Keep up with the news by installing RT’s extension for . Never miss a story with this clean and simple app that delivers the latest headlines to you.


​Facebook sued for alleged monitoring of users’ private messages

Published time: January 03, 2014 01:10
Edited time: January 05, 2014 15:59
Reuters / Thomas Hodel

Reuters / Thomas Hodel

Social media giant Facebook is being sued for the alleged monitoring of its users’ private messages in order to gather more consumer data that it in turn shares with marketers.

A federal lawsuit filed Thursday in San Jose, California alleges that Facebook traces the contents of users’ private messages, including links to other websites, "to improve its marketing algorithms and increase its ability to profit from data about Facebook users,” The Los Angeles Times reported.

A link to another site is read as a “like” of that website. The information contributes to a comprehensive profile on the user’s activity that is collected by Facebook and that eventually becomes material for targeted advertising, the lawsuit claims.

Two plaintiffs are seeking a class action suit on behalf of all Facebook users who have sent or received a private message in the past two years that contained links.

The allegations are “without merit,” said Facebook spokeswoman Jackie Rooney.

"We will defend ourselves vigorously," she told the LA Times in an emailed statement.

Hackers News was first to surface Facebook’s supposed practice of scanning private messages and converting links to “likes” in 2012.

Two weeks ago, a new study showed that Facebook records everything users type on the social networking site, including notes they choose to delete instead of posting.

Adam Kramer, a data scientist employed by the social network, studied the profiles of 3.9 million people for the study, dubbed “Self-Censorship on Facebook.” Kramer viewed activity on each profile by monitoring its HTML form element, which is made up of HTML code that changes whenever a user types in their Facebook chat, status update, or other areas where they speak to others.

While Facebook claims it does not track the words that are written in each box, the company is able to determine when characters are typed, how many words are typed, and whether they are posted or deleted. Kramer, with help from student Sauvik Das, spent 17 days tracking “aborted status updates, posts on other people’s timelines, and comments on other posts.”

The social network site does offer opt-outs for certain advertising features, such as whether a user’s consumer brand likes are shared with others and, perhaps tellingly, the ability to opt out of any future decision to allow third-party sites to use a user’s name or picture in advertisements.

Facebook - which is again expected to pay no federal taxes this year - is not alone among major tech companies facing lawsuits that claim privacy violations. Google has been sued in federal court, accused of illegally accessing the contents of email sent through its Gmail service, a violation of US wiretapping law.

Also earlier this month, documents leaked by former NSA contractor Edward Snowden revealed that the National Security Agency has quietly subverted the tools used by online advertising companies in order to track surveillance targets and improve its monitoring ability.

Comments (21)


Austin Bodetti 25.07.2014 23:37



Chassie Leigh Chapmond 06.03.2014 05:25

I live in the states. Facebook is certainly invading our privacy and watching our private messages. My Boyfriend sent me a picture we thought was quite funny but it was not appropriate to post to Facebook itself as it contained nudity. No where in the terms does it say you cannot send in private messages things that you cannot post. Lo and behold, he was banned from posting to Facebook for 7 days because of the picture he sent me in private message. Yes I do use Facebook Messenger to text a lot. Its ridiculous that not I cannot even have a conversation on PM without being watched and possibly banned.


Mike Hauben 04.01.2014 05:48

Unfortunately, they can't win this lawsuit. Its a very different issue than what happened with Snowden, because we never authorized the government to spy on us and monitor us. It was complete spying on our rights. This is different, because we actually sign up and use Facebook on their terms. Its in the agreement when making a profile. They're allowing you to use their Facebook service in exchange for your info, etc. Its not a free service, you're paying with your info. They'll easily win this lawsuit.

View all comments (21)
Add comment

Authorization required for adding comments

Register or



Show password


or Register

Request a new password


or Register

To complete a registration check
your Email:


or Register

A password has been sent to your email address

Edit profile



New password

Retype new password

Current password



Follow us

Follow us