Keep up with the news by installing RT’s extension for . Never miss a story with this clean and simple app that delivers the latest headlines to you.

 

TV channel under fire for online poll on legendary Leningrad siege

Published time: January 28, 2014 10:09
People watch a parade on the 70th anniversary of Leningrad liberation from the Nazi siege on Nepokoryonnykh Prospekt in St. Petersburg.(RIA Novosti / Anna Volkova)

People watch a parade on the 70th anniversary of Leningrad liberation from the Nazi siege on Nepokoryonnykh Prospekt in St. Petersburg.(RIA Novosti / Anna Volkova)

A group of Duma MPs have called for a prosecutors’ probe and legislative limitation after a news channel positioned as ‘opposition’ asked its audience if Leningrad should have been surrendered to the Nazis during World War II.

The parliamentarians want the Prosecutor General’s Office to give an assessment of the moral and ethical side of the recent move by the independent TV channel Dozhd (Rain).

As the country celebrated the 70th anniversary of lifting the Nazi Blockade of Leningrad (now St. Petersburg), Dozhd, always posing as opposition-leaning and critical of the authorities, posted a poll on its website asking if the audience considered it reasonable to surrender the city to the Nazis in order to save thousands of lives.

This approach immediately caused outrage on social networks and in the mass media. That reaction prompted Dozhd to apologize and have the controversial poll removed from its site, however it was too late.

Internet users continued to decry the channel for insulting the heroic history of what is termed the Great Patriotic War, and at some point a man dressed in Soviet Army uniform raised a copy of the ‘Victory Banner’ – the red flag that was put on the Reichstag in 1945 – over the Dozhd office complex.

Screenshot from YouTube user Darya Sukhorukova

Politicians of all inclinations condemned Dozhd and its provocative move in statements.

MP Irina Yarovaya of centrist conservative parliamentary majority United Russia said the poll was in fact an attempt to rehabilitate Nazism.

“These things all look equally disgusting – the parades of Ukrainian neo-Nazis, the demolition of monuments to war heroes and the sly, fake and counterfeit polls,” Yarovaya told Itar-Tass. “And every time the same thing is behind these actions – the justification of Nazi crimes and the desecration of the historical memory.”

Army general, and the head of the Russian Veterans’ Union, MP Mikhail Moiseyev (United Russia) called the poll an insult to history and the betrayal of the people, and on behalf of all veterans demanded official apologies from the channel.

Another veteran, President of the Academy of Military Sciences Makhmut Gareyev, noted that the creators of the poll showed their ignorance of history, as the described choice never existed – Hitler ordered his troops to completely destroy Moscow and Leningrad and eliminate the populations of these cities.

“If Leningrad was handed over everyone would have been killed. In reality at least some of the residents survived,” the historian noted.

MP Leonid Levin of the center-left Fair Russia party said the memory of the war is one of those things where questioning is impossible.

January 27, 2014. Russian President Vladimir Putin, middle ground center, participates in a wreath-laying ceremony at the Motherland memorial at St. Petersburg's Piskaryovskoye Memorial Cemetery.(RIA Novosti / Michael Klimentyev)

“The victory, the country’s sovereignty, charity and religion – the nation must be united over these topics or it cannot be called a nation,” the politician noted. Levin said that the existence of such polls questions the moral and ethical competence of the Dozhd editors and managers, and urged the Russian Journalists’ Union to intervene.

Deputy head of the Russian Communist Party, Ivan Melnikov, called the channel’s attitude “absolutely shameless” and “an attempt to lift the taboos imposed at the Nurembergtrial.” He also noted that the authors of the poll did not understand that the heroism of the defenders of Leningrad did not contradict the abstract humanism, but was instead a manifestation of absolute humanism.

The high-level reaction prompted Dozhd journalists to take further steps to restore their image. The channel’s Chief Editor Mikhail Zygar issued a special address to viewers in which he said that he and all his colleagues have always condemned Nazism and opposed attempts to justify it.

He added that the wave of negative statements and reports was caused by a “political order,” for which he indirectly blamed the United Russia party.

Apart from many heated comments, the MPs also urged legislative action. In the same address in which Communists asked the prosecutors to establish the “authors and initiators” of the controversial poll, they also sought to revive the bill on criminal responsibility for the rehabilitation of Nazism.

Two different drafts of the document were prepared and submitted to the lower house in 2013, but put on hold after being rejected by the government. The critics said that the definitions used in the bill were too vague and some of its provisions duplicated existing articles of the criminal and administrative codes.

Comments (30)

 

zaika 31.05.2014 13:33

In my opinion it is senseless to speculate what could or should have happened if this or that was different and so on. We have fact of mass bravery and suffering of people of Leningrad and future generations should know the proud history of their grandparents who made an ultimate sacrifice for us all living now and in the future. Dozhd should do useful work instead and discuss current issues like death on Russian roads, use of alcohol, cigarettes and drugs, free sporting clubs for kids and so on.

 

Re Ku 22.05.2014 21:43

Only 1/2 truth! Kiev was, after Germans entered the city blown UP, by orders of Stalin! 10s of 1000s Ukrainians were killed by this action! Leningrad had similar bombs placed all over the city. Russia suffered heavy casualties in the War, but... Germany has had similar losses, beside the difference; East Prussia is still occupied by Russia & partly by Poland. Pomerania & Silesia occupied by Poland. 18 Million Germans w. expelled f. their homes. 3 - 4 million of them where killed. So much I support Mr Putin and the Russian people, the now Ukrainian problem is partly HOME MADE! You may read more at algaddafi.or g

 

Ksaint3244 14.05.2014 14:55

georg12 06.05.2014 21:23



Respect!

  


Th ats only partly true, due to the fact that the Red Scare after WWII was all due to Russia wanting to maintain itself as the the #1 superpower in the world by experimenting with the atomic bomb, if it were not for the arms race Russia and the U.S. would have an actual alliance instead of competition.

View all comments (30)
Add comment

Authorization required for adding comments

Register or

Name

Password

Show password

Register

or Register

Request a new password

Send

or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:

OK

or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile

X

Name

New password

Retype new password

Current password

Save

Cancel

Follow us

Follow us