VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД
breakingnews
Go to main page   Politics   American activist killed in Israel remembered in documentary  
MORE ON THE STORY
Jerusalem: A Palestinian demonstrator flashes victory signs during clashes with Israeli soldiers in east Jerusalem, on March 16, 2010. (AFP Photo / Jack Guez) 16.03.2010, 19:05 2 comments

Israel endures Palestinian “day of rage” as Washington fumes on sidelines

As Israel attempts to console Washington over an ill-timed announcement on new settlement construction, Palestinians have also weighed in on the matter, with violence erupting in East Jerusalem on Tuesday.

AFP Photo / Mahmoud Zayat
					28.09.2010, 11:50 4 comments

Israel labels charity “terrorists”

Ten Israeli warships have forced a British aid boat carrying Jewish activists attempting to reach blockaded Gaza to divert to the port of Ashdod in Israel.

Palestinian members of the armed wing of the Islamist movement Hamas, Ezzedine al-Qassam Brigades, take part in a march against the Israeli-Palestinian peace negotiations, on October 1, 2010 (AFP Photo / Mohammed Abed) 19.10.2010, 09:58 1 comment

Israel pushing Palestinians to pledge loyalty

Israel is facing criticism over a bill that requires prospective non-Jewish citizens to swear allegiance to the Jewish state.

Israeli soldiers arrest a Palestinian youth (AFP Photo / Hazem Bader) 08.09.2009, 10:44 11 comments

Israel: apartheid state or only democracy of the Middle East?

Israel’s borders are those of 1947, and because it is a bi-national state it needs the formation of a unitary state, like Belgium. This is the view of academic and human rights activist Professor Uri Davis.

28.07.2010, 19:07 14 comments

Cultures clash in battle over Islamic face veil, extremists add fuel to fire

Al-Qaeda second-in-command Ayman al-Zawahiri has attacked the bill passed by French lawmakers, which could ban wearing Islamic face veils in public places, and has urged Muslim women to ignore it at any cost.

22.05.2009, 06:16 3 comments

US pilot wants UN to help sue George Bush

Former Boeing pilot sent a message to Russia’s UN Ambassador through a newspaper in order to secure his help in suing ex-US President George W. Bush.

A frame from Tarantino's movie "Inglourious Basterds" 28.08.2009, 21:02 4 comments

Inglourious Basterds threaten Tarantino movie screening in Urals

A Yekaterinburg cinema may refuse to show the latest Quentin Tarantino work, called "Inglourious Basterds," following anonymous threats to explode a bomb if the movie continues, Intrefax-Urals reports.

Gaza city : Hamas marine security take to the open waters during a drill in preparation for the arrival of ships expected to break the Israeli naval blockade on the port in Gaza City on the coast of the Mediterranean Sea on May 26, 2010. (AFP Photo / Mahmud Hams) 27.05.2010, 02:38 1 comment

Israel to block massive aid shipment to Gaza

Israel is set to block eight ships carrying 10,000 tons of humanitarian aid, cement, school supplies, and medical equipment to Gaza.

05.06.2010, 00:52 2 comments

Antiwar activists around the world take on Gaza

Global protests have erupted over Israel’s decision to use military force to block aid ships carrying 10,000 tons of aid and 800 activists and politicians on their way to Gaza.

15.06.2010, 04:29 2 comments

Filmmaker smuggled raw footage off Mavi Marmara

Iara Lee managed to save raw footage of the Israeli raid of the Gaza flotilla despite her equipment being confiscated by Israeli forces.

American activist killed in Israel remembered in documentary

Published: 21 March, 2010, 10:23
Edited: 23 March, 2010, 22:50

US ISM activist Rachel Corrie in front of a bulldozer 16 March 2003 in Rafah, southern Gaza

(44.8Mb) embed video

TAGS: Movies, Crime, Accident, Middle East, Protest, Human rights


Seven years ago the American peace activist Rachel Corrie was crushed to death by an Israeli bulldozer as she campaigned against the demolition of Palestinian homes in Gaza.

The 23-year-old American activist was participating in a non-violent protest when a 49-ton Israeli army bulldozer ran her over.

The unprecedented killing sparked outrage worldwide, and put the issue of security of international activists firmly in the spotlight.

On the anniversary of her killing, a trial brought by her parents against the Israeli government got underway.

RT spoke with filmmaker Simone Bitton, who has made a documentary investigating the circumstances around Rachel's death.

RT: Why did you choose Rachel as the subject of your documentary? What drew you to her story?

Simone Bitton: I'm making films in Israel and Palestine. It is not my first film there. Usually I’m motivated to make a film when the red line is crossed. Rachel's killing was that red line because it was for the first time when a young foreigner who came in a solidarity mission with the Palestinian civilians was killed by the Israeli army. It never happened before. There were other cases after her, but that was the first time. It really was a red line.

In the Middle East we always think it can’t be worse, but always something happens to show it can be worse. And this was one of these moments, because if even a non-violent young protestor –and she was an American citizen – can be killed by the Israeli army, it means that Palestinian civilians remain without protection at all, even though it was very small protection.

RT: You show some very graphic images in your documentary. You didn't seem to censor anything. Why don't you think it was important to show?

SB: The thing is the inquiry into the death of this young person; it would have made no sense not to show what I'm talking about. So, I gathered so many documents, videos, photographs, the positions – there are many documents in the film, including images of Rachel’s body just after she was killed. All my work won't make sense if I kept my eyes away from images, because this is what I talk about in the film.


Rachel Corrie
In the film I share with the viewer some of my feelings about these kinds of images because the images of the direct aftermath of the killing are shown by the young activist who actually took the pictures. And he talks himself about how you feel when you take such pictures. You feel like a voyeur, it is obscene, but still you feel you must do it because you know the proof will be needed.

RT: Your film was called a masterpiece documentary, and it was even accepted by the Jewish festival and caused a lot of controversy and opened a lot of protests and heavy criticism. You are an Israeli citizen, are you surprised by all this?

SB: The film was shown in very prestigious international festivals, in the Tribeca Festival in New York and the Berlin Biennale. It arrived to the San Francisco Jewish Film Festival already with the legitimacy of the cinema world and, yes, at this festival everyone was very surprised, but there was a very harsh and brutal response from some Jewish institutions in San Francisco that gave us a lot of publicity. I always say as an Israeli citizen, who is clearly a dissident to the Israeli occupation of the Palestinian territories, I know that many people do not like what I am doing. But I am okay with this. I do not have any problems at all. It’s surprising that people behaved so vulgar in San Francisco and attacked the film before seeing it. It was ridiculous.

RT: Do you view Rachel as a martyr?

SB: No, I never use this name. I think a martyr would be somebody who is ready to die. I am sure that Rachel didn’t want to die. She came there for life, for playing with children, testifying and protecting. She did not take at all into consideration that she could be killed because nobody was killed before her. It never happened that the Israelis went so far as to kill a foreign protester. So, she is not a martyr, she is a victim.

RT: Do you think that the driver of the bulldozer intentionally killed her?

SB: I can’t prove that. What I can prove, and this is very well explained in the film, is that the bulldozer drivers saw Rachel and her friends for three hours. It was a very long demonstration, and a kind of a game, a terrible game between the bulldozers and the protesters.

There was interaction between them, as the official Israeli version says; it was an accident because the bulldozer driver could not see her. It does not make sense, I cannot say if at the very last moment while he was driving over her, he saw her. He is the only one to know. What I know is that there were three hours that he saw her, they saw each other and were interacting with each other. If he did not see her at the last moment, maybe that’s because he did not want to see.

RT: In all the work that you are putting in this film together between the interviews and the footage. What did you find to be the most difficult in telling Rachel’s story?

SB: I think that it was a very difficult movie to make.

RT: What was the most difficult?

SB: It was the most difficult of all the films, and I made a lot of films in Palestine. I discovered when I was doing it that it was a very sensitive issue. Really nobody wanted to talk about it at the beginning. It was getting more and more difficult for us to work there, because it was more and more difficult to move from place to place. Even for me, an Israeli citizen, as I am privileged, I’m part of the tribe and it helps. But still it was difficult. There are scenes in the film that were shot without my presence because the army did not let me enter Gaza for the last week of shooting.

That’s the only time it happened to me over 30 years of my professional life. I had to direct sequences from far, did interviews by phone, because the army would not let me into Gaza. But when the door is closed, we have to go through the windows. We have to go where they do not want us to go.

RT: Why did you decide to attend the trial?

SB: I wanted to attend the trial because I was living with this story for more than three years and it is an important moment and I want to be there. And I wanted to be with Rachel’s family. For me it’s a normal gesture of solidarity with the characters of my film. But also it was important for me to show the film in Israel at the time of the trial. The film will be broadcast on Israeli satellite. Also, I’m going to hold special screenings in the cinemas, because in my film there are many elements and testimonies that will not be heard at the trial. Because the court does not bring in the Palestinian witnesses and does not go to the Gaza Strip to see where it happened. And many direct, key witnesses of Rachel’s killing will not be there. But they are all in my film.

I wish the judge has the opportunity to see my film. He will learn a lot.

Read also – Israel Gives The Finger To The USA

+19 (19 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
AFP Photo / Alexey Sazonov 20.03.2010, 19:37 10 comments

“Rally of Wrath” demands action from the government

Thousands of Russians have taken to the streets to participate in so-called “Day of Wrath” opposition rallies all over the country.

21.03.2010, 13:25 10 comments

Ukraine’s previous hopes of joining NATO to be dashed

Ukraine is preparing to pass a new law preventing the country from joining any military alliance, including NATO.

Israel Resource News March 23, 2010, 17:01
0

On March 16, 2003, American citizen and member of the International Solidarity Movement (ISM), Rachel Corrie was crushed by an IDF bulldozer. While Corrie's family alleges that she was killed by a driver who clearly had her in his sights, news interviews and photos tell a different story. Photos published by Reuters shortly after the incident shows Corrie standing to the left of the bulldozer, in a location where she is obviously visible to the driver, holding a megaphone. Beneath the photo, the caption read “Photographed before Rachel Corrie was run over by an IDF bulldozer.” Readers looking at the photograph and caption were lead to believe that the driver saw Corrie and proceeded to crush her under the weight of the bulldozer, however this is a fallacy. Immediately after the accident, our news agency contacted ISM and was sent to speak with some of Corrie’s friends who were with her when she died. Corrie's friend Joe Smith described how Corrie sat on a mound of dirt facing the IDF bulldozer making its way to the house it was about to demolish.Our agency pointed out to him that no such notice appeared in the pictures we saw on the Reuters site. We asked the director general of Reuters in Israel, Tim Heritage, whether Reuters had a set policy of using pictures provided by political organizations, and Heritage replied that it is widespread. Heritage promised into check the matter of the misleading picture that was taken before the incident and asked us to call him back in an hour. After an hour, Heritage was no longer available to speak with our agency. We went into the Reuters website and were amazed to find that the pictures of Corrie had been removed. After our agency checked the pictures that Reuters distributed to the world's newspapers, we noticed the difference. -David Bedein Director of Israel Resource News Agency and Center for Near East Policy Research Melissa Goraj and Sarah Hindman- Staff