VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД FIND US ON: YouTube Twitter
breakingnews
Go to main page   Politics   Russia’s getting back to death penalty is “purely theoretical” – Ombudsman  
MORE ON THE STORY
Platon Lebedev (R) and Mikhail Khodorkovsky (RIA Novosti / Andrey Stenin) 23.12.2009, 20:51 7 comments

Supreme Court annuls 2003 arrest of former Yukos executive

Russia's Supreme Court has ruled that the 2003 arrest of former Yukos executive Platon Lebedev was illegal on procedural grounds and must be annulled. The decision will have no impact on his imprisonment, however.

03.05.2009, 13:38 3 comments

Guns don’t kill people, Police do

The number of Russian policemen brought to justice over the past four years is increasing. With people scared of seeing men in uniform, human rights activists and lawmakers in Russia are calling for urgent police reform.

21.01.2010, 20:32 3 comments

We should improve the legal knowledge of ordinary people - minister

Russian law has always been a complicated issue. RT has interviewed Aleksander Konovalov, Russia’s Justice Minister on widespread distrust in the country's legal system and on planned measures to improve the situation.

Image from yaplakal.com 26.01.2010, 21:38

Village demolition drama near boiling point in posh Moscow district

Controversy surrounding a luxury development in Western Moscow has reached the boiling point as residents of Rechnik settlement are protesting city hall's attempts to evict them from their homes.

19.11.2009, 13:55 1 comment

Saying no to capital punishment – ban on death penalty upheld

Russia’s Constitutional Court has ruled out the return of the death penalty to Russian courts after the 10-year moratorium on capital punishment expires on January 1, 2010.

North Caucasus 27.02.2010, 19:12 2 comments

North Caucasus still a concern – Medvedev

Russia’s President Dmitry Medvedev has reiterated that stabilizing the North Caucasus remains the country’s most-serious concern, during a visit to the volatile region.

29.07.2010, 21:21 2 comments

Medvedev calls for cutting the number of arrests

President Medvedev has demanded to reduce the number of criminals in jails, claiming that more crimes should be punished using alternative punishments.

29.09.2009, 09:53 1 comment

Top spy indicted in sex ring case

Moscow’s regional military court is due to resume hearing a sex trafficking case involving 13 suspects, one of whom is a senior Russian intelligence officer.

19.11.2009, 20:53 1 comment

Russian society split over death penalty ban

As top Russian court instance on Thursday ruled to prolong the death penalty ban in the country, many Russian politicians still can not agree, whether capital punishment is good or bad for the nation.

27.11.2009, 13:20

“Fighting back might bring further problems”

Olga Kamenchuk from the Russian Public Opinion Research center told RT how police officers are perceived by citizens and whether it is worth striking back, as Minister Rashid Nurgaliev advised the nation to on Thursday.

Russia’s getting back to death penalty is “purely theoretical” – Ombudsman

Published: 30 October, 2009, 18:51
Edited: 02 November, 2009, 18:36

TAGS: Crime, Russia, Human rights, Law


Russia’s Constitutional Court has accepted the request of the country’s Supreme Court to consider the issue of capital punishment on November 9.

“The question whether capital punishment will be introduced in Russia on January 1, 2010 will be discussed November 9, 2009 at a public plenary session of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation, due to its urgency and extreme importance,” the court's press service said in an official statement.

In February 1999, the Constitutional Court introduced a moratorium on the use of the death penalty, ruling that no court could sentence criminals to death until all courts had switched to jury trials. However, jury trials have now been established throughout Russia and Chechnya will become the final Russian republic to institute jury trials on January 1, 2010.

Does that mean Russia will get back to implementing the death penalty from the beginning of the next year?

To clarify this thorny issue, RT turned to Russian Human Rights Ombudsman Vladimir Lukin.

“Considering the issue from the legal perspective,” Lukin suggested. “I’d like to emphasize that the constitution has a reference on the temporary nature of the death penalty, so the normal state of the constitution implies an absence of the death penalty.”

“Secondly, we’ve signed the 6th protocol to the European Convention on Human Rights, which abandons the death penalty completely,” he continued. “At the same time, according to the Vienna Convention of 1969 on the Law of Treaties, to which Russia is a signatory, a state is obliged not to do anything that contradicts a treaty even prior to its entry into force.”

Russia’s international obligations have the force of a Russian law, Lukin said, and in case of a contradiction between the domestic and international laws, priority is given to the international ones.

“That means until the protocol is considered by the State Duma, the death penalty cannot be implemented,” he concluded. “So the only way for the death penalty to be put into force is if the 6th protocol is considered and declined by the State Duma.”

However, Lukin, who worked as a Head of the State Duma International Committee for many years, thinks this possibility is purely theoretical.

“You have to understand that ‘declined’ implies considering and declining by both chambers of the Russian Federal Assembly – first by the State Duma, then by the Federation Council,” he said. “But firstly, it’s very unlikely that it will be considered in Russia’s parliament anytime soon. And secondly, I’m not aware of any precedents in recent years when an international agreement, submitted by the president, would be declined by the parliament. I simply don’t know of any such cases.”

As for his personal attitude, Lukin says he always was and always will be strongly against the death penalty, both for personal and practical reasons.

“First of all, it’s a crime equal to killing a person,” he said. “It’s exceeding man's commission, since life is God’s gift and only God can take it away. Practically speaking, there’s no direct link between crime and death penalty. We know the US implemented the death penalty, but crime there is very high, whereas in many countries in Europe where the death penalty is abolished, crime is low. As for the criminal situation, it is mostly affected by the irreversibility of punishment – e.g. effectiveness of police and judicial authorities.”

Read also - Russia To Reinstate Death Penalty Already in 2010

+2 (2 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
Vladimir Kremlev for RT 30.10.2009, 14:04

ROAR: Russia-Belarus Union State still in limbo

Analysts and the media are rather skeptical about the prospects of a Union State of Russia and Belarus.

30.10.2009, 23:36 32 comments

Remembering Stalin’s Great Purge victims

On Friday, Russia marks the Day of Remembrance of the Victims of Political Repressions. Millions suffered from Stalin’s repressions from the 1920s through to the 1950s.