VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД FIND US ON: YouTube Twitter
breakingnews
Go to main page   Politics   ROAR: Russian Opinion and Analytics Review, Apr.14  
MORE ON THE STORY
Georgia, Tbilisi (AFP Photo / Vano Shlamov) 11.06.2010, 14:12 10 comments

US admits failure in its strategy towards Georgia

The US Administration has Georgia on their minds – and it's not one of the fifty states.

31.07.2009, 11:45 8 comments

“CSTO-NATO conflict of interests in Kyrgyzstan unlikely”

CSTO’s plan for a military base in Kyrgyzstan is unlikely to cause a conflict of interest with NATO after the decision to convert the US Manas base in into a support facility, says military analyst Dmitry Evstafyev.

27.02.2010, 17:58 21 comments

Polish president gives the green light to US troops’ deployment in Poland

Polish President Lech Kaczynski has ratified the Status of Forces Agreement (SOFA) with the US, laying out the conditions for the deployment of US troops on Polish soil.

16.09.2010, 17:38 12 comments

Black Hawk down: US looking to buy Russian helicopters

With NATO forces advancing on fortified Taliban positions ahead of parliamentary elections, the US Defense Secretary has stated his interest in purchasing Russian helicopters.

Serbian nationalist holds a banner during a rally in Belgrade on May 19, 2009 (AFP Photo / Andrej Isakovic) 20.05.2009, 19:22 10 comments

Biden gets mixed reception in Belgrade

US Vice President Joe Biden arrived in Serbia on Wednesday to try to improve relations with this Balkan country. Unlike the Serbian President, some MPs preferred to “greet” him in a different manner.

RIA Novosti 07.04.2010, 17:15 3 comments

Will Kyrgyzstan’s unrest change the political situation in the country?

Clashes between protesters and police in Kyrgyzstan have continued on Wednesday, spreading to the capital Bishkek. Human rights organizations have described the situation in the country as "complex."

Georgian tank personnel sit on their tank at a road outside Tbilisi on May 5, 2009 (AFP Photo / Vano Shlamov) 21.05.2009, 22:10 2 comments

Georgian mutiny suspect killed, two arrested

An alleged organizer of the mutiny at a military base in Georgia has been killed and two others injured in a shoot-out with police, the country’s Interior Ministry says.

photo by Poras Chaudhary 10.04.2009, 03:54 2 comments

Color revolutions come to nought?

Unlike many former Soviet states during the past ten years, something is fundamentally different in the case of Moldova’s opposition unrest. Some analysts already consider this week's events in Chisinau a revolution.

SWEDEN, STOCKHOLM : L to R: Russian President Dmitry Medvedev, Swedish Prime Minister Fredrik Reinfeldt, President of the European Commission Jose Manuel Barroso in Stockholm on November 18, 2009. (AFP Photo / Ria Novosti / Kremlin Pool / Vladimir Rodionov) 25.11.2009, 13:32 2 comments

Moscow positive about final pre-Lisbon Russia-EU summit

Moscow has hailed the results the Russia-EU summit last week as positive, namely the signing of agreements concerning a cross-border cooperation program, said Russian Foreign Ministry spokesman Andrey Nesterenko.

Georgian police clash with opposition protesters in Tbilisi (AFP Photo) 09.07.2009, 19:37 3 comments

Will Georgian opposition outlast the summer?

The political stalemate in Georgia is taking a new twist. The Georgian government has recently worked out a draft law on manifestations – something which the opposition stands firmly against.

ROAR: Russian Opinion and Analytics Review, Apr.14

Published: 14 April, 2009, 14:11

Vladimir Kremlev for RT

Vladimir Kremlev for RT

TAGS: NATO, CIS, Georgia, Protest, Politics


This Tuesday ROAR looks upon NATO through the eyes of a French politician, hails the lack of violence in the Georgian street protests and presents an opinion on the recent events in Moldova, Georgia and elsewhere.

Jean-Marie Bockel, the French Secretary of State for defense and veterans’ affairs, writes in NEZAVISIMAYA GAZETA that, at the present moment of history, NATO needs to remember its initial call and function, which is to serve as a platform for the construction of collective security in Europe and elsewhere in the world.

The decision by France to reinstate its full membership in the military organization of the alliance completely agrees with the place which France, as a major power, occupies today in the world, writes the Secretary. He adds that the changes caused to NATO by the ending of the Cold War facilitated the return of France to the military side of the alliance.

The Secretary considers cooperation between NATO, the EU and Russia paramount for European security and names Central Asia, the Black Sea and the Caspian, and the Arctic region as areas where that cooperation may bear the best fruit. Cooperation is necessary in such spheres as countering the strategic impact of global warming, facilitating the free flow of goods and people across borders and liberalization of trade.

In the same newspaper, analyst and commentator Yury Simonyan writes that the main success of the recent Georgian street protests is the fact that these protests never turned violent and drew no violent reaction from the government, apart from the totally senseless attack on the opposition’s press center.

The commentator says that today, after the events, it is clear that the protests could never have achieved the goal that the opposition had professed to pursue: the resignation of Mikhail Saakashvili. For six months, he writes, the opposition leaders in Georgia had been saying that on April 9 Saakashvili would go, and they never accepted any doubts. For six months government figures had been saying that Saakashvili would stay in power under any circumstances, and had no words to explain why.

The author believes that the lack of unity and the absence of one leader accepted by all others as the supreme leader of the opposition played a bad joke on the whole movement. The opposition approached the appointed date of April 9 without a leader and with wrong priorities. The government entered the stage of that dramatic day without the slightest idea of what was to be done about the opposition.

AFP Photo

As a result, says the author, neither side performed up to its supporters’ expectations. Luckily there was no bloodshed.

Simonyan writes that for the opposition it was definitely a failure, but it wasn’t a victory for the government. Nobody can speak of victories if an 80,000 strong crowd gathers to march against the government, even if it disperses eventually. Georgia, says the author, has many problems which are gaining in complexity and severity.

They may take the country all the way to that boiling point when presidents are propelled out of their chairs by the pressure of the steam. Before it happens, the author suggests that the two sides sit down and discuss the matters together – if they are still flexible enough to negotiate.

In IZVESTIA, Vitaly Ivanov of the Institute of Politics and State Law writes that, looking with sadness and pity at what has been going on in Georgia and Moldova, he is tempted to say, like the doctor in an old joke who examines his patient’s many ailments and says ‘Good. Very and very good. Very good it’s not me who’s got all these…’ It is good that it has not been happening to us here in Russia.

It actually couldn’t have happened here, continues the writer. After the ‘Orange’ movement started in Ukraine and elsewhere, the Russian powers-that-be prescribed an anti-Orange prophylactic. It caused a stir among the Liberals, who said the state was fighting ‘an imaginary threat.’ However the elections that followed demonstrated with rare clarity that ‘Orangism’ doesn’t grow on the soil protected from it, even if the seeds are in the soil.

The writer says that the pogroms in Moldova and the zero-gain protests in Georgia have shown Russia’s Liberals that Orangism without the support of the US, which lacked in both cases and without the laxness of security, which doesn’t often occur in Russia, leads only to a senseless loss of time, effort and property. For the Liberals, the best mode of conduct for now is to start looking for ways that could lead them back into the officially existing political system.

Evgeny Belenkiy, RT

0 (0 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
14.04.2009, 10:32

“Russia is more developed economically now” – Minister

Russians have lived through some massive social and economic changes in the past 20 years. Russia’s Minister of Health Care and Social Development Tatiana Golikova tells RT what that legacy now means for the country.

UN Security Council (AFP Photo / Stan Honda) 14.04.2009, 18:15

“North Korea offended by UN decision”

North Korea strongly protects their right to participate in peaceful space development and regards the decision of the UN Security Council as discrimination, says Aleksandr Vorontsov