for Animal Rights. |
21.07.2009, 09:44
3 comments
The Israeli bus battle of the sexesWomen’s rights are being taken for a ride by a minority of ultra-Orthodox Jews in Israel. Female followers are often forced to sit at the back of buses in their own specially segregated section. |
The problem with Islam is that it does not teach you to be a patriot to your country on the contrary it teaches you to be loyal to your own co-religionists even at the expense of other non-Muslim inhabitants often in violent and brutal manner as we see across the world wither it be in Southern Russia, Thailand, the Middle East the Balkans, China, Africa and India. In fact across the world were Muslims reach a critical mass of per-population over there non-Christian inhabitants and there is success for likely rebellion and domination there is likely for violence. This is especially critical to Russia due to Muslim population growth, militants linked to foreign intelligence for geo-political advantage and organised crime and support financial, physical with foreign fighters and theological with Saudi sponsored religious schools and teachings. In the Crimea Tatars are seeking to expel ethnic Russians through large population growth in the area and organised militants attacks and support from the US and probably Yushchenko in Ukraine to be the dominant players in the region. Wouldn’t be surprised if Ukraine and the US were smuggling weapons to Crimean Tatars in the future to cause a civil conflict in the Crimea that would benefit Ukraine, EU and the US and expel the Russian Naval fleet there. According to F. William Engdahl Crimean Tatars are on the lists of people on the US catalogue of people or separatist groups supported by the US and there CIA affiliates under UNPO. http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=va&aid=14327 http://en.fondsk.ru/article.php?id=2167 http://en.fondsk.ru/article.php?id=2143 So expect to see a Balkans operation like they did in the former Yugoslavia against the Serbs.
I find this topic about religion in schools interesting. Because, everyone is religious. Religion is nothing more than one's "heart felt belief". From the Atheist to the Christian, they have heart felt beliefs. I have a website. ******. I ran for the Senate in America, not that I wanted to take up residence in the "District of Criminals". There is a section covering Education. It's short but interesting. Religion is taught in the schools, like it or not. Intellectual learning must run hand in hand with moral education. When one has a good intellect but no morals, what kind of a person is he? The American Founders taught: There is a God. He holds people accountable for there actions in the after life. Any religion can accept that. If you don't believe there is a God, who or what should you be accountable to?













While not wanting to unnecessarily reopen old wounds and pour salt on them for the sake of saying "See we told you so," from a (Catholic) Christian and American's perspective, Russian schools are taking a much better approach towards teaching about religion in their public schools than we, and EU nations are. Far better to present religious values extolling the principles of the Ten Commandments, Sermon On The Mount, etc., than to be ramming ideological notions in their heads such as totalitarian nations have done in the past. If teaching religion in public schools is considered "dangerous," may I ask "dangerous compared to what? ... Stalinism, and Naziism?" The millions of Christians in Russia lost to Stalinism alone, 20 million and counting, provide all the answers you need to settle this dispute. Russia is taking the right path on this issue. I only wish American public schools would drop their growing antipathy towards religion and Globalism, Multiculturalism and Moral Relativism. Keep it up Mother Russia. But with one favor, include more favorable mentions about your (Roman) Catholic cousins.