Keep up with the news by installing RT’s extension for . Never miss a story with this clean and simple app that delivers the latest headlines to you.

 

EU justice chief accuses bloc of hypocrisy in data privacy debates

Published time: January 29, 2014 01:05
European Union Commissioner for Justice Viviane Reding (AFP Photo / Frederick Florin)

European Union Commissioner for Justice Viviane Reding (AFP Photo / Frederick Florin)

The EU needs to start protecting its own citizens from the American global spying initiatives and quit being “hypocritical” when it comes to reforming its own data protection system, said the EU’s Justice Commissioner.

Viviane Reding, a vocal critic of American cyber surveillance, lashed out against EU member states’ reaction in wake of Edward Snowden revelations, urging the bloc to protect citizens’ private information and seek more legal assurances from Washington.

“There's been a lot of hypocrisy in the debate,” Reding said at the Centre for European Policy Studies in Brussels on Tuesday. “If the EU wants to be credible in its efforts to rebuild trust, if it wants to act as an example for other continents, it also has to get its own house in order.”

The EU itself should also look carefully at some of its [data protection] laws. Neither the Commission, the Council, nor the European Parliament can be proud of the Data Retention Directive.”

The Directive requires telecom companies to store all telephony metadata, including geo-location data. Criticizing some aspects of the Directive, Reding said that the data “is kept for too long, it is too easily accessed and the risk of abuse is too great.”

AFP Photo
“One cannot simply use ‘national security’ as a trump card and disregard citizens' rights. That is what others used to do. The European Data Retention law needs a health check. The EU Charter of Fundamental Rights is the medicine,” she told the audience in Brussels.

EU member states are currently engaged in negotiations on a new data protection law which would require companies like Google, Facebook, or Twitter to ask for permission from authorities before using personal information. But governments have yet to agree on the wording as the EU Parliament threatens to block the law if privacy concerns are not properly addressed.

In particular, Reding criticized Britain over its role in helping the US spy overseas, warning that if allegations of the UK’s involvement in intercepting and storing personal data from fibre optic cables were true, she would launch “infringement proceedings”. While stating that EU has no power over its member’s national security operations, Reding called for a strong response.

“If I come across a single email, a single piece of evidence that the TEMPORA program [British spy agency GCHQ surveillance program] is not used purely for national security purposes, I will launch infringement proceedings. The mass collection of personal data is unacceptable.”

The European Commission wrote a letter to the UK government expressing its concerns about the scope of the TEMPORA program. The response was evidently not what Brussels had anticipated.

“The response was short: ‘Hands off, this is national security’,” Reding said.

At the same time, the EU’s justice chief urged the US to provide more legal safeguards to strengthen the Safe Harbour data privacy agreement. If such provisions were not met, Reding warned she would work to suspend the agreement that allows companies that gather consumer information in Europe to send it to the United States.

“For Safe Harbour to be fully roadworthy the US will have to service it,” she said. “Safe Harbour has to be strengthened or it will be suspended.”

Commenting on the latest leak that implicated the NSA and its UK counterpart, GCHQ, to have the ability to harvest sensitive personal data from phone apps that transmit users’ data across the web, such as the extremely popular Angry Birds game, Reding said:

“Now I know why the ‘Angry birds’ look so angry. Often with applications, the rule is 'take it or leave it'. That’s when trust evaporates. That's when people feel forced to part with their privacy.”

Reding also drew on the interconnected issues of data collection by private firms and spying activities by governments.

“Backdoors have been built, encryption has been weakened. Concerns about government surveillance drive consumers away from digital services.”


Private data should not be kept forever simply because storage has become cost-effective, Reding said. “Data should not be processed simply because algorithms are refined. Safeguards should apply and citizens should have rights.”

Comments (12)

 

Jason Bedard 29.01.2014 19:04

All these governments are aware that the data is collected and how the systems do it. They can easily remove the data collection portion of the systems without interfering with the Message and Data processing components. Their refusal to do so is by default cooperation with the NSA. 80% of the worlds systems use one manufacturer HP for MP, DP and DIH (Data Intelligence Harvester). They could easily remove the DIH blade server in slot 15 and the SAN blade in slot 16 that stores the data without interruption. They could easily remove the DR bond from the Cisco 3120 to the off site collection but still refuse to do so.

 

Freaky 29.01.2014 16:54

I realize more and more that Edward Snowden is a real hero on the age of 29 where he was sucesful and could live in wealth, his consious tells him that what he was doing for NSA was not right for humanity he choose to put his life up site down and inform the people of the world
The US barbarians always blames other countries about humanrights, and want Snowden dead and frustating Mr Putin with homo propaganda
Major ity of the Russians do not like homo's period
And that is their good right Who are we to tell them what is right or wrong
35 years ago Europe hypocrits forgot Europe also where beat and humiliated his homo's

 

Freaky 29.01.2014 16:37

Nice try miss Reding, but I think NSA will come after you or they will have their lobbyist to hypnotize you that it is not that bad.

View all comments (12)
Add comment

Authorization required for adding comments

Register or

Name

Password

Show password

Register

or Register

Request a new password

Send

or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:

OK

or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile

X

Name

New password

Retype new password

Current password

Save

Cancel

Follow us

Follow us