Joseph Stalin dead, denounced and debated

Published time: March 05, 2011 05:23
Edited time: March 05, 2011 18:05
Joseph Stalin (AFP Photo)
Embed

Joseph Stalin was called "the Father of the Nation" who brought the country through the war, but locked away in labor camps the heroes who helped him do it. 58 years after his death, the dispute over his legacy is still loud and clear.

Some of history's most notorious dictators, like Benito Mussolini, Adolf Hitler – or Joseph Stalin were for years adored by the people of their countries. The phenomenon of a personality cult has intrigued historians and psychologists alike.

The so-called "People's Father", Joseph Stalin, ruled the USSR with an iron fist, and despite the terrors, persecutions and executions, he was almost worshipped. This love is still something not easy to account for.

Psychoanalyst Gio Di Feo says it reminds him of the Stockholm syndrome, “where after you have been kidnapped by some bad person, you start loving him. The love is not true love, it is a way to save yourself, to keep your balance ok.

By the time the Soviet Union entered the Second World War, Stalin's personality cult was at an all-time high. Men and women of all ages were willing to lay down their lives, firmly believing that bravery and, ultimately, victory would guarantee them Stalin's approval.

Read more about Joseph Stalin in RT's Russiapedia

Lev Netto was 23 when he returned home from the battlefields. Having survived dozens of attacks, partisan missions and months in captivity, he was proud to be coming back alive. Proud to have accomplished what "comrade Stalin" had asked of him.

I remember being marched through a small Latvian town. The local women were all standing on the street, throwing things at us, spitting and shouting "Stalin's bandits!" says Lev Netto. “That’s what they called the partisans. And I remember feeling then a sort of pride, because being our leader's bandits somehow put us close to him, and we all wanted that. I had that feeling for a long time, until life set things straight.

In 1948, Lev Netto was accused of being a traitor and sentenced to 25 years in a labor camp. The charge was simple: he survived captivity, which to Stalin's mind meant he had sold out his country for his life. No proof was necessary. After three months of torture, Lev Netto was ready to sign any document.

"I refused to sign their so-called confessions, even after all the torture they put me through. But then they said "if you don't sign, we'll bring your parents here" – and I couldn't let them go through this. So I agreed,” says Netto.

After eight years in a labor camp in Norilsk, a town in Russia’s polar region, Lev Netto returned home – and the new Secretary General of the Soviet Union denounced Stalin's personality cult. The man who had twice been named Time Magazine's Person of the Year had all his carefully sculpted glory taken away.

Despite all the denunciations 55 years ago, Stalin still evokes mixed emotions to this day. The very fact that half a century later Stalin's actions are still debated and their emphasis on Russian past, present and future asserted, means the personality cult has survived to some extent.


Comments (179)

Svyatlana 16.03.2011 22:00

Bogdanov, in your reply to me you've asked and you've immediately answered. But I disagree with you - Belarusians are not Russians.

0

Undo

Bogdanov 16.03.2011 19:44

Svyatlana,
I find this pretty remarkable when you say -- "Belarus sooner or later will officially join the list of his victims"! If Belarusians were the victims of Russians, why they were not in the list before? Or now? Why we have to wait? I know why -- because it takes time for the propaganda to wash the brains. I cannot argue with you on that -- if you take a group (any size) of people who never knew about certain realities (e.g. the USSR) and let them being driven by another (small) group having specific agenda, then, without any doubts at the end the minds of those people will be twisted out and they will start seeing&nb sp;new reality... Now, lets suppose that ethnic Russians have such oppressors qualities and they torture Belarusians during the Soviet time. Then, it doesn't explain me why the leader of one of the Moscow gang (I aware of) was Belarusian. And it doesn't explain, as well, why my college friend (ethnic Russian) was killed by Belarusian mafia from Minsk. And it doesn't explain why so called "Russian" mafia, had only small percent of ethnic Russians in it. Does it ever occur to you that Belarusians were just part of the Soviet Union and, therefore, share all qualities of "Russians"? Another remarkable statement of yours -- "Baltic states now in the West"! So, the Baltic lands were taken and physically moved closer to Britain or the US? If you are talking about minds of Balts, then, it is possible they they might be shifted to praising Western values. That, though, doesn't make them being Westerners. In any way. They are who they are and who they were. I think, Georgians especially suffer from this syndrome -- picturing themselves by who they are not.

0

Undo

Svyatlana 16.03.2011 17:53

Bogdanov, if Khrushchev's failed policies were the USSR's internal affairs, Stalin's crimes were not. The three Baltic states now in the West, Poland was never a republic of the SU and Belarus sooner or later will officially join the list of his victims. And who knows, the ex-soviet Central Asia republics may something to add  as well. I don't expect you or PR101 elaborating on post-October revolution reforms there and the Turkistan movement as a result, which brings me to the conclusion that this topic's western psychoanalysis  may not work to mitigate mass crimes as a power tool in the Soviet-Stal inist history.  

0

Undo

View all comments (179)
Add comment

By posting your comment, you agree to abide by our Posting rules

Log in to comment in full, or comment anonymously under character-limit restriction.

100 Text

– required fields

Register or

Name

Password

Show password

Register

or Register

Request a new password

Send

or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:

or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile

Name

New password

Retype new password

Current password

Save

Cancel

Follow us