Keep up with the news by installing RT’s extension for . Never miss a story with this clean and simple app that delivers the latest headlines to you.


Free speech banned: Student group sues 4 US universities that ‘stifle dissent’

Published time: July 02, 2014 14:28
AFP Photo / Getty Images / Max Whittaker

AFP Photo / Getty Images / Max Whittaker

Arguing that free speech is suffering at colleges across the US, an advocacy group filed lawsuits against four universities, seeking to strengthen the rights guaranteed by the Constitution.

The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) has filed lawsuits against four schools – Iowa State University, Ohio University, Chicago University and Citrus College in Glendora, California – that it says disrupt the flow of free speech in a number of ways, including the banning of particular T-shirts, for example, or by refusing to permit certain speakers address the student body on controversial issues.

According to the group’s estimate, about 60 percent of public universities and colleges have restrictions on rights guaranteed by the First Amendment.

The four lawsuits were filed partially in response to a rise in student protests against scheduled commencement speakers, some of whom canceled their appearances.

Condoleezza Rice, former US Secretary of State, for example, declined an invitation to speak at the Rutgers University commencement this year, following student protests against her appearance in connection with the hugely unpopular war in Iraq.

Former US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice (AFP Photo / Paul J. Richards)

In an open letter to the president of the school, printed in the student paper The Daily Targum on April 30, "Rutgers Student Protestors" cited "destruction" in Iraq "at the hands of the Bush administration."

"These are clearly human rights issues. By inviting her to speak and awarding her an honorary degree, we are encouraging and perpetuating a world that justifies torture and debases humanity," the letter said.

In another filing, Vincenzo Sinapi-Riddle alleged that Citrus College, California had violated his First Amendment rights by limiting his petitioning actions to a small "free-speech zone" in the campus quad.

According to Sinapi-Riddle's lawsuit, campus authorities prevented him last fall from speaking to another student about his campaign against surveillance by the National Security Agency, saying he had wandered beyond the free-speech zone.

"It was shocking to me that there could be so much hostility about me talking to another student peacefully about government spying," Sinapi-Riddle told the Los Angeles Times. "My vision of college was to express what I think."

According to FIRE, many American institutions of higher learning have acquired arbitrary policies that give administrators and some student groups the power to remove all sorts of political debate and satire from the campus.

The lawsuits allege that both Iowa State University and Ohio University banned T-shirts deemed inappropriate to campus officials; Chicago State University attempted to block a faculty blog; and Citrus College in Glendora, Calif., set up a free-speech zone where a student could collect signatures for a petition.

The Philadelphia-based advocacy group said such an approach to free speech at colleges and universities is setting a dangerous precedent.

“We’re cultivating an intellectually unhealthy attitude that it is not OK, or even dangerous, to hear opinions that might make you uncomfortable,” Greg Lukianoff, the president of the group, said as quoted by the New York Times. “Universities have been much too shy in saying that there’s a great educational benefit from hearing dissent.

“You have a whole generation of people who think that they should be protected from anything they see as unwanted or disagreeable.”

Legal action is also being taken against Iowa State University and Ohio University, who are accused of banning certain T-shirts deemed offensive.

The group has met with success in the past in similar lawsuits, including one last year against Modesto Junior College in California, after faculty members told a student he was forbidden from passing out copies of the US Constitution outside the college’s “free-speech zone.”

In addition to removing the zone, the college settled the lawsuit for $50,000.

Comments (14)


Kenneth T. Tellis 06.07.2014 21:10

America's long journey of a freedom struggle from Lexington Green to its present stand means that there is no FREEDOM and you can be imprisoned without any charges being laid against you. Thus American Independence has become a farce!


Kenneth T. Tellis 06.07.2014 21:05

This is not so different from a vacationing lawyer in New York being arrested by a security guard for wearing a T-Shirt with GIVE PEACE A CHANCE written on it. Then there was the student expelled from a Michigan high school with a picture of George W, Bush War Criminal written on it. The USA is NOT nor EVER was a democracy, it is a Rightist REPUBLIC, which has taken away Constitutional Rights from all its citizens.


Doc 05.07.2014 14:08

Nigel Hedley 03.07.2014 15:46

. . . this is what you get when you have a written constitution . . . in addition to clowns massacring school children with the guns they have right to carry we have idiots who think that freedom of speech means you can say what you want irrespective of the effect it might have . . . freedom of speech equals freedom to offend but that does not include shouting fire in a crowded cinema!


P.S. Chicago has the strictest gun laws in the US and they have the HIGHEST murder rate.....Go figure :-)

View all comments (14)
Add comment

Authorization required for adding comments

Register or



Show password


or Register

Request a new password


or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:


or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile



New password

Retype new password

Current password



Follow us

Follow us