VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД
breakingnews
Go to main page   Politics   Agree to disagree  
MORE ON THE STORY
18.05.2009, 13:56

Caucasus peace talks: little hope for progress

As the fifth round of international talks on the peace settlement in Caucasus opens in Geneva, the prospect of progress in resolving the conflict between Georgia, Abkhazia and South Ossetia seems bleak.

Members of UN humanitarian commission (AFP Photo / Kazbek Basayev) 16.06.2009, 10:45 3 comments

Russia sends the UN mission packing from Georgia-Abkhazia

The UN's observer mission on the Georgia-Abkhazia border zone will wrap up its work on the ground. It comes after Russia vetoed a Security Council draft on prolonging the UN Caucasus mandate.

09.06.2010, 16:19

Geneva talks on Caucasus end in deadlock

Yet another round of Geneva talks on security and stability in the Caucasus following the August 2008 conflict has brought no result. The parties failed to come to a compromise over a document on non-use of force.

Russian President Dmitry Medvedev (R) meets with South Ossetia leader Eduard Kokoity in Sochi on August 13, 2010 13.08.2010, 16:27 7 comments

Policy on S.Ossetia, Abkhazia to remain unchanged – Medvedev

Moscow’s policy towards supporting South Ossetia and Abkhazia remains unchanged, President Dmitry Medvedev said at a meeting with his Ossetian counterpart Eduard Kokoity.

04.08.2010, 14:12 5 comments

UN membership door closed for Kosovo – Moscow

Russia’s UN envoy Vitaly Churkin has made it clear that Moscow will not allow Kosovo to join the organization and that UN Resolution 1244, which confirms Serbia’s territorial integrity, will not be amended.

16.07.2010, 15:36 5 comments

Lukashenko & Saakashvili merge in duet against Russia

President Lukashenko, having lost ground in Moscow, has now turned to the Kremlin’s foes and is enjoying warm relations with his former critic Georgian leader Saakashvili. What could be behind this sudden mutual love?

Russian Federation, Alagir: Children from South Ossetia wait in a refugee camp on August 11, 2008 (AFP Photo / Natalia Kolesnikova) 12.09.2009, 07:18

“Georgia’s initiative on Abkhazian and South Ossetian refugees purely political”

The Georgian initiative on refugees and temporarily displaced persons from Abkhazia and South Ossetia has nothing to do with humanitarian objectives, said Russia’s Foreign Ministry spokesman, Andrey Nesterenko.

Georgia's President Mikhail Saakashvili (AFP Photo / Guillermo Legaria) 17.08.2010, 16:20 4 comments

Saakashvili eyes reviving anti-Russian bloc

Tbilisi and Chisinau have reportedly agreed to revive the post-Soviet bloc uniting Georgia, Ukraine, Azerbaijan and Moldova (GUAM) which Moscow considers “anti-Russian”, writes Kommersant daily.

UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon (AFP Photo / Lehtikuva / Mikko Stig) 29.05.2009, 15:29

UN chief: Russia never blackmailed me

UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon has rejected a claim by Georgia that he changed a recent report on the Caucasus following blackmail by Russia.

09.10.2009, 15:43 1 comment

“No reply” from Moscow to Ukraine’s invitation

Leaders of former Soviet republics are in Moldova for the CIS Summit on Friday. The official request from Kiev to arrange a meeting between Medvedev and Yushchenko has been met with a mute response from Russia.

Agree to disagree

Published: 19 May, 2009, 15:41

(3.9Mb) embed video

TAGS: Conflict, Meeting, UN, Georgia, Russia


Russia and Georgia have found themselves in rare agreement - both have criticized a UN report on the security situation in the Caucasus.

Moscow says the document is biased, while Tbilisi claims it was drawn up under Russia's influence, something Moscow was quick to dismiss.

Security talks in Geneva restarted on Tuesday, after being suspended when Abkhazia walked out.

However, Abkhazia says it's now happier with the content of the report.

The Republic’s Foreign Minister Sergey Shamba said all phrasing to which Sukhum had objected has now been dropped.

Three days later than scheduled, UN General Secretary Ban Ki Moon produced a report on the current situation in the Caucasus, Aleksandr Pisarev, member of the Russian UN mission stated to the Ria Novosti news agency. According to Pisarev, this version of the report, as compared to the earlier ones, does not state that Abkhazia is part of Georgia.

Russia and Georgia are also attending the discussions which are aimed at differences resulting from the war in South Ossetia last August.

Earlier on Tuesday, Abkhazia’s President Eduard Kokoity blamed the UN for having a double standard.

The President stressed that neither his Republic nor South Ossetia refuse to take part in the talks, but both want equal rights for all the participants.

“There are facts of the reality which have to be taken into account. That is recognizing the independence of South Ossetia and Abkhazia. So we want to hold talks on equal terms,” said Kokoity.

Meanwhile, Georgia has blamed Russia saying it was hindering the peace process in the region. Earlier Russia suggested halting the consultations until Abkhazia gets back to the negotiating table. The Russian side said that in the absence of one of the parties at this meeting, it would be ineffective to discuss serious security issues.

But Georgia insisted that was not the reason enough to suspend the talks.

“The Russian negotiators have withdrawn from the discussions for reasons not connected with the agenda and format of the talks,” the Georgian Foreign Ministry said in a statement on Tuesday.

The country has also proclaimed Russia’s decision "provocative."

Tbilisi is sure that the UN “will not make any decisions violating Georgia’s territorial integrity,” said the country’s Foreign Minister Grigol Vashadze, quoted by ITAR TASS.

In his comments on the UN Secretary General’s report on the situation in the Caucasus, Vashadze has noted that this document is “preliminary” and “must be carefully examined.”

“Yet even now we can unambiguously say that no compromises, no decisions violating Georgia’s territorial integrity or the international legal status of the country’s internationally acknowledged borders, will be made,” added the minister.

Both Russia and Georgia criticise the report

As he also said, the document “contains positive points and those that have obviously been included into the report under Russia’s pressure.”

The Russian Foreign Ministry immediately refuted Georgia’s accusations of pressing on the UN, saying they were “twaddle,” RIA Novosti reports. According to Igor Lyakin-Frolov, a Ministry representative, Russia itself is not satisfied with the document and considers it biased.

“It is twaddle,” he said. “We could equally state that the report is prepared under Georgia’s pressure.”

“We consider it biased. Many of its clauses disagree with our position and our evaluation of the present situation in Transcaucasia,” said the diplomat.

The UN Secretary General presented his report three days later than was initially planned, because of the variant readings of the document’s title. The United States was insisting on mentioning Abkhazia as a part of Georgia. Eventually, a neutral formulation was approved.

The next round of the Geneva consultations is scheduled for July 1, Russia’s Deputy Foreign Minister and State Secretary Grigory Karasin has advised.

“As always, we emphasized [at today’s talks] that a compulsory, obligatory agreement must urgently be made between Georgia and South Ossetia, as well as Georgia and Abkhazia, on the non-use of force,” said the Russian diplomat.

No to international police forces

Karasin also dismissed Tbilisi’s allegations of Russia thwarting the work of the peace-keepers in the conflict zones.

“It is not true. The thing is that Georgian representatives, with help from Americans, tried to impose a discussion on certain formats of the international peace-keeping operation, and the presence of international police forces in Georgia, Abkhazia and South Ossetia,” said the Deputy Foreign Minister to Interfax.

He then continued that, “a special mission of the EU observers is present in the territories adjacent to South Ossetia and Abkhazia.”

"What other additional international peace-keeping and police forces Georgians want to talk about, they failed to explain,” added Karasin.

+5 (5 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
Vladimir Kremlev for RT 19.05.2009, 13:58

ROAR: Russian Opinion and Analytics Review, May 19

In Tuesday’s ROAR we look at oil markets and how the global economic crisis may shift trends in it. The fate of the US air base in Kyrgyzstan is also in focus.

19.05.2009, 20:44 4 comments

Anti-missiles in Europe: unneeded, ineffective, harmful

The anti-ballistic missile system, which the US wants to use to protect itself and Europe from a possible strike from Iran, is not up for the job, a joint US-Russian threat assessment says.

Veselin May 19, 2009, 13:19
0

It is important that the new-born countries South Osetia and Abhazia are safe and independant!!! EU and UN should prevent new Georgian aggression against the new countries. If South Osetians and Abkhazian want to be free and independant they should BE!!! And Georgia has no right to torture them and thraeten them!!!