VERSIONS: روسيا اليوم NOTICIAS FREEVIDEO ИНОТВ RTД
breakingnews
Go to main page   Politics   Saakashvili opens propaganda monument to “freedom fighters”  
MORE ON THE STORY
GEORGIA, TSKHINVALI : Soldiers guard the checkpoint into Tskhinvali the capital of South Ossetia 13 July 2007. (AFP Photo / Vano Shlamov) 04.09.2009, 17:33

Georgian journalist seeks asylum

A Georgian opposition journalist with his family has crossed the border with South Ossetia and asked for political asylum.

23.10.2009, 18:01 18 comments

Does Fox News appear on White House “enemy list”?

News organizations were never intended to be the focus of “the news” per se, but that's what is happening in the US as the White House seems to have lost its patience with a popular news channel.

25.06.2010, 13:37 5 comments

Stalin’s hometown “destalinized”

Residents of Gori, the Georgian city where Joseph Stalin was born, awoke on Friday morning to discover the centrepiece of their main square, a six-metre bronze statue of the infamous soviet leader, had vanished.

Georgian police Armoured Personnel Carriers move in convoy along a road outside Tbilisi (AFP Photo / Vano Shlamov) 06.05.2009, 13:00 3 comments

No proof of Russia’s hand in Georgian mutiny – The Times

Despite accusations by Georgian officials that Russian secret services were involved in Tuesday's mutiny and alleged coup attempt, there is no firm evidence of it, according to a report in The Times.

South Ossetia, Tskhinval on August 13, 2008 (AFP Photo / Kazbek Basaev) 20.05.2010, 20:01 3 comments

Georgia started the war with South Ossetia – European Parliament

Victims of Georgia's attack on South Ossetia in August 2008 may now have an EU-approved document on their hands if they want their cases to be heard at the international criminal court in The Hague.

Every celebration easily turns anti-Russian - in Georgia... (AFP Photo / John Thys) 25.02.2009, 19:38 2 comments

Georgia marks Sovietization Day

On February 25, Georgia marks ‘Sovietization Day’. Introduced in the early 1990s, the holiday has recently acquired a slightly different sense.

30.09.2009, 14:53

Georgian media forgot about objectivity – refugee journalist speaks out

The opposition journalist who fled Georgia in early September gave an interview to the Russian media blaming the media of his native country for losing its objectivity.

27.04.2010, 22:38

Victim’s family to sue Georgian TV for report about “Russian invasion”

The family of a Georgian man who died after watching a falsified report about a Russian invasion on Imedi television has filed a demand to the Prosecutor General’s Office to launch an investigation into the case.

Irakli Okruashvili (AFP Photo / Vano Shlamov) 20.03.2009, 16:15

Rebel Georgian minister going home to oust president

Irakli Okruashvili, an ex-minister under President Mikhail Saakashvili who turned to opposition and fled the country, is planning a comeback from exile despite the 11-year jail sentence he faces in Georgia.

08.08.2009, 23:12 15 comments

Silence of the lambs: US girl recounts effort to tell the truth about August war

US girl trapped in Tskhinval during last year’s war between Russian and Georgian forces experienced a different sort of hostility when she attempted to “tell the truth” to western media.

Saakashvili opens propaganda monument to “freedom fighters”

Published: 27 May, 2010, 14:14
Edited: 10 July, 2010, 20:50

Image from newsgeorgia.ru

Image from newsgeorgia.ru

TAGS: Conflict, Georgia, Politics, Mass media


On Wednesday, Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili unveiled the country’s tallest monument. The “Tower of Heroes” is in honor of the soldiers who died for independence – but only to the ones who fought against Russia.

The 48-meter-high structure of metal and plastic has golden engravings of almost 3,500 names. Many plaques are left blank, and new names will probably be added in the future. In a solemn speech, Saakashvili, the mastermind behind the tower’s concept, said he is prepared to have his name on the monument, and every true Georgian should be too.

Numerous critics of the Georgian president were quick to point out the Freudian overtones in the construction of the structure. It is even a few meters higher than the monument to victims of World War II in Kutaisi, which had been demolished on Saakashvili’s order in December to make way for a new parliament building, officials said.

The choice of the names engraved on the tower leaves little doubt about the propaganda nature of the new monument. The history of the Georgian state dates back many centuries, and the peak of its power in the region was between late 12th and early 13th century. But not a single name of Georgian heroes, who conquered new lands under legendary Queen Tamar or repelled invading Mongols, Ottoman Turks and Persians in the following centuries made their way on to the Tbilisi tower.

Apparently for Saakashvili, the timeline of heroism starts in 1918, with the short-lived independent Georgian Republic formed in the wake of the Russian Bolshevik revolution and the civil war. The “true heroes” praised by Tbilisi are the Georgian cadets fighting against the Red Army and members of the anti-Soviet uprising in 1924.

But also there are soldiers who participated in the disastrous attack on secessionist South Ossetia in 2008 and the 13-month-long war in Abkhazia in the early 1990s. Why would people killed while trying to squash rebellion in breakaway regions and put them under Tbilisi control be called “fighters for Georgian independence”, is a mystery. That is, unless, propaganda goals are more important than historical accuracy.

For the current Georgian government Russia is the supervillain, and, according to comic book logic, anyone fighting a supervillain is a hero. The effort to distance from the neighbour sometimes looks bizarre, for instance, when the Georgian Foreign Ministry asks other nations to call its country the Western-style “Georgia”, and not Russian-style “Gruziya”. Georgians themselves call their country “Sakartvelo,” while both variants of the name used in foreign languages have Persian roots and was adapted differently in different countries.

Ironically, back in the second half of the 18th century, the Russian Empire was viewed by the kingdoms, which used to be parts of a united Georgia, as an ally against Ottomans and Persians. Both powers had a record of invading and occupying the lands, taking captives as slaves and pillaging settlements. At the same time, Russia was a Christian nation with culture similar to that in Georgia, and it needed allies and footholds in the region for the future war with Turkey.

Certainly, the transition of Georgia under Russia’s control was far from being smooth. Georgians had reasons to complain about Russia’s insufficient military support, promised to them by the Treaty of Georgievsk – which made eastern Georgia a protectorate – while the Bagrationi royal family was eventually dethroned despite previous agreements. On the other hand, both Georgian nobility and clergy were given a rightful place in the Russian Empire and not oppressed. Anyway, it was Russia which managed to re-unite the former kingdom.

By depicting modern Russia as a sinister and greedy would-be empire, which had been conspiring to expand and rob its provinces – Georgia included – for all its history, Saakashvili goes against truth. Saying that Georgians and Russians had no conflicts in their history would be ridiculous, but the same can be said about any two neighbour countries. Saying that they had no good things between them is just as wrong. Conflict rhetoric may win political points today, but at the same it poisons the future, making reconciliation harder to achieve.

+3 (16 votes)
 
Back to top
next MORE NEWS
RIA Novosti 26.05.2010, 17:29 3 comments

Shirkers & slackers may be kicked out of State Duma

Russian lawmakers might face harsh punishment for not attending parliamentary sessions without a good reason. The issue came to surface following a scandalous video report shown by a Russian TV channel.

27.05.2010, 16:01 5 comments

Ukraine: NATO membership is off the agenda

Joining NATO has been taken off Ukraine’s agenda, Foreign Minister Konstantin Grishchenko has announced. However, Kiev is going to continue developing relations with the alliance.

jsmith May 30, 2010, 19:05
0

this monument won't stand the test of time, perhaps when saakashvili's regime collapses, and a pragmatic leadership comes to Georgia, they will leave this monument as a "gorey reminder" of an oppressive Georgian leader, just as in another Georgian town, there is a "Gori reminder" of another Georgian leader who brutalised millions. Also, many Georgians died in WW2, and the collective memory of their brave sacrifice is something that can't be "knocked down" by an egotistical maniac.(Saakashvili)

Impera May 29, 2010, 01:35
0

I too also fully agree with you Gazza you have hi the bullseye with your statement. This is yet another piece of a large network of "Brainwashing" Georgians about their history, and quiet literally spitting on their own legacy at the same time, the world seriously needs to question themselves about doing business with Saakashvili's Georgia, I fully respect Georgian's legacies from which they first was in their inception. But it's a real shame that one person especially a Georgian would desecrate this. I can only offer my most sincerest respect and sympathy to the civilians and history and Georgian's themselves not Saakashvili's Georgians. I'am so happy and glad that Both Abkhazia and South Ossetia are officially free from this mad man as in the long term will become a detriment to Georgia's future. As for this monument I find it to be a complete abomination and should have never been erected and built, as it holds no historical value, Just simply madness. Russia and Georgia have always had differences in the past and present but when the Soviet Union merged these two entities they were as one entity but when the Soviet Union collapsed both countries had their own mutual economical and political problems and deficits and I would have though that being former brothers in arms from Post-Soviet era they would have at least banded together not fight each other, for which at least enemies would have respect for each other. I suppose the only way forward for Georgia is to finally see the end of Saakashvili's regime once and for all as it has lasted for far too long and has prevented Georgia to be proud of their History and enjoy their culture, and thus be all a Georgian can be and that is free of Tyranny

Razkolnik May 28, 2010, 04:03
-1

Finally a quite balanced and well written article against Saakashvili. Especially by the end. My repspects to the author!