Keep up with the news by installing RT’s extension for . Never miss a story with this clean and simple app that delivers the latest headlines to you.

 

Woman claims discrimination against atheists in NJ license plate lawsuit

Published time: April 18, 2014 23:48
Edited time: April 19, 2014 04:01
Photo by Thomas Anderson / flickr.com

Photo by Thomas Anderson / flickr.com

A New Jersey woman is suing the state’s Motor Vehicle Commission for denying her attempt to keep God off her vanity license plate by proclaiming her atheism.

The defendant in the case, Shannon Morgan, attempted to purchase a vanity plate from the MVC website in November 2013, entering “8THEIST” as her desired personalization, according to the lawsuit filed in federal court on Thursday. But the website denied her request, stating, “Requested plate text is considered objectionable.”

The complaint says that Morgan then decided to experiment with other, more religious requests.

“Confused about why the Commission considered her proposed plate objectionable, Ms. Morgan entered 'BAPTIST' and discovered that the website did not flag this proposal as ‘objectionable.’ Instead, it displayed a preview of a personalized license plate reading 'BAPTIST' and permitted her to continue the application.”

Morgan then attempted to contact the MVC to inquire as to why the “8THEIST” plate was rejected and to ask for help in obtaining the plate. At this point, MVC employees gave her the runaround, according to the suit. Finally, Morgan sent the agency a certified letter reiterating her desire to obtain the vanity plate and find out why it had been deemed objectionable. She received no response.

Because the state did not find a potential “BAPTIST” plate objectionable, the suit says, Morgan believes that the state therefore favors religion over non-belief, which discriminates against atheists like herself.

The executive director of Americans United for Separation of Church and State (AU), the Rev. Barry W. Lynn, agreed. “The state of New Jersey is favoring religion while disparaging non-belief. It simply has no right to do that,” he said in a statement. “This license plate issue may seem like a small matter but it is indicative of a much larger problem – atheists are often treated by the government as second-class citizens.”

AU is an advocacy group based in Washington, DC that is representing Morgan in the lawsuit against Raymond Martinez, the chair of the New Jersey MVC.

“This isn’t a frivolous lawsuit. All the MVC had to do was say ‘yes’ to the plate — or provide a compelling reason when saying ‘no.’ They did neither,” blogger Hemant Mehta wrote on the Friendly Atheist. “Since MVC officials research all vanity plates before approving them, this isn’t just a computer glitch. Someone thinks ‘atheist’ is a dirty, offensive, objectionable word.”

This is not the first time the New Jersey MVC has faced allegations of discrimination against atheists. In August 2013, David Silverman, president of American Atheists, said the MVC rejected his request for an “ATHE1ST” plate, sending a letter that called the term “objectionable.” When Silverman tried to clarify what this meant, an employee allegedly told him that the proposed license plate was “offensive.”

Silverman filed an appeal with the MVC, and was soon notified that the state of New Jersey had reversed its ruling and would allow the “ATHE1ST” license plate. MVC Spokeswoman Elyse Coffey blamed the initial decision on a clerical error, arguing that a clerk exceeded her authority by calling the proposed plate offensive.

The lawsuit notes that the occurrence of two rejections of similar vanity plates within three months of each other shows discrimination against atheists and expresses a preference by the state for religion over atheism.

“The New Jersey Motor Vehicle Commission’s actions are mean-spirited and derogatory,” Ayesha N. Khan, the AU’s legal director, said in the statement. “They’re also unconstitutional because the government cannot endorse belief over non-belief.”

Morgan is requesting she be allowed the “8THEIST” vanity plate and asks that the MVC “adopt and implement a regulatory scheme that requires any restriction of expression on personalized license plates to be based on specific, objective, viewpoint-neutral criteria,” the lawsuit states.

Sandy Grossman, a spokesperson for the New Jersey MVC, told NJ.com, “We review every request personally...and we review them for anything that’s offensive [or] objectionable.” She said that officials research the meaning of each request, and those officials send a letter to the requestor if they are unsure of the meaning.

Comments (11)

 

Orlando Silva 21.04.2014 14:31

Fyodor Shapirovski 20.04.2014 01:06

Actually, atheists are easier to control. That's why communist and totalitarian regimes like the Soviet Union encouraged it. Without religion, there is nothing for the people to believe in which the government can make its people believe whatever they want. In fact, most of the time the church and believers oppose the government..

  



Well actually, an example that counter acts that is the American revolution many of the founding fathers preferred science over religion, one of those being Benjamin franklin of course, so id have to disagree

 

Steven Nodlehs 20.04.2014 08:41

Isn't everyone an atheist - you either don't pray to God or you pray to an imaginary one.

Unless someone can prove there's a specific God then they are only enlightened atheists and gullible ignorant ones.

 

DoAskDoTell 20.04.2014 05:04

bubbles of out-of-work lawyers?

bu bbles of trust-fund people with no idea what to do with themselves?

gov to dictate "religious freedom"?

*corporatist religion* to dictate "religious freedom"?

We are supposed to "follow" the "winner" as numbskulls? LOL

View all comments (11)
Add comment

Authorization required for adding comments

Register or

Name

Password

Show password

Register

or Register

Request a new password

Send

or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:

OK

or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile

X

Name

New password

Retype new password

Current password

Save

Cancel

Follow us

Follow us