Duma receives bill introducing jail sentence for public blasphemy

Published time: September 26, 2012 10:36
Edited time: September 26, 2012 14:36
Believers at the divine service held during the Palm Sunday holiday at the Church of the Icon of the Mother of God Consolation of All the Afflicted.(RIA Novosti / Vladimir Astapkovich)

The Russian State Duma has received a bill to protect religious believers’ feelings that introduces a punishment of up to 5 years in prison.

The bill was prepared jointly by all the parliamentary parties and presented by MP Yaroslav Nilov of the opposition Liberal Democratic Party. Nilov, who is also the head of the parliamentary committee for public organizations and religious unions, presented a special address to the Lower House on the subject which was almost unanimously approved by all four State Duma factions.

If the new bill is approved it would amend the Criminal Code with a new article on “Insulting citizens’ religious views and feelings and desecration of the objects of the religious reverence and pilgrimage as well as those destined for conducting religious rites and ceremonies”.

Under this article a public insult or humiliation of church services or other religious rites is punished with fines of up to 300,000 roubles (about US$9,000), up to 200 hours of community work or up to three years in prison. Defiling or destruction of buildings or objects that are revered as holy by any official religion can be punished with a fine of up to 500,000 roubles (US$ 15,000), up to 400 hours community work or with prison sentence of up to five years.

The bill also adds a new article to the Administrative Code. It suggests that public defiling of religious books, signs or emblems must be punished with a fine of up to 50,000 roubles (US$1,500).

The new draft law follows the line parliament took by approving the address ‘On protection of the religious feelings of the citizens of Russia’ the document which, according to MPs, was prompted by a large number of sacrilegious situations and events that took place in 2012.

These are the “punk prayer” staged in the Moscow’s main cathedral, the desecration of icons, the Nazi and Satanist graffiti in churches and synagogues and cutting down of memorial Orthodox crosses in various Russian regions. There are also more dangerous incidents, such as the recent assassinations of Muslim clerics in Russia’s internal republics of Tatarstan and Dagestan.

While some analysts point at potential dangers of the bill in the multi-confessional and officially secular state, a source in the Russian Presidential Administration called the move a normal reaction of the parliament to public sentiment.

"This was an understandable reaction of the State Duma to public feelings about the latest insults of the believers, including the Pussy Riot incident," the Interfax news agency quoted the unnamed source as saying. "The deputies took into account the public demand, backed by the latest opinion polls. The polls showed that 80% of Russians supported that idea," the source said.

The official also pointed out that the draft law is in line with the international practice. “Countries like Germany, Spain and Finland all have legislative acts, which protect rights of believers. This is a normal and natural process," the source said.

Comments (24)

Anonymous user 14.03.2013 00:51

Brilliant! I am happy this bill is being considered.

0

Undo

Atossa (unregistered) 27.09.2012 16:17

Vikram (unregistered) posted: " Would this new law make most RT posters liable to arrest in Russia for their antisemitic rants on here? That would be an amusing consequence. " ___________ ____________________ __ Year s ago, on another "Russian" news forum posters told me if I were in Russia I'd be arrested for posting against satanic antichrist jews. I remember one poster there said she was going to "turn me in" to authorities for being antisemitic. I used to tease her about having coffee and cookies ready when the Texas Rangers arrive.

0

Undo

aka 27.09.2012 09:55

Somedude wrote in #1
But aren't all these crimes they point already punishable with current laws?Damage of property? Murder? Vandalism? Trespassing?
I'm not russian and neither do i live there (though i'd love to spend some vacations there), so i have no clue how russian legal system is but in any secular western country  those situations are very punishable without meddling religion in.

Also what would be exactly  "Insultin g citizens’ religious views and feelings" ? publishing a satirical cartoon or video of *insert favourite religion profet here*? criticise or denouce religious practices that perjudicate sectors of the population? Openly state your personal stance toward any particular religion? 

I see this as very vague and could very well backfire badly, this is comparable with those ACTA and SOPA legislations in the way that they could be misused to censor and cut down freedom of speech. Wow! very fascinating and intriguing..... Could you please tell me how the Western system would have legally dealt with "the innocence of Muslims" blasphemous film? Even in the wake of the violent reactions and loss of lives, the film is still justified as a case for "freedom of speech".....When people are making speeches that cripple others psychologically and brutalise them spiritually, the West has no objective and rational system to deal with this inherent evil of our civilisation, except to justify it as freedom of speech.

0

Undo

View all comments (24)
Add comment

By posting your comment, you agree to abide by our Posting rules

Log in to comment in full, or comment anonymously under character-limit restriction.

100 Text

– required fields

Register or

Name

Password

Show password

Register

or Register

Request a new password

Send

or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:

or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile

Name

New password

Retype new password

Current password

Save

Cancel

Follow us