Keep up with the news by installing RT’s extension for . Never miss a story with this clean and simple app that delivers the latest headlines to you.


EU inquiry draft finds NSA, GCHQ activities ‘illegal’ – report

Published time: January 09, 2014 23:36
Satellite dishes are seen at GCHQ's outpost at Bude, close to where trans-Atlantic fibre-optic cables come ashore in Cornwall, southwest England June 23, 2013.(Reuters / Kieran Doherty)

Satellite dishes are seen at GCHQ's outpost at Bude, close to where trans-Atlantic fibre-optic cables come ashore in Cornwall, southwest England June 23, 2013.(Reuters / Kieran Doherty)

An EU parliamentary inquiry condemns “unprecedented” and “indiscriminate” mass data gathering by US and British agencies, calling for the practice to stop and questioning its legality, according to a draft committee report obtained by the Guardian.

The 51-page draft report prepared by the European parliament’s civil liberties committee’s rapporteur, British MEP Claude Moraes, has in the “strongest possible terms” condemned mass surveillance activities of the US National Security Agency (NSA) and its British counterpart, Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ).

The document is still being discussed and has not been voted on yet. However, the draft clearly calls on the US, the UK and European governments to halt the collection of data that the intelligence agencies gather on “an unprecedented scale and in an indiscriminate and non-suspicion-based manner,” and to safeguard their citizens against mass surveillance by the letter of law.

The report calls on US authorities and EU states to “prohibit blanket mass surveillance activities and bulk processing of personal data,” saying it is “very doubtful” that the collection of information on the perceived is only guided by the fight against terrorism. The inquiry further questions the “legality, necessity and proportionality” of the programs.

Despite the international uproar surrounding the revelations of former NSA contractor Edward Snowden and demands to clarify the alleged spying activities voiced at a top diplomatic level, rapporteur Moraes notes that the intelligence agencies “have declined to co-operate with the inquiry the European parliament has been conducting on behalf of citizens.”

The US must revise its laws governing the activities of intelligence services and bring them into line with the international law, so that they “recognize the privacy and other rights of EU citizens,” the report stresses.

The UK, Germany, France, Sweden and the Netherlands must also revise relevant laws to ensure they are in line with the European convention on human rights, the draft document demands.

The “chilling” way journalists publishing Snowden’s revelations have been intimidated by state authorities is also addressed by the EU inquiry. Not only might mass surveillance have severe effect on the freedom of the press, it also might be abused to gather information against political opponents, Moraes writes.

In all, the draft version of the report delivers 116 findings and recommendations.

Meanwhile, the EU parliamentary committee’s MEPs on Thursday voted overwhelmingly to have Snowden testify from Russia via video-link despite warnings from senior US congressmen that giving the “felon” a public platform would damage the EU body’s reputation and hamper the EU’s cooperation with Washington.

Snowden is expected to provide evidence in the coming weeks, according to the Guardian.

Only two members of the committee, both British Conservatives, voted against letting Snowden speak at the hearing, criticizing Snowden’s actions.

”Snowden has endangered lives. Inviting him at all is a highly irresponsible act by an inquiry that has had little interest in finding out facts and ensuring a balanced approach to this delicate issue," Tory MEP Timothy Kirkhope said. "At least if Snowden wants to give evidence, he will now have to come out of the shadows and risk his location being discovered.”

Others defended Snowden’s role as a whistleblower. MEP Jan-Philipp Albrecht from the Green group stated that Snowden should no longer be considered a criminal.

"Snowden has brought this all to light. I think it's very clear after this inquiry how huge this scandal is and that we would never have heard about it if Edward Snowden hadn't taken this step,” Albrecht told DW.

Comments (16)


fox bravo 12.07.2014 13:12

It is obvious also that the EU is an even bigger danger to the English Speaking World, with its megger-buck funding of cry-babby bleeding-heart politicaly motimated NGOs Time for ENGLAND to leave and the EU to implodfe on itself. Once the real crisis comes the German State's Jackboot will not stop the rising tide of revolt. Only when Germany is reduced back to it's 1945 state of rubble will peace return. Only this time there will no "rich Yanks" to stop the march of progressive forces right to the Atlantic shore and not Facists but Socalist will have won the argument permenently in Europe, no EU!.


fox bravo 12.07.2014 13:00

Mr. Snowden has endangered no one other than American and British pride. And it is time he was given a high profile “Prime Time” platform hopefully beamed around the world in real time. As far as giving his location away; I am quite certain the Russians Security Service are as good at at protecting him now as the KGB in the Soviet era, were at protecting their agents “The Cambridge Ring” ;who penetrated right to the heart of the British establishment Conservatives all.
Time for the EU to find GCHQ and NSA "illegal organizations" and have them disbanded.


fox bravo 12.07.2014 12:47

Snowden has done us the ordinary folk a big favor in blowing the lid off the cesspit that is Western that is USUKCANAUSNZ intelligence in the post-Soviet era. And deserves the highest award for risking life and limb to bring the toxic knowledge to public view. As the target make no mistake is not some Allebaba but you, a WASP, member of the British public.And it is not aimed at our foreign enemys but at you; be you a Trade Unionist, H2S, Fracking, or Badger Cull Protester; your the target. And ever more so as Britain disintegrates culturally, becoming ever more the disunited kingdom., and facist police state.

View all comments (16)
Add comment

Authorization required for adding comments

Register or



Show password


or Register

Request a new password


or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:


or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile



New password

Retype new password

Current password



Follow us

Follow us