Wrong language means no medical help?
Published: 03 November, 2009, 02:22
Edited: 03 November, 2009, 15:25
TAGS: Conflict, Health, Scandal, EU, Human rights
In Tallinn, the capital of Estonia, a regional hospital doctor refused treatment to a Russian-speaking patient who could not explain his symptoms in the country’s official language.
According to the Novosti.err.ee portal, Dmitry Smolnikov, a diver, had approached the hospital after receiving a jaw injury during an unsuccessful plunge. Smolnikov waited to be seen by the oral surgeon for three weeks.
When he finally got an appointment, he entered the doctor’s office and tried to explain his condition in Russian. He was then requested to speak Estonian.
“Overall, I understand what people say, but I would be unable to explain my condition using medical terminology in Estonian,” Smolnikov later explained to journalists.
His attempts to come to terms with the surgeon were fruitless. So was his girlfriend Ekaterina’s attempts to ameliorate the situation. The young woman addressed the doctor in Estonian, yet he still refused to perform his duty.
According to Dmitry and Ekaterina, the doctor called them “pigs” and advised them to “get out of Estonia.”
Now, the clinic’s patients are planning to take the case to court. They found out at the clinic’s registry that there have been a number of similar complaints against the surgeon.
The doctor himself, as well as the clinic employing him, are refusing to comment on the situation.
02.11.2009, 23:09
2 comments
Ukraine pleads for help as flu epidemic spreadsUkrainian President Victor Yushchenko has called on the international community to help the country combat the swine flu epidemic which hit the country last week. Kiev is taking emergency measures to stop the outbreak. |
Remaining Arctic Sea crew back homeThe last four sailors who remained on board the hijacked Arctic Sea vessel have returned to their home base in northern Russia. |












I think the Estonian media did a good job of covering this controversy. It was a top story in both major news dailies. It's too bad, though, that these are the only kinds of stories about Estonia that Russia Today runs. Its either "rewriting history" or "infringing the rights of Russian speakers." Those must be the only two talking points provided by the Russian Foreign Ministry.