Keep up with the news by installing RT’s extension for . Never miss a story with this clean and simple app that delivers the latest headlines to you.


Fracking dilemma: Fresh water or cheap gas? The latter 'is not likely to happen'

Published time: November 25, 2013 16:04
A general view shows the Cuadrilla exploration drilling site in Balcombe in Balcombe in southern England, on August 15, 2013.  (AFP Photo)

Energy companies are giving people a very unhealthy choice: Whether to have cheap gas, which is unlikely to happen, or fresh water, former oil executive Ian Crane, now a campaigner against fracking, tells RT.

RT:  You gave up a lucrative career over fracking... why are you against it so much?

Ian Crane: Well, if we were looking at conventional oil and gas exploration I wouldn’t be sitting here talking with you. But this is the first attempt in the UK to exploit unconventional gas resources from shale. The track record in the UK is pretty dire. Out of the four wells drilled and fracked two of them resulted in seismic events in the peninsula. And a law moratorium was put on 2 1/2 years ago, that moratorium was lifted one year ago by Lord Browne, who advises David Cameron. But Lord Browne is also chairman of Cuadrilla, one of the companies that has very heavy interests in this operation. The real concern is that this is a technology that basically has been proven not to work as the oil industry claims, and it has resulted in an irrefutable evidence of contamination of water, soil and the air, and also significant negative health impacts on the population that live above the gas fields.

RT:  Pope Francis has reportedly said that he believes that fracking exploits the poor and their land. But there is a very strong economic argument, isn’t it? I mean all these people will be compensated after, won’t they?

IC: I don’t think it really matters what the economic argument is if the water supply is put at risk. I mean, what do people prefer to have: cheap gas, which I don’t think is going to happen anyway, or fresh water? Because the reality is if people do not have access to fresh water, then effectively the life as we know it is over. This, unfortunately, goes right along with the philosophy of Pete Brabeck, the CEO of Nestle, who eight years ago recorded an interview in which he stated that in his opinion, it should not be regarded as a human right for people to have access to fresh water. And this is potentially creating a situation where basically people would have to effectively buy their fresh water from the corporations. This industry has never before been unleashed beneath the densely populated islands such as the UK. We’ve seen the effects in places like Colorado and Pennsylvania, and southern Queensland in Australia, when the population density of the UK is 20 times that of Colorado and 100 times that of southern Queensland. I would simply implore that people do a bit of research for themselves, and they look at the damage and the contamination that has been wreaked in these locations around the world. We are doing everything we possibly can to ensure that this doesn’t happen in the UK.

RT: Why can’t I expect government to do this research for me? Why won’t they protect my own health, what do you think?

IC: That’s a very good question and in fact, last Thursday evening I attended a public meeting with IGas Energy, which is the company that has a license to exploit the resources in Manchester. And their direct response to that question was that it is not their responsibility to investigate the environmental damage or the negative health impact that this industry has caused elsewhere. This is totally irresponsible, and tragically, what it reflects is the fact that we are dealing with the cowboy industry that is driven by greed and that in fact, that takes the mantra directly from Lord Browne, the former chairman and CEO of BP, who basically said “this is profit above all else,” and that he would do whatever it takes to get into the heart of the shale gas industry. Basically there are an increasing number of people around the UK to ensure that it doesn’t happen. The British government and the shale gas industry, the embryonic shale gas industry in the UK, does not have the social license to proceed with it.

The statements, views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of RT.

Comments (16)


mergon 04.12.2013 20:32

Last year southern water went on a program to replace all of their water meters ,we were paying £28 a month thats now up to £40 for us = 2 of us in a small retirement bungalow , fracking may a cheap way to make big corporate profits, but the price for us will just just keep going up ,on top of that they are poisoning the underground supply with the acids that they pump into the wells to get the gas out ,look at any news broadcast and the words they use for the acids is chemicals ,after all the public should not hear that a gas company is pumping acids into the under ground water supply ,they may get upset !


Mark 03.12.2013 19:35

whats funny is that they are spending more money to get the fuel out that they can sell it for. Frack sources run out rather fast so to keep up the production levels they have to at least double the sources every year.
Oil's high point 2005, it's all down hill from here, in a not too far future oil will be 400 dollars a barrel. American is already like a crack addict going around the world killing to feed its addiction to oil. BP wrecked the gulf of mexico mainly because they wanted to save the well, if it was a case of just blocking it that could have been done far quicker


Little Johnny 29.11.2013 06:41

Attaching monetary value to the very essentials of life... We truly are living in a period that will be referred to in future as the "Idiocracy" ; (by whatever species supercedes us).

View all comments (16)
Add comment

Authorization required for adding comments

Register or



Show password


or Register

Request a new password


or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:


or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile



New password

Retype new password

Current password



Follow us

Follow us