Keep up with the news by installing RT’s extension for . Never miss a story with this clean and simple app that delivers the latest headlines to you.


Will California prison hunger strike lead to Gitmo-style force-feeding?

Published time: July 15, 2013 20:04
California Department of Corrections officer looks on inmates (AFP Photo / Getty Images / Kevork Djansezian)

California Department of Corrections officer looks on inmates (AFP Photo / Getty Images / Kevork Djansezian)

Amid a massive hunger-strike being waged across the state of California by thousands of prisoners in several facilities, officials may move to begin force-feeding inmates if it could prevent a larger uprising from occurring.

California is one of only three states where prison physicians are barred from using force-feeding in instances where inmates refuse to eat, but ProPublica journalist Christie Thompson has noted that the courts there have also allowed for an exception in the event that not intervening might cause chaos to unfold within a facility.

Now one week after prisoners at 22 state prisons and four out-of-state facilities started refusing meals, officials could consider taking the route that physicians have adopted at the Guantanamo Bay detention facility.

The California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation only recognizes a fasting streak as a hunger-strike if inmates forego nine consecutive meals. The Los Angeles Times reported Sunday afternoon that the number of prisoners who have reached that point has dwindled down to 4,487 from the original 30,000 inmates involved in the strike one week earlier. As calls for reform within the California prison system continue, though, officials could see inmates — even in dire numbers — neglecting to eat in the coming weeks.

And although the California Correctional Health Care Services’ director of legislation told ProPublica that “Force-feeding inmates is not part of our medical protocol,” a provision within established law leads room for the CDCR to start ordering those procedures to take place if it’s imperative to the safety of the prison.

A 1993 decision made by the State Supreme Court ruled that a paralyzed inmate could “decline life-sustaining treatment, even if to do so will cause or hasten death,” paving the way for a provision that today keeps officials from intervening right away in any attempts to protest. Elsewhere in that ruling, though, the court ruled, “In another case, or in this case if a change of circumstances warrant, we do not preclude prison authorities from establishing the need to override an inmate’s choice to decline medical intervention.”

“A custodial environment is uniquely susceptible to the catalytic effect of disruptive conduct,” the ruling continued, “and courts will not interfere with reasonable measures required to forestall such untoward consequences.”

In other words, the decision stated, authorities can intervene with medical treatment “when otherwise health prisoner’s attempt to starve himself threatened prison disciple and security.”

However, such measures must be demonstrable ‘reasonable’ and necessary,” not a matter of conjecture.

According to ProPublica’s Thompson, the prison officials might reach such a conclusion should they feel threatened by the current strike. Isaac Ontiveros, a spokesperson with the Prisoner Hunger Strike Solidarity Network, told Thompson that “It doesn’t need to come to that,” though, adding prison officials “can end this very, very simply.”

It’s a little bit of bad press if you force-feed inmates,” bioethicist Dr. Jacob Appel added to Thompson’s report. “It’s a lot of bad press if you have a lot of protesting inmates and one of them dies.”

As of Sunday evening, strikes were continuing in 23 California prisons and one out-of-state prison. According to the LA Times, 731 inmates have also refused to go to work or class.

Inmates at the facilities have released a list of demands to the prison asking for, among other requests, an end to the state’s practice of holding inmates suspected of internal gang involvement in isolation indefinitely.

Comments (34)


Nancy Valentin 19.08.2013 01:57

Force feeding? Really cant u people admit that the system is a fucked up one?its ran by crooked as fucken cops and the leader! Aint non of u know or know somebody that is going thru this! Bet all u loosers have medical or ss and they dnt have the right to get a half desent medical or releass people from shu...people die! Their deprived of vitamins a body recieves from son!!! Free!!! Communication!!! Should be a must!!! And guess what all u tight assed probably unemployed loosers the best things in life are needed and free!!!!

Anonymous user 20.07.2013 02:27

RT will not allow a comment they restrict the number of words because they have a control neurosis

Anonymous user 18.07.2013 19:13

The way out of torture is paved with broken doctors!
Patient s' Front

View all comments (34)
Add comment

Authorization required for adding comments

Register or



Show password


or Register

Request a new password


or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:


or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile



New password

Retype new password

Current password



Follow us

Follow us